Intro   Accueil   English

 

     Nouvelles

     Biographie

     Discographie

     Concerts

     Presse
          Concerts
                 2013
                 2012
                 2011
                 2010
                 2009
          Opéras
          Disques
          Entrevues

     Médias

     Galerie

     Information

 
Concerts  |  Opéras  |  Disques  |  Entrevues
2013 | 2012 | 2011 | 2010 | 2009...

Orchestre de Philadelphie
Verizon Hall, Philadelphie
3, 4 et 5 décembre 2009

Broad Street review 6 janvier 2010  

In defense of leisurely pacing

“The 34-year-old conductor from Montreal, Yannick Nézet-Séguin led this piece beautifully at last week’s Philadelphia Orchestra concerts. He took the opening (Franck’s Symphony) slowly and gently and let the music unfold with nuance and expressiveness. The Philadelphians sounded at their considerable best with rich lower strings, lower woodwinds and brass set off against frequent soft plucking by the violins.”

“The pacing was relaxed but never lost momentum, and the climaxes rang out dramatically. “

“The pacing of that classic (Brahms Piano Concerto No. 1) was, again, leisurely, but it never dragged. I found it to be quite engaging, as was Angelich’s calm, untheatrical persona at the keyboard.”

“Orion (from Vivier) was fun, with some jazz influence ... and exotic percussion effects.”

“I hope to hear much more of him with this orchestra in the future. Meanwhile, I’m running up to New York to hear him conduct a new production of Carmen at the Metropolitan Opera in January.”
Steve Cohen   

Philadelphia Inquirer 5 décembre 2009  

Making others look good. Nézet-Séguin stands out by standing back

“Of all the paradoxes: Conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin became the hero of his own concert by ceding the spotlight to all around him, making them look terrific”

“Nézet-Séguin's strengths include solid pragmatism that makes the music work as an architectural entity, fired by less-tangible inspiration that makes you care about the whole package. Even the oft-heard incidental solos in the Brahms took on a new meaning while helping Angelich make a case for his slowness.”

(In the Franck) “Nézet-Séguin went for maximum tempo  and volume contrast, plus vivid instrumental colors in sections that cross-cut so dramatically that the performance had an almost cinematic quality. Smartest of all, he defied the composer's Wagnerian tendencies, dividing normally serpentine melodies into discrete sections that had different things to say.”

(In the Vivier) “As someone used to Germanic performances, I was thrilled to hear so much mystery and hard-to-identify sound in Nézet-Séguin's coloristically astute, emotionally anchored performance, from a muted trombone solo to vocalizing that sounded like a Muslim call to prayer but was actually percussionist Don Liuzzi's voice bouncing off a gong.”
David Patrick Stearns   
 

Orchestre Métropolitain de Montréal
Salle Wilfrid-Pelletier, Montréal
9 novembre 2009

The Gazette 11 novembre 2009  

“Yannick's Schumann takes flight.”

“ The performance was fully prepared, yet spontaneous in effect. Nimble exchanges between strings and winds justly reflected the composer's (Schuman) capricious mind. The Scherzo, at high velocity, was a virtuoso statement and the finale had a joyous "fanfare" sound.”
Arthur Kaptainis   
 

Orchestre de Chambre d’Europe
Stadtcasino Basel, Bâle
28 octobre 2009

BaselKlassik.com 1er novembre 2009  

«  L’orchestre, sous la direction du jeune chef canadien Yannick Nézet-Séguin, a réussi dès le premier mouvement à mettre en valeur de façon spécialement claire les voix thématiques secondaires. »

« L’Opus ultimum symphonique de Haydn  fut interprété par Nézet-Séguin et son orchestre de chambre à la manière du romantisme tardif. Des contrastes extrêmes, un pathos un peu fou mais aussi de grandes arches façonnent la symphonie, spécialement au niveau du dynamisme très diversifié. Malgré son essence emphatique et romantique, Nézet-Séguin a réussi à faire ressortir l’esprit de Haydn et ce pleinement au sens esthétique classique. »
Toni Hildebrandt  
(Traduction libre par Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard)  

BaZ, le journal de Bâle 30 octobre 2009  

« Des cris de joie et de triomphe les ont acclamés: l’Orchestre de Chambre d’Europe et le jeune chef d’orchestre Yannick Nézet-Séguin ont enthousiasmé le public de Bâle de même que la violoniste Lisa Batiashvili.»

 « Rarement a-t-on entendu du Haydn aussi voluptueux, avec des sonorités à leur meilleur. Nézet-Séguin ne met pas l’accent sur le côté léger et humoristique de Haydn, comme plusieurs le font, mais il fait ressortir ses abîmes harmoniques. Et l’on a pu le constater également dans certains passages de Beethoven, qui fut l’ancien élève de Haydn. »

« Il est historiquement reconnu que Beethoven a dépassé son maître dans sa démarche artistique. Grâce à Yannick Nézet-Séguin, on a pu entendre cette évolution. Il façonne les passages orchestraux du concerto pour violon de Beethoven de manière romantique et chantante, en les marquant par des cordes rudes et des instruments à vent puissants. »

Jenny Berg  
(Traduction libre par Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard)  
 

Orchestre de Chambre d’Europe
Halle-aux-Grains, Toulouse
27 octobre 2009

La dépêche du midi 31 octobre 2009  

Le phénomène Yannick-Nézet Seguin

«Cinq ans après avoir effectué à Toulouse ses débuts européens à la tête de l'Orchestre national du Capitole, le jeune chef québécois n'a rien perdu de son enthousiasme communicatif. Toujours souriant lorsqu'il est au pupitre, il donne au public la même sensation de respirer avec la musique.»
Anne-Marie Chouchan  

Classic Toulouse 28 octobre 2009  


“ Dirigeant le Chamber Orchestra of Europe, le jeune et bouillant chef québécois s'exprimait dans un répertoire germanique dont il excelle à renouveler l'approche ”.
“ Après sa mémorable interprétation de la huitième symphonie de Bruckner à la tête de l'Orchestre du Capitole, le 5 avril 2007 dans cette même Halle-aux-Grains, comment ne pas admirer le grand pouvoir d’adaptation au répertoire de Yannick Nézet-Séguin. ”

“ Ainsi jouée, la dernière symphonie de Haydn, la n° 104 titrée “ Londres ”, rayonne d’une joie et d’une énergie pétillantes comme du champagne. ”

“ Le chef déploie une palette de phrasés d'une incroyable richesse. ”

“ Rien n’est laissé au hasard. L'orchestre suit sa direction (sans baguette ni partition !) avec une admirable précision et un sens étonnant du jeu collectif. Mobilité, légèreté, grâce, équilibre bien dosé des pupitres. Contrairement à ce qu'une vision 'romantique' avait établi, les cordes ne dominent plus de leur tapis confortable les interventions savoureuses des bois et des cuivres. Un vrai bonheur. ”

“ Dans le concerto pour violon et orchestre de Beethoven, l'orchestre conserve le même dynamisme et la même transparence. Il entoure d'un cocon coloré et fruité le jeu somptueux de la jeune et belle violoniste Lisa Batiashvili. ”

“ Yannick Nézet-Séguin y insuffle (Symphonie 'Reformation' de Mendelssohn) encore cette vitalité qui caractérise sa direction. Les bouffées d’énergie sont canalisées avec rigueur. ”

“ Contrastes et nuances animent le discours. Jusqu'au choral final, l'oeuvre coule comme un fleuve vers son embouchure. Du grand art ! ”

Serge Chauzy  
 

London Philharmonic Orchestra
Royal Festival Hall, Londres
24 octobre 2009

Seen and Heard, UK 28 octobre 2009  

“Nezet-Seguin has obviously studied the symphony intensely and has thought long and hard about a range of complex interpretative matters. He has also built a rare relationship/rapport with the LPO and has thoroughly rehearsed them.”

“There was grandeur, gravitas and drama here which never degenerated into grandiosity.”

“The huge build up in the first movement to the mid-movement climax, ... was managed with an absolutely rock-like ( should I say Klemperer-like?) hold on the ground bass rhythm”

“The wonderful sustainedly intense sotto voce passage which follows this climax ... was managed with a clarity I have rarely heard.”

“Previously I thought only the Vienna Philharmonic could deliver such Austrian passages authentically, but tonight Nezet-Seguin drew playing from the LPO (especially the string sections) which sounded equally at home!”

“A broad,solemn adagio which has a forward and trenchant momentum.”

“The beautiful, gradually descending coda was superbly moulded and sustained, with a particularly memorable quasi horn cadenza.”

“From the whole progression of the opening urgent rhythmic bass figures in C minor, to the blazing C major coda peroration of all preceding motives, the finale was a triumph. Nezet-Seguin managed a basic structural line throughout. But also he managed to interpolate into this line sequences of varying dynamic and harmonic contrast. Nothing sounded static or marmorial. Bruckner’s invention here (some would say over-invention) was superbly moulded into the whole.”

“In this performance I could totally empathise with the great American novelist William Gaddis's characterisation of this coda as '...rising to the heavens...' More than most conductors, Nezet-Seguin emphasised the sheer range of orchestral textures in Bruckner's score.”

Geoff Diggines  

Music OMH, London 28 octobre 2009  

“In this performance of the Eighth Symphony, in the Haas edition, Nézet-Séguin presided over an interpretation which was notable for its long-breathed, patient exposition, steady tempos and structural coherence. The Adagio alone lasted over 29 minutes. Another distinctive feature was the rich, almost saturated sound that Nézet-Séguin drew from the orchestra, not to mention the ethereally beautiful string sonorities of the Adagio's coda.”

Christian Hoskins  

The Telegraph, UK 26 octobre 2009  

“The conductor was Yannick Nézet-Séguin, who pulled off the impressive feat of conducting this immense piece from memory. Perhaps it was the freedom this gave him to think in the long-term that made his shaping of Bruckner's long paragraphs so convincing. The piece makes huge demands on the orchestra's stamina, especially the brass, but the LPO rose to the challenge magnificently. The most telling moment was the very last, when Nézet-Séguin shaded off the final chord rather than going for sheer volume. It was a canny substitute for the cathedral-like final echo the piece needs, and created a sense of something immense fading away on the air.”

Ivan Hewett  

The Times, London 27 octobre 2009  

“Yannick Nézet-Séguin directed a performance of Bruckner’s Eighth Symphony that exuberantly confirmed what an asset he is to London’s musical life.”

“From the first bars, he was reactivating the nerves and innermost fibres of the music: making us feel as though we were hearing that mysterious, circling bass theme, and those characteristic Brucknerian triplets and little cadential turns, for the first time. The LPO, too, seemed to be relishing newly minted music — imagining those plangent and elemental bird cries, experiencing that sense of rising sap as never before.”

“This was achieved not only by Nézet-Séguin’s obvious deep assimilation of the work; but also by his sheer sensitivity and authority in seeking out its proportions and judging its pacing.”

Hilary Finch   

The Guardian, UK 26 octobre 2009  

“Nézet-Séguin's curiosity about this work was inexhaustible. Every phrase, from the halting opening of the first movement to the blazing close of the last, was laden with emphasis.”

“LPO played tremendously, the brass especially rich and fine.”

Martin Kettle  

The Arts Desk.com 25 octobre 2009  

”Nézet-Séguin is undoubtedly the greatest Bruckner conductor alive today. That’s the sum of it. His performance of the Eighth – as with the Seventh earlier this year – was among the finest concert-going experiences of my life so far, attaining a level of intensity, a unity of purpose, that led one friend to wonder whether perhaps Nézet-Séguin was in fact a reincarnation of Bruckner himself.”

”There was a vitality from the off. The opening phrase lept from the anxious, fiery depths, in a clear sign that what we were about to witness was going to be very special indeed. It was this and more: spontaneous, potent and masterful. Perfection, in a word, musical lines flowing out from Nézet-Séguin as effortlessly as the air from his lungs.”

”Moments that have always seemed odd or incongruous were given new meaning and coherence. Sweep and structure, phrasing and pacing, balance and coloration were being juggled with a supreme and rightful self-confidence.”

”Never has it (the final movement) sounded so satisfying or so exciting and the audience responded by rising to give this tiny conductor a huge standing ovation.”

Igor Toronyi-Lalic  
 

The Orchestra of the Age of Enlightment
Queen Elizabeth Hall, Southbank Center, Londres
15 octobre 2009

The Times, UK 19 octobre 2009  

”Right from the start, Nézet-Séguin created a sense of a strange wanderings through mists and miasmas, so that it was impossible to guess what would come next. This sense of smiling wonder at the audacious unpredictability of Haydn, even while working in the most familiar of forms, was characteristic of the entire evening’s music-making.”

Hilary Finch  

The Independant, UK 16 octobre 2009  

“Such "novelties" sounded freshly minted under Nézet-Séguin, surely the conductor to be watching right now.”

“ There was a renewed spring in Haydn's jaunty tunes, grace and grit in the articulations, and an added robustness to those feisty developments with fiery interplay between first and second violins and arresting timpani tattoos. The way the young French-Canadian lengthened and intensified the general pause into one of Haydn's more audacious modulations could not have better demonstrated his instinctive nose for this music.”

“Most of all, though, it was the sheer vitality and joy of the OAE's playing and that communal sense of rediscovery at how these phrases turn and how individually the harmonies move beneath them.”

“The music was familiar and not. Symphony No104 "London" moved from a most imperious introduction with crisp timpani flourishes to the beery street music of the finale with its low droning horns and a jolly theme whose progress Nezet-Seguin chronicled so vividly through every section of the orchestra. The leapfrogging strings in the coda really sent the rosin flying reinforcing the feeling that even the bicentennial of Haydn's death is cause for partying.”
Edward Seckerson  
 

Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
Murci et Barcelone, Espagne
8 et 9 octobre 2009

La Opinion, Barcelona, Spain 12 octobre 2009  

“Nézet-Séguin translated everything (in Mahler’s Ninth Symphony), the totality and the details, extraordinarily well: with strength, vigour, dynamism, intensity, momentum, an overflowing energy and more-than-proven physical and mental stamina, without aggrandising or disguising the music’s tension. He did it both in the powerful sound explosions and in the most moving lyrical moments.”

“This was a magnificent version by the conductor, a name we should remember, his youth notwithstanding, and an exemplary performance by the Rotterdam Philharmonic, in its entirety an admirable ensemble.”
Enrique Bonmati  
(Traduit de l'espagnol par Bureau Mettaal)  

EI Faro, Murcia, Spain 11 octobre 2009  

“The music was so full of nuance that no one wanted it to end.”

“This was an outstanding job by an excellent orchestra and a great conductor.”

 

(Traduit de l'espagnol par Bureau Mettaal)  
 

Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
De Doelen Hall, Rotterdam
Du 1er au 4 octobre 2009

De Volkskrant 3 octobre 2009  

“There is hardly a greater contrast imaginable between György Kurtág's subdued Songs of Despair and Sorrow and Beethoven's extroverted Ninth Symphony. On Thursday, Yannick Nézet-Séguin created a bridge between these worlds. Gloominess effortlessly changed into euphoria.”

“In Beethoven's voluminous Ninth, Nézet-Séguin sustained the dark atmosphere. A raw, almost fatalistic and insistent Molto vivace succeeded a throbbing first movement.”

“A great achievement”
Lonneke Regter  
(Traduit du néerlandais par Geertje Hoekstra)  

NRC 2 octobre 2009  

“A characteristic of Nézet-Séguin's conducting style is the combination of unbridled enthusiasm and versatile vitality.”

“There was a magically blossoming opening (in the third movement, the Adagio molto e cantabile) which was succeeded by delicate woodwind parts that were not only played beautifully, but sounded as near and intimate as chamber music in the hall.”

“In the final movement [...] Nézet-Séguin gave shape to the rugged music in a natural way.

“The Berliner Rundfunkchor was radiant in the choir parts.”
Jochem Valkenburg  
(Traduit du néerlandais par Geertje Hoekstra)  
 

Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
Du 23 au 27 septembre 2009

De Volkskrant 28 septembre 2009  

“Yannick Nézet-Séguin [...] seems to be mainly interested in the new roads opened by Mahler.”

“Yannick Nézet-Séguin painted ecstatic visions in the last movement: clawing, grimacing and even groaning. After the last delirious notes he threatened to collapse, like a marathon runner at the finish.”
Guido van Oorschot  
(Traduit du néerlandais par Geertje Hoekstra)  

NRC 26 septembre 2009  
Live Webcast of Rotterdam Maher Ninth

“Music Director Yannick Nézet-Séguin, who has started his second season in Rotterdam, made a deep impression with an extremely personal rendering of Mahlers Ninth Symphony.”

“ The one and a half hour lasting journey to the other side, Mahler's autobiographic music about death and about fading away into eternity, sounded as a story full of lovely memories, menace and doom, confusion, chaos and desperation.”
 

“The two middle movements were almost a symphony in themselves, brilliantly performed by the orchestra and with a stunningly fast ending.”
Kasper Jansen  
(Traduit du néerlandais par Geertje Hoekstra)  
 

Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
Salle Wilfrid-Pelletier, Montréal
14 septembre 2009

La Scena Musicale 16 septembre 2009  

Richard Strauss and Nézet-Séguin: A Hero's Life

It’s hard to fathom the arrogance of a thirty-four year composer who writes a huge orchestral piece called Ein Heldenleben (A Hero’s Life) – about himself! What’s more, in the section called "The Hero’s Works of Peace" he quotes from his own previous compositions! Then you have the case of a thirty-four year old conductor who programs this virtuoso piece with a part-time orchestra. Fortunately, the supremely confident young composer was named Richard Strauss, and, as they say, the rest is history. As for the conductor, he happens to be a leader who can galvanize his players to perform way beyond themselves as they did this week at Place des Arts in Montréal.

Yannick Nézet-Séguin celebrated his tenth anniversary as artistic director and conductor of the Orchestre Métropolitain this week and demonstrated yet again why he is not only a Canadian treasure, but also one of the most sought-after maestros on the international scene. It was an all-Richard Strauss programme with Don Juan leading off, followed by a set of orchestral songs featuring soprano Barbara Bonney and, after intermission, Ein Heldenleben.

Don Juan was well-rehearsed and urgent in spite of some shaky trumpet playing and the love music was meltingly beautiful.

I must confess that I am a huge admirer of Strauss’ vocal music, especially in the endlessly imaginative orchestrations by the composer himself. Earlier this summer we heard some of them in fine performances by Ben Heppner and Thomas Hampson at the Knowlton Festival. Strauss had a genius for capturing the very essence of the poetry he set to music. Bonney led off with one of my favourites, Die Heiligen Drei Könige aus Morgenland (Three Holy Kings from the Land of the West). The poem by Heine is a very simple telling of the role of the Wise Men in the Christmas story. Strauss makes it a thing of wonder and childlike innocence.

(...)

One of Nézet-Séguin’s most impressive qualities is his fearlessness. He thinks nothing of recording all the Bruckner symphonies in Montreal or programming Mahler’s massive Eighth Symphony later this season (June 20). In taking on Ein Heldenleben, a work that has tested the finest ‘full-time’ orchestras, he was asking the Orchestre Métropolitain to do the near impossible.

This Heldenleben opened with a very fast tempo- as befits the spirit of a thirty-four year hero - and in terms of technical mastery, it quickly became apparent that Nézet-Séguin had everything under control. At no time, however, did one sense that this performance was about mere accuracy. This young maestro’s technique is extraordinary – a combination of natural ability and hard work – but his performances are never just about getting the notes right; he always reaches beyond that to capture the full range of emotion and meaning in the music. His players gave him everything he asked for, and the results were spectacular! The augmented horn section was thrilling throughout, with authoritative and eloquent solos from principal horn Louis-Philippe Marsolais. The famous violin solos were played by concertmaster Yukari Cousineau. She may have been a little too careful with her long cadenza, but the warm tone she produced in the epilogue was something special. Her dialogue with Marsolais was as touching as one is ever likely to hear.

Finally, I want to commend Nézet-Séguin for making the last chord of Ein Heldenleben – a trumpet-saturated E flat major - the thing of splendor it was meant to be. I haven’t heard it so well-prepared and sustained since Karajan. Most conductors are content to make a half-hearted crescendo, followed by an anti-climactic punctuation mark. This is neither what Strauss wrote, nor what he meant. This is a Straussian Valhalla moment, as the hero is seen one last time in all his glory. In purely musical terms, this chord must be of a weight and power to balance everything that has come before it in the piece. It is obvious that Nézet-Séguin took enormous care over this moment in rehearsal and inspired his players to give everything they had in the performance. Make no mistake about it. This was a very loud chord but – again, Karajan comes to mind – it had no hint of raucous blaring. This is one of the secrets of great conducting and Nézet-Séguin already knows many of them.

The Orchestre Métropolitain simply has no right playing Ein Heldenleben as well as it did this week. This was a great triumph for both conductor and orchestra.

(...)
Paul E. Robinson  

La Presse 16 septembre 2009  

« À 34 ans seulement, Nézet-Séguin apporte à cette musique - qu'il adore, de toute évidence - une passion dévorante et contagieuse qui rappelle les grands soirs de Mehta et de Decker »

« les deux partitions comportent des moments d'accalmie et de tendresse sur lesquels Nézet-Séguin s'attarda amoureusement. »

« Superbe orchestre et superbe concert »
Claude Gingras  
 

Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
Nieuwe Luxor Theater
5 septembre 2009

De Telegraaf 7 septembre 2009  

“The new Music Director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic reached a high level in the love dreams of Zemlinsky's Lyrical Symphony.”

Wim Hekking  
(Traduit du néerlandais par Geertje Hoekstra)  

NRC 7 septembre 2009  
Nézet-Séguin Full of Fire at Gergiev Festival

“The orchestra is noticeably happy with its young Music Director, which is both understandable and deserved.”

“Under Nézet-Séguin's precise direction, the orchestra also gave a fiery performance of Zemlinsky's Lyrical Symphony.”
Mischa Spel  
(Traduit du néerlandais par Geertje Hoekstra)  
 

Sydney Symphony Orchestra
Sydney Opera House, Australie
20, 21, 22 août 2009

Standard 24 août 2009  

“The SSO played with aplomb and obvious relish and the ovation was about the closest Sydney gets to a Proms night at the Albert Hall.”

Steve Moffat  

The Sydney Morning Herald 21 août 2009  

“Nézet-Séguin nursed the expressiveness of the slow movement with care, and the blend between organ tones (David Drury) and orchestra was subtle and clear.”

Peter McCallum  
 

Sydney Symphony Orchestra
Sydney Opera House, Australie
12, 14, 15 et 17 août 2009

The Sydney Morning Herald 15-16 août 2009  

“The spacious first movement (Bruckner’s Third Symphony) had not a hint of hurry and his tempo was a notch or two slower than the norm, yet the structure blossomed. It was as though each component, freed of the stress to press forward, and with its distinctive shape nurtured, found inner strength to take its place in the huge architectural arch.”

“A notable feature of the orchestra's playing was the unforced openness of sound and care with balance and intonation, particularly in the first two movements. In the extended slow movement the quality of sound and attention to each utterance concentrated the listener on each moment.”

“Bruckner's changeable finale sounded paradoxically economical, so that as soon as the final blaze of sound recalled the work's opening trumpet idea, it was clear the work had said what it intended to say and stopped.”

“With Haydn's Symphony No.100 in G (The Military) Nezet-Seguin used enormous podium energy to shape, darken and enliven phrases as though each of Haydn's ideas had to be rescued from the danger of complacency.”

Peter McCallum  

The Australian 14 août 2009  

“In the opening work, Haydn's Symphony No. 100 (Military), expectations were fully met with a stylish, invigorating performance. Brisk tempos, strong dynamic contrasts and sharply etched accents generated boisterous energy. By contrast, shapely phrasing, lilting rhythms and an engaging lightness of touch brought warmth and elegance.”

“Once again, he demonstrated a sure understanding of Bruckner's unique musical architecture (Symphony No.3). In particular, his appreciation of how the composer uses silence created pauses of Pinteresque profundity when he shifted between the contrasting slabs of sound.”

Murray Black  
 

Orchestre du Festival Mostly Mozart
Lincoln Center, Avery Fisher Hall, New York
4 et 5 août 2009

The New York Observer 21 août 2009  

Just Barely Mozart

“Nézet-Séguin’s rendition, with its pungent orchestral colors and crisply percussive rhythmic patterns, proved that this so-called neoclassical throwback (Stravinsky’s Pulcinella) came from the same pen that wrote The Rite of Spring. His interpretation of Mendelssohn’s Italian Symphony had a hard, driving swing at times, but none of the highlighted detail (a timpani whack, a thrust from the violas) disrupted the elegance of the total, silken texture.
Russell Platt  

The New York Times 5 août 2009  

Conductor Embraces His New York Moment

“Mr. Nézet-Séguin tried to make “Pulcinella” seem a real Stravinsky piece with a contemporary character. There were wonderfully sour wind chords, bone-dry plucked string lines and driving rhythms in the dance movements. The Presto, a patter song for tenor, recalled “Les Noces” a bit. The restless Allegro assai sounded like an Italianized episode from “Petrouchka.””

“the performance (Mendelssohn’s Symphony No.4 “italienne”)had sweep, line and lightness. The Andante was a revelation, taken at a true ambling pace, with a steady walking bass line in the lower strings and an austerely shaped melody. It was almost Baroque in its stateliness and quiet rigor”

“The third movement had genial grace, like a breezy Italianate melody floating atop an undulant stream of eighth-notes. The brisk tempo that Mr. Nézet-Séguin set in the Saltarello finale might have been dangerous. But he kept the playing light and flowing, with gossamer textures. Even sudden accents were not forced. There was something impressionistic about the conception, and the orchestra was at its best here.”
Anthony Tommasini  
 

Scottish Chamber Orchestra
BBC Proms, Royal Albert Hall, Londres
31 juillet 2009

www.musiweb.com 5 août 2009  

“I must say that Nézet-Séguin’s and the SCO’s performance was as pleasant as it was skilful. He managed a dynamic and genuinely balletic interpretation of Stravinsky’s imaginative score (Pulcinella), effectively conveying its carefree, lively and witty characteristics.”

“More than with any of the previous pieces, the SCO and Yannick Nézet- Séguin really came into their own here (Mendelssohn’s Symphony No.5). Nézet-Séguin is a very dynamic conductor who injected the piece with energy and enthusiasm. Under his lively leadership, the orchestra delivered an eloquent, dazzling interpretation, negotiating Mendelssohn’s rich orchestration and glorious harmonies with great effect. This was a marvellous finale to a great musical evening, which totally fulfilled the promise implied by the opening Stravinsky ballet.”
Margarida Mota-Bull  

www.musicmh.com 3 août 2009  

“With a varied programme that encompassed two of this year's themes, alongside Schumann's Piano Concerto in A minor, this young Canadian conductor yet again proved that he is not only the most exciting conductor of his generation but has the Midas touch when it comes to interpreting a wide-encompassing repertoire.”

“Nézet-Séguin's scrupulous ear for detail meant that the work came across freshly-minted and he was rewarded with wonderfully buoyant playing by the SCO.”

“Nézet-Séguin's interpretation (Mendelssohn's Symphony no 5 in D minor) brought out all the necessary solemnity of the first movement, whilst his balletic movements on the podium encouraged the orchestra to lend the dance-like second movement a lightness of touch that I'd not experienced in this work before. The third movement was played on a thread of tone which led into an exuberant and ecstatic fourth movement. The SCO played like Trojans for Nézet-Séguin – let's hope he becomes a regular fixture at the Proms from now on.”
Keith McDonnell  

The Times, UK 3 août 2009  

“The Scottish Chamber Orchestra responded with effervescent, precise playing, each note lifted into the air as though the musicians were the dancers. Instrumental colouring stayed equally bright.”

“The clear voicing and pristine glow of the SCO winds and brass helped a lot, and once Luther’s chorale was hoisted up noble festivities reigned.”
Geoff Brown  

The Guardian, UK 2 août 2009  

“It was clear that Nézet-Séguin and the Scottish Chamber Orchestra were delivering a first-rate performance, daringly shaped and marked by attention to detail.”

“Nézet-Séguin showed his mettle here, easing his orchestra into fruitful communion with a pianist (Nicholas Angelich) who, given less sensitive handling, could easily have sounded awkward.”

“Concluding with Mendelssohn's "Reformation" symphony, orchestra and conductor left the near-capacity audience with memories of an evening rich both in character and sparkle.”
Guy Dammann  
 

Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
Festival de Lanaudière, Joliette
4 juillet 2009

La Presse 6 juillet 2009  

Le Sacre de Nézet-Séguin se rapproche de l'idéal: entier dans la sauvagerie et la dissonance, entier dans la subtilité et le mystère.

Claude Gingras  

Montreal Gazette 6 juillet 2009  

Principal among these was Stravinsky's The Rite of Spring as performed by the Orchestre Métropolitain under Yannick Nézet-Séguin. Here was a fine mix of force and expressive fluency. The texture was colourful and symphonic, the beat vibrant rather than just relentless.

Arthur Kaptainis  
 

Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
Bruckner : Symphonie n° 8
15 juin 2009

La Presse 17 juin 2009  

Un autre grand Bruckner de Nézet-Séguin

« Tout comme il y a cinq ans, Nézet-Séguin dirigeait de mémoire cette heure et demie de musique et cet orchestre augmenté à 85 musiciens. J'avais alors parlé de son «immense» Bruckner. Mon impression est la même et j'y ajoute d'autres considérations, la plus significative étant la force de concentration qu'en dépit d'un horaire de plus en plus turbulent notre génial jeune chef parvient à conserver et à communiquer à ses musiciens et, par le fait même, à l'auditoire entier. »

« La foudroyante virtuosité des deux timbaliers est à signaler, comme le sont, tout à l'opposé, les trémolos mendelssohniens du Scherzo. »  

« Le silence absolu de l'auditoire … était digne de cette musique de haute spiritualité. Nous étions dans un autre monde. »
Claude Gingras  
 

Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
Parkstad Limburg Theaters, Heerlen
30 mai 2009

Limburgs Dagblad 3 juin 2009  
Sensational Beethoven by Rotterdam Philharmonic

“Right from the start, in Mozart's Overture to The Magic Flute we heard how beautiful the Rotterdam orchestra can play under their enthusiastic young Canadian Music Director Yannick Nézet-Séguin. A large dose of transparency – in which not only the main structures but also the small motives and patterns in the inner voices were brought out very clearly, and in which also the beautiful timbres and the blending of colours in the winds had full play – was combined with a lively, energetic way of  playing with great musicality and dramatic expressiveness.”

“Mozart's Piano Concerto in C had the same qualities. Sometimes the attention was even drawn away from the wonderful performance of the soloist Daria van Bercken and directed to the beautifully detailed workmanship in the orchestra. At last there is a conductor who takes an accompaniment seriously. Van Bercken played the concert beautifully light, clear and with true sensitivity”.

“The grandiose highlight of the evening, however, was a magisterial and highly original rendering of Beethoven's Seventh Symphony. The amount of bunched-up energy that burst forth into the hall was breathtaking. Limburg probably has never seen such a sublime and enervating performance of Beethoven's Seventh before.”

“From the start to the end the audience was spellbound and fascinated, and enjoying this top orchestra with its absolute top conductor. Everyone on stage appeared to be having enormous fun.”

“The highest honour, however, goes to Nézet-Séguin. The unequalled amount of energy and momentum he put into the work made this performance an event of which people will still ask each other in a few years' time: "Were you there?"

 

Wim Hekking  
(Traduit du néerlandais par Geertje Hoekstra)  
 

London Philharmonic orchestra
Royal Festival Hall
27 mai 2009

Music OMH, London 3 juin 2009  

*****
Aldo Ciccolini makes a rare, yet unforgettable visit to London with a transcendental performance of Rachmaninov’s 2nd Piano Concerto with the LPO.

For someone approaching his mid-eighties, he delivers playing of such astonishingly assured virtuosity that one is left grasping for superlatives.

Italian born pianist Aldo Ciccolini has been far too infrequent a visitor to these shores, which probably goes some way to explaining why this mid-week LPO concert was packed to the rafters. Italian born, yet French domiciled, his career spans more than six decades. These days his appearances on the platform are becoming increasingly scarcer so this performance of Rachmaninov’s 2nd Piano Concerto promised to be a very special event, but nothing could have prepared the audience for the emotional impact of Ciccolini’s quite mesmerising performance.

Looking frail when he made his way onto the platform, and bearing a startling resemblance to his idol Liszt, once installed at the piano became a man possessed. He launched into the first movement with playing of vigour and energy that took one’s breath away and with loving support from Yannick Nézet-Séguin and the LPO, showed that he was blessed with the digital dexterity of a man half his age. His virtuosity was spell-binding and having been taken aback by his agility in the first movement, the poise, feeling, expression and elegiac introspection he brought to the second movement came over as pure unadulterated aural balm.

The fiendishly difficult third movement held no terrors for him and he crowned his performance with playing of such scintillating brilliance that he rightly brought the house down and was awarded one of most heartfelt and thoroughly deserved standing ovations I’ve witnessed in this hall in recent years. He gave one encore – a delicately played account of an unpublished piece by Schubert entitled the Kupelwieser Waltz.

The concert opened with a sun-drenched performance of Mendelssohn’s 4th Symphony, (Italian) which Nézet-Séguin infused with Mediterranean warmth from the ebullient opening, through to the energetic close, eliciting alert playing from all sections of the LPO.

After the interval this prodigiously gifted young conductor once again proved that his appointment as Principal Guest Conductor of the LPO is one of the most exciting things to happen to musical life in London in recent years. The LPO quite simply play better for him than for any other conductor, and I can think of no other musical partnership in the capital at the moment that produces such consistently electrifying results.

His reading of Dvorak’s 7th Symphony perfectly captured the dark, brooding qualities of the work. There was fire and passion in the tempestuous first movement which gave way to an achingly beautiful slow movement whose melancholic overtones were perfectly judged. The Slavonic character of the infectiously lilting rhythms of the scherzo was beautifully handled whilst the final movement had an almost Wagnerian grandeur – its optimistic D major conclusion was properly shattering. The playing of the LPO was exemplary and impassioned throughout.

A truly unforgettable concert, that will live long in the memory.

Keith McDonnell  

London Evening Standard 28 mai 2009  

Bringing sun to England: Yannick Nézet-Séguin

Half a century of age and experience separated the conductor and soloist in last night’s LPO concert, with enthralling results.

While the dynamic young French Canadian Yannick Nézet-Séguin has been setting audiences alight with his electrifying interpretations since becoming principal guest conductor of the orchestra, Aldo Ciccolini, now well into his eighties, is something of a legend. Neither disappointed.

Nézet-Séguin brought the Mediterranean sun of Mendelssohn’s Italian Symphony to the Festival Hall, showering it with love and affection.

In Dvorák's Symphony No 7 in D Minor, by contrast, he sought the darker, Wagnerian timbres, in a reading that combined lyrical rapture and volcanic intensity. For all the lilt, winningly done, of the dance music featured in the last two movements, this was a performance both physically demanding for the players and emotionally draining for the audience.

In Rachmaninov’s Second Piano Concerto, Ciccolini demonstrated that he could still command impressive agility and litheness. Curiously, though, there was less freedom in much of his phrasing than Nézet-Séguin had invoked in the Mendelssohn. Occasionally, however, he broke free from metrical constraints and revealed a poetic gift ripened by a lifetime’s wisdom.

Ciccolini traces his pedigree back to Liszt and Busoni and indeed, with his flowing white mane, he rather resembles Liszt in profile. Just as one was thinking how good it would be to hear him play something of that repertoire, he returned to the platform and obliged with a short encore, delivered with inimitable charm and delicacy. Pure magic.
Barry Millington  
 

Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
Amsterdam Concertkebouw
8 mai 2009

NRC 11 mai 2009  

“Ravel's Ma mère l'Oye was again fairytale-like, frivolous and sophisticated, like sultry swirls of summer wind which evoke memories from a far past in a Proustian way.”

“Berlioz' Symphonie fantastique was passionate, effective and overwhelming.”
Kasper Jansen  
(Traduit du néerlandais par : Geertje Hoekstra)  

Het Parool 11 mai 2009  

“The program he conducted last Friday in a packed Concertgebouw was not very adventurous, but it fit the French Canadian conductor very well. Nézet-Séguin is Québecois, and therefore Ravel's music is dear to him (he conducted Ma mère l'Oye by heart), with Berlioz' Symphonie fantastique he indirectly professed his love for Beethoven, and with Mozart's Piano Concerto No. 24 (soloist: Stephen Kovacevich) he could demonstrate that he is familiar with early music practice, but that he is not sectarian about it.”

“ The audience was very enthusiastic. A successful debut. »
Erik Voermans  
(Traduit du néerlandais par : Geertje Hoekstra)  
 

Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
18 Avril 2009

stadsomroep.com, Bruges, Belgique 19 Avril 2009  

Mahler 5 : Minutes-long Standing Ovation

“As soon as the last note of Mahler's Fifth Symphony had sounded, the audience leapt to its feet to reward musicians and conductor justly with a long applause. The Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra, once led by Gergiev, lived up to its expectations in the Bruges Concertgebouw. Mahler sounded as it should.”

“A worthy concert with a worthy orchestra, a worthy audience and a masterful conductor.”

Traduit du Hollandais par Geertje Hoekstra

Patrik Pieters  
 

London Philharmonic orchestra
4 avril 2009
Royal Festival Hall

The Guardian, London, UK 9 avril 2009  

(...)

After the interval came Brahms's German Requiem. It's fashionable to argue that the piece works best done swiftly and on a small-scale. This, however, was big, slow and overwhelming. The choral singing was wonderfully intense, and soloists Elizabeth Watts and Stéphane Degout were both outstanding. The long silence at its close, which no one dared fracture with applause, was testament to its impact.
Tim Ashley  

Music OMH 8 avril 2009  

Reconstructed Mendelssohn and spell-binding Brahms make for a thrilling LPO concert under Yannick Nézet-Séguin

On the basis of this evening alone, Yannick Nézet-Séguin's appointment as Principal Guest Conductor of the LPO is a cause for major rejoicing.

The first half of this memorable evening was devoted to one work, namely Mendelssohn's Piano Concerto in E minor, which if he had lived to complete it would have been his third. At the time of his death he had only managed to sketch the opening bars, the solo piano part for the remainder of the first movement, the entire second movement and a few melodic fragments for the third. It was tonight's pianist, Roberto Prosseda, who suggested to scholar Marcello Bufalini that he reconstruct the piece from what little fragments the composer had left.

Whether Mendelssohn would have followed the same train of thought as Bufalini is open to endless conjecture but what can be in no doubt was Prosseda's technical virtuosity throughout this exhilarating performance, which concluded with a breathtaking finale.

After the interval, we were treated to the most moving, reverential, illuminating and ultimately uplifting performance of Brahms' Ein Deutsches Requiem I've ever heard, either in the concert hall or on CD. In deciding against setting the Latin Requiem Mass, Brahms delivers a far more personal work, heavily influenced by the death of his great friend Robert Schumann and his mother. There is none of the fire and brimstone, hell and damnation that is found in most other Requiem Masses, Brahms instead finding a compositional voice of quiet emotion and profound humanity that when faced with such an enlightening a performance as this, even the most fervent unbeliever cannot fail to be moved.

From the hushed introspection of the opening, delicately played by cellos, then violas it was evident that this was going to be a remarkable performance – a view confirmed when the LPO Choir entered singing 'Selig sind, die da Lied tragen (Blessed are they that mourn)' on barely a thread of tone. Throughout the evening they never put a foot wrong, and I don't think I've ever heard such glorious choral singing, whether at full throttle in 'Denn alles Fleisch, es ist wie Gras (For all flesh is as grass)' or in the quiet valedictory hymn 'Selig sind die Toten (Blessed are the dead)' which concludes the work. Quite astounding, and they and their superb director Neville Creed were rightly awarded a thunderous ovation at the end.

Both announced soloists cancelled but we were lucky that their replacements, Elizabeth Watts and Stéphane Degout, more than compensated. She achieved lyrical nirvana with her impassioned singing of 'Ihr habt nun Traurigkeit (And ye now therefore have sorrow)' whilst he was forthright and resplendent in 'Denn wir haben keine bleibende Statt (For here have we no continuing city)'.

But architect of the evening's unequivocal success was Yannick Nézet-Séguin. To conduct a piece of this magnitude from memory is no mean feat, yet it was evident in every bar that here was a work dear to this young conductor's heart. Tempi were perfectly judged, attention to orchestral detail was scrupulous and all the sections of the orchestra responded with secure and impassioned playing. The seemingly endless silence at the close, with no one daring to applaud, was indicative of the profound and stirring effect this performance had had on its listeners. All in all a performance that no one present will forget in a hurry and a reminder, if one needed reminding, that this is probably Brahms' greatest achievement.
Keith McDonnell  

The Independant 6 avril 2009  

(Rated 4/5)
Brahms’ Ein deutsches Requiem should be mandatory for anyone (and there are many) who has ever uttered a disparaging or ill-considered word against its composer.

Under the conspicuously talented Yannick Nezet-Seguin it shone, it thundered, it inspired awe and consolation in equal measure. I can’t honestly remember when it last sounded so all-enveloping.

(...)

And then it was forgotten. As that richly consoling alliance between cellos and violas proffered solace in lamentation from the opening bars of Brahms’ Ein deutsches Requiem and the chorus’ words “Blessed are they that mourn” left one in no doubt as to its grateful recipients, Yannick Nezet-Seguin’s labour of love on a work he so clearly reveres put not a foot wrong. With wonderfully sensitive and articulate singing from the London Philharmonic Choir the fine balance between the work’s deep and abiding compassion and its death-defying exultation was memorably achieved. Awe was duly forthcoming as the mighty cortege of “Denn alles Fleisch, es ist wie Gras” rolled out, low horns and pounding timpani accentuating its black splendour, and those fugal codas were properly rollocking, hopeful affairs – blasts from the past powering towards the future.

A requiem for the living, then, and at its heart one and only one soprano solo: Elizabeth Watts’ prowess in Strauss served her well in this seraphic movement - the still, small, maternal voice of comfort for us all.
Edward Seckerson  
 

Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
3 avril 2009
De Doelen, Rotterdam

NRC 7 avril 2009  

“The monumental opening was followed by an avalanche of contrasting emotions, from the deepest darkness to the most radiant joy, all realized in one large gesture. The Adagietto was not overly slow and made a sunny upbeat to the enervating final movement.”

“This Mahler (Symphony No.5) was a real event.”

Kasper Jansen 
(Traduit du néerlandais par : Geertje Hoekstra)  

De Telegraaf 7 avril 2009  

“ Under his hands, Mahler's Fifth Symphony developed into a solid, broadly-breathing structure with well chosen nervousness in the carnival-like fragments. The Adagietto for harp and strings was conducted without the baton en radiated supernatural peace without becoming melodramatic.”

Frederike Berntsen 
(Traduit du néerlandais par : Geertje Hoekstra)  

De Volkskrant 5 avril 2009  

“ The Adagietto was so beautiful it could make you weep.”

Guido van Oorschot  
(Traduit du néerlandais par : Geertje Hoekstra)  
 

Toronto Symphony Orchestra
25, 26 et 28 Mars 2009. Roy Thomson Hall

Toronto Star 27 Mars 2009  

Nézet-Séguin coaxes TSO into vibrant colour
****(out of 4)

To call Wednesday night an embarrassment of riches doesn't begin to describe its musical pleasures.

First, in Roy Thomson Hall, the Toronto Symphony Orchestra offered up one of its shortened "Afterworks" programs, which start at 6:30 p.m.

The orchestra members and CBC Radio Two host Tom Allen, on emcee duty, may have been dressed in casual black, but the performances vibrated with colour.

Guest conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin, in his early 30s already an established favourite at major concert houses around the world, coaxed particularly rich sounds out of the orchestra in a powerful reading of the World War II Symphony No.5 by Sergei Prokofiev and conjured a deliciously effervescent rendition of the 1931 Piano Concerto in G Major by Maurice Ravel, with pianist Louis Lortie appearing to have the time of his life at his Fazioli concert grand.

Tomorrow, pianist and conductor add on Ravel's Piano Concerto for the Left Hand in one of this season's unmissable concert dates.

John Terauds  
 

Los Angeles Philharmonic
12, 13, 14 et 15 Mars 2009

Pasadena Star-News/San Gabriel Valley Tribune/Whittier Daily News 14 Mars 2009  

Moreover, it wasn’t all Argerich. Yannick Nézet-Séguin, a 34-year-old Montreal native, is making his L.A. Phil debut this week and he conducted the concerto as if the occasion were as important as it turned out to be. He was also extraordinarily attuned to Argerich, facing her during her cadenza passages and really listening. The Philharmonic also rose to the occasion with absolutely top-flight ensemble work. I’ve never heard this concerto played better.”

Following the well-deserved thunderous ovation, Argerich playfully joined Nézet-Séguin in a four-hand arrangement of an excerpt from Ravel’s “Mother Goose” Suite, which proved that, in addition to his other talents, Nézet-Séguin knows his way around the keyboard” 

Add Los Angeles to the list. Nézet-Séguin is cut from the same bolt of cloth as Gustavo Dudamel: tres-exuberant on the podium, rapier-like baton thrusts, beaming with wide smiles, etc. Despite seating the cellos in the middle of the ensemble, which would normally produce a deep, luxuriant tone, Nézet-Séguin coaxed the orchestra to deliver the lean sort of sound that we used to hear from the Montreal Symphony (that city’s “other” orchestra) when Charles Dutoit was at its helm.”

However, this most familiar of Shostakovich's 15 symphonies was laid out expertly, to my taste. Conducting without a score (as was the case in La Valse), Nézet-Séguin’s tempos tended to be on the deliberate side for the most part but the tension never flagged, even for an instant, and everything made sense. The third movement, in particular, unfolded as one gigantic arch, and the final movement built inexorably to a majestic, shattering conclusion.“

Nézet-Séguin is clearly a conductor to watch carefully in the future. Let’s hope there are plenty more opportunities in Los Angeles.“

Robert D. Thomas 

Los Angeles Times 13 Mars 2009  

Thursday’s program began with Ravel’s “La Valse” and ended with Shostakovich’s Fifth Symphony.  In everything, Nézet-Séguin -- who is flashy and hyper-expressive in his gestures -- got a sound I had never quite heard before from the Angelenos.  It was lean, sleek, tart in the French manner, yet also very bold and forward.  It reminded me of the sound of the Montreal Symphony during the Charles Dutoit era, but with more punch.”

“In complete command of everything, Nézet-Séguin brought out interesting details in every phrase.  He quickly figured out what the orchestra could do and what Disney could do, and he went for an extreme dynamic range.  Climaxes did, however, turn a bit brittle.” 

His interaction with Argerich was especially intriguing.  Ravel began his concerto with a snap of percussion, and conductor and pianist were off like racehorse and rider.  Argerich was the rider, but she challenged the conductor to be wild, seeming to take delight in being able to maintain her balance no matter what.  Through it all, she was ever cool, tossing off ethereal trills, when required, with a flick of the wrist.  The slow movement alone was worth the price of admission.  She has not lost her art of seduction.”

For an encore, the conductor joined Argerich at the keyboard in a brief excerpt from Ravel’s “Mother Goose” Suite in its four-hand arrangement.  For all his cockiness at the podium, Nézet-Séguin, sitting next to Argerich and playing the second piano part, was like a proud but nervous schoolboy.  The performance had considerable charm. “

“La Valse” had a kind of charm as well in its suave parts and in that astonishing French sound Nézet-Séguin was able to achieve.“

It had moments of great beauty.  The young conductor wrung from the (Shostakovitch) Fifth every ounce of emotion, and the composer gave him a lot to work with.  Inner lines were illuminated.  Orchestral colors were vivid.“

Nézet-Séguin is a considerable virtuoso, able to slow down to a near stop and rush to finish with dazzling speed.  The last movement was not Soviet triumphalism but mad fury.“

Mark Swed 
 

Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
5, 6, 7 et 8 Mars 2009

Algemeen Dagblad 7 Mars 2009  

Wonderful Schubert's Ninth

The Viennese Classics are in good hands with Yannick Nézet-Séguin. In November 2007, he demonstrated this with a brilliant performance of Beethoven's Eroica. Last Thursday, with Mozart and Schubert on the programme, he decidedly proved that he has a very personal style.

This was immediately evident in Mozart's Adagio and Fugue. The opening was stern, but Nézet-Séguin continued in a subdued way, which had an alienating effect. And in the fugue, the attention was drawn to the commanding way in which the bases and the cello's (who were placed in the centre) performed their parts.

Mozart's Piano Concerto Nr. 24 was beautiful. The opening received a symphonic approach and Stephen Kovacevich was a soloist with an excellent sense of style. The woodwinds finished the song phrases that Kovachevich had started in a lovely way. Together they played a fascinating game.

Just like last month with Berlioz' Symphonie Fantastique, Yannick Nézet-Séguin conducted the massive torso of Schubert's Ninth Symphony (almost an hour of music), completely by heart. As if it was nothing. The advantage was that he could keep in touch with the orchestra and did not have to look at the score.

The performance was just as beautiful as the majestic horn solo with which Schubert's swan song started. Inspired, full of warmth and passion. In the supple Scherzo, the vocal-like melody that suddenly blossomed up was abundant with charm. Delightful, Viennese schmalz.
Ger van der Tang 
(Traduit du néerlandais par : Geertje Hoekstra) 
 

Boston Symphony Orchestra
26, 27 et 28 février 2009

Classicalsource.com 9 mars 2009  

Montreal-born conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin teamed up with French pianist Jean-Yves Thibaudet to make an impressive Boston Symphony debut. A relative newcomer to American audiences, Nézet-Séguin guest-conducted the Philadelphia Orchestra last December in performances of Rachmaninov’s Second Piano Concerto (with André Watts) and Tchaikovsky’s ‘Pathétique’ Symphony and is scheduled to lead the Los Angeles Philharmonic (with Martha Argerich) in a program of Ravel and Shostakovich this March.

Although Americans are just getting to know Nézet-Séguin, he has been Artistic Director and Principal Conductor of Montreal’s Orchestre Métropolitain since March 2000 and has been making his mark in concert halls on the other side of the Atlantic since his 2004 European debut with Orchestre National du Capitole de Toulouse. At 34 years old, he has been appointed to succeed Valery Gergiev as Music Director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic this season, and since last September has been principal guest conductor of the London Philharmonic.

The concert opened with a captivating account of Ravel's Valses nobles et sentimentales, music firmly established within the BSO repertoire. Nézet-Séguin elicited all the sumptuous textures and rich colors in the alluring score, the woodwinds sounding especially on their game, along with the orchestra’s eloquent strings, bright-sounding brass and gleaming celesta. The orchestra, so long accustomed to the expressive mannerisms of Seiji Ozawa and the swooping gestures of James Levine, responded with assurance to Nézet-Séguin’s vividly demonstrative conducting style.

The first half of the program concluded with a superb performance of Liszt’s compact Second Piano Concerto. Thibaudet’s sparkling articulation was matched by great tenderness and poetic feeling in the dreamy, more amorous sections, but there was plenty of bravura and panache in the more energetic passages. Thibaudet’s playing was splendid throughout, as was his rapport with Nézet-Séguin and the BSO players, who provided him with excellent support. Martha Babcock’s cello sounded especially gorgeous in her solo.

A vigorous and dynamic account of Dvořák’s Sixth Symphony took up the second half of the program. Conducting from memory, just as he had done with the Ravel and the Liszt, Nézet-Séguin elicited all the vibrant colors and atmosphere of the piece, so full of Brahmsian echoes and Czech pastoral overtones. His reading made the most of the work's dynamic contrasts. The BSO strings and woodwinds shone in the lyrical moments of the opening Allegro. The Adagio was full of expressive feeling, and there was a wonderful vibrant energy to the dance-rhythms of the scherzo. The finale was delivered with plenty of power and excitement.
Susan Stempleski 

The Boston Phoenix 3 mars 2009  

“ Thirty-four-year-old Canadian conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin reminds me a little of stage director Peter Sellars — he's small, with spiky short hair, and a dynamo. He conducts the Orchestre Métropolitan du Grand Montréal, and he's just taken over the directorship of the Rotterdam Philharmonic from Valery Gergiev. He's hot. In his Boston Symphony Orchestra debut, he led tight, eloquent performances of Ravel's elegant Valses nobles et sentimentales, Liszt's bravura but offbeat Piano Concerto No. 2, with Jean-Yves Thibaudet, and Dvorák's earthy, nationalistic Symphony No. 6. He always seemed a step ahead of the orchestra, and the orchestra seemed to be hanging on every beat, ready to follow him wherever he wanted to go.

The Ravel moved delicately back and forth between waltzes that were lilting and pointed and waltzes that were tender and contoured. The Liszt sounded compositionally compelling, with Thibaudet providing more accompaniment to the orchestra than vice versa. The most beautiful, supersaturated theme in the concerto is for cello, and it was richly spun out by Martha Babcock. Still, Nézet-Séguin had the players alert to Thibaudet's every turn, as by the end he was tobogganing up and down the keyboard with blinding bi-directional glissandos. I liked watching Nézet-Séguin's energetic body language, but even better was when he just stood there listening to Thibaudet's solos. My favorite part of the Dvorák is the third-movement Scherzo, with its vigorously dancing hymn to Bohemia, and here it was a real pick-me-up. The lovely slow movement, almost a lullaby, had a seductive meandering gait.”
Lloyd Schwartz 

The Boston Globe 27 février 2009  

FBSO debut for a rising Canadian

The career of the French-Canadian conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin has been moving at light speed, though American symphony audiences are just now starting to get to know him. At just 34, he is in his first season as music director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic, attempting to fill the shoes of Valery Gergiev, and this season he also began as principal guest conductor of the London Philharmonic Orchestra. Since 2000, he has been leading Montreal's Orchestre Métropolitain. Last night, he made an auspicious debut leading the Boston Symphony Orchestra in works by Ravel, Liszt, and Dvorak.

Walking out onto stage Nézet-Séguin cuts a diminutive figure but once the music begins he is a whirl of irrepressible energy. His podium approach is vividly demonstrative and almost dance-like yet his gestures seldom seem designed for the audience's benefit rather than the musicians'. At least last night his technique served him very well as he drew vibrant performances from the orchestra, at once structurally coherent and viscerally exciting.

The program opened with Ravel's "Valses Nobles et Sentimentales" in a reading that seemed to relish this music's luxurious textures and rich palette of color. But the center of gravity on the first half was Liszt's brief but capacious Piano Concerto No. 2, with the French pianist Jean-Yves Thibaudet.

Given this soloist's reputation for keyboard elegance, one would hardly expect a brash firebreathing account of this virtuoso work, and true to form, Thibaudet delivered a graceful and nuanced reading that strived for much more than pyrotechnic display. The work's passages of soft-toned reverie came across as cherished moments of repose, though Thibaudet did not shy away from the flashy and thunderous runs, dispatching them with a clear and forceful technique. Cellist Martha Babcock made the most of her solo turn.

After intermission, Nézet-Séguin led a robust and dynamic account of Dvorak's Sixth Symphony, full of shape and detail without sacrificing a sense of overall sweep. The occasional balance was askew but the performance brimmed with energy. The slow movement had its own completely distinct mood and character, distinguished by long lines and shapely phrases from the woodwinds. Dvorak's Scherzo is a blast of chest-thumping musical nationalism, here vigorously dispatched. In both outer movements, there were moments when Nézet-Séguin daringly pushed the tempo to the limits but the orchestra was with him every step of the way.

 

Jeremy Eichler 
 

Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
Mahler : Le chant de la terre
22 février 2009

The Gazette 24 février 2009  

Fresh from the London Philharmonic and looking forward to the Boston Symphony, Yannick Nézet-Séguin managed on Sunday to make his Orchestre Métropolitain sound like an ensemble that can compete in that league. Since the program included Mahler's Das Lied von der Erde, there was little margin for error.

This exquisite score has lengthy interludes of chamber restraint and intimacy, which YNS balanced to perfection. Woodwind contributions were no less songful than the vocal solos. Strings made a radiant sound.

Singers were excellent on their own terms and ideally contrasted. John Mac Master brought rugged tone and forthright expression to his drinking songs. A comparison with another Canadian tenor, Jon Vickers, is not overdrawn.

Christianne Stotijn, a golden-toned Dutch mezzo-soprano, occupied the more placid and poetic numbers with equal propriety. The final Abschied movement was built with radiant arches. She also managed to hold the stage with her long-tressed Nordic looks during the extended orchestral passages.

To say the conductor was involved in the music is putting it mildly. Always an exuberant and balletic figure, Nézet-Séguin seemed ready at times to sing along.

String sound had been less burnished in Haydn's Symphony No. 100. The orchestra was energized, however, by the lusty development of the first movement and the surprising outburst near the end of the second, where Haydn introduces premonitions of the romantic future. The stirring trumpet fanfare could have passed for Mahler.

The OM is clearly doing many things right. Many impressive sponsorships were acknowledged in the program booklet and on a screen above the stage. Yet even with the world's hottest young conductor, the orchestra has trouble filling Salle Wilfrid Pelletier - the balcony of which was closed for the sake of making attendance in the rest of the hall seem less threadbare.
Arthur Kaptainis 

La Presse 23 février 2009  

Nézet-Séguin et Stotijn: un Mahler troublant

L'interprétation du Chant de la terre que Yannick Nézet-Séguin et la mezzo Christianne Stotijn nous ont donnée hier après-midi fait partie de ces expériences troublantes - et rarissimes - qui déconcertent l'observateur. Celui-ci cherche tout simplement ses mots pour décrire ce qu'il a ressenti; il ne sait d'ailleurs pas par où commencer son analyse de l'événement.

Et si on commençait par la toute fin? Par le silence qui a suivi le «ewig» («éternellement») doucement répété de la chanteuse? Un silence incroyable, que Nézet a maintenu pendant ce qui semblait une éternité, justement, prolongeant ainsi l'atmosphère qu'il avait établie dans la salle depuis une heure. 

L'OSM et Nagano avaient donné cet ultime Mahler, Das Lied von der Erde, le mois dernier dans la version facultative où un baryton remplace la mezzo. Nézet revenait hier à la version traditionnelle ténor-mezzo, plus intéressante en raison du contraste des voix. Encore faut-il une mezzo à la hauteur. Ce qu'est tout à fait la Néerlandaise Christianne Stotijn (on prononce «chto-taïn»).

D'un maintien très digne, avec une voix belle et toujours égale et un phrasé caressant, Mme Stotijn livra entièrement de mémoire le texte, tour à tour poétique et contemplatif, dont elle avait bien pénétré le sens. L'Abschied final, qui fait à lui seul une demi-heure, soit la moitié de l'oeuvre complète, donna lieu à un dialogue plein de mystère - et véritablement mis en scène par Nézet - entre la voix et des instruments comme la flûte et le hautbois traités à leur tour comme des voix.

Les yeux dans sa partition, même quand il ne chantait pas, John Mac Master fournit la prestation de Heldentenor que Mahler souhaite. C'est finalement un ivrogne qui gueule ici et le corpulent Mac Master rendit bien le personnage, même que ses efforts à l'aigu cadraient avec le contexte assez délirant.

Le grand héros reste néanmoins le jeune chef du Métropolitain, pour avoir obtenu de celui-ci une réalisation aussi précise et aussi convaincante de cette partition très difficile.
L'exécution était accompagnée de surtitres et d'images d'une sculpture d'Anne Kahane inspirée par l'oeuvre de Mahler. Mme Kahane était présente parmi les quelque 2000 auditeurs. Le concert était donné sous la présidence de Mme Sophie Desmarais.

En première partie: la Symphonie no 100 de Haydn, jouée avec toutes les reprises, une nette articulation des violons et une amusante turquerie.

Claude Gingras 
 

Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
Le Chœur de l’Orchestre Métropolitain
Au bénéfice de l’Institut du cancer de Montréal
14 février 2009

La Presse 15 février 2009  

« Vendredi soir, il (YNS) a poussé son orchestre et son choeur à leur maximum, non seulement dans le sens de la puissance, mais encore des plus fines nuances. » « À cet égard, il suffit de rappeler, par exemple, l'articulation des violons dans l'ouverture des Nozze di Figaro ou les solos de flûte et de hautbois dans les pages orchestrales de Carmen. Même soin des détails chez le choeur et notamment le célèbre «Va pensiero» de Nabucco, où les voix se prolongeaient au-delà du dernier accord de l'orchestre. »

Claude Gingras 
 

London Philharmonic Orchestra
11 février 2009

The Financial Times 16 février 2009  

London Philharmonic Orchestra, Royal Festival Hall, London

“ Nézet-Séguin has such a high level of engagements in next year’s diary that London must feel lucky to have caught him while it still could.”

“What made this performance memorable was Nézet-Séguin’s ability to make every note come alive.” “Here, the symphony made sense on many more levels, focusing on the details in the great cathedral of Bruckner’s vision, as if every stone mattered, without losing sight of the vast structure’s overall grandeur.”
Richard Fairman 

Seen and Heard International 13 février 2009  

Nézet-Séguin  has been receiving plaudits from everybody who  experiences one of his concerts. I’ve heard some live concerts conducted by him on CBC, Canadian Radio, in the days when live concerts were regularly broadcast by them, and I was impressed with what I heard. It was obvious that a major talent was at work, one who could get the very best from his orchestra and deliver performances of  great power, energy and insight. Tonight was my first experience of him live and he exceeded all expectations.

It’s unusual for someone as young as Nézet-Séguin  to have the full measure of the later Symphonies of Anton Bruckner and to be able to understand, and bring together, the many and various strands which go to make up one of these towering edifices. What was most impressive 
about this performance of Bruckner’s 7th Symphony was Nézet-Séguin’s superb understanding of the architecture of the piece. From the opening minutes, with the long, soaring, cello theme, it was obvious that our conductor had his sights firmly set on the closing pages of  the work where this theme returns triumphant on full orchestra. What happened in the sixty minutes between these two events were full of high drama, malevolence and searing passion.

The slow movement, with its four Wagner tubas, is an elegy on the death of Wagner and here Nézet-Séguin  encouraged the long lines to breathe, building the climaxes with care and allowing them to grow naturally from the ever changing musical landscape which surrounds 
them. The coda was sombre and tragic, indeed, it was heart–breaking, as befits an in memoriam for a great artist. The scherzo is another of Bruckner’s malevolent allegros. Nézet-Séguin  kept his feet firmly on the ground and this music stamped its way, so it seemed to me, to a very disturbing end. The finale is a difficult movement to bring off  successfully, not least because, with all the huge, insistent, downward movement of the musical ideas it is easy to loose the beat  and let it run away with itself, as it did when Giulini conducted it at the Proms about 20 years ago, and then the whole structure is put in jeopardy. Nothing like that happened tonight for Nézet-Séguin  kept a very firm hand on the proceedings and, by slightly holding back the 
forward momentum, and gradually building a large structure, the final statement of the opening theme felt like a satisfactory homecoming, rather than just a loud peroration.

One more point. Bruckner’s music is full of silences, some Cathedral–like in their size, and these are important for the audience, letting it take in what has just happened and preparing it for what is about to happen. Tonight Nézet-Séguin  filled those silences with the most intense meaning, making them speak volumes as part of the whole and understanding them as part of the composition, not just gaps between  bars. This was most exciting for I have never fully appreciated the silences quite as much before.  This interpretation was a magnificent 
achievement and the London Philharmonic, which was on top form, can be proud of their commitment to the music, and what they gave to their audience.

Before the interval, Truls Mørk was a fine advocate for Haydn’s early Concerto. He was undemonstrative, as befits the work, and was fully in touch with the music. It was no fault of his that his performance was completely overwhelmed by what followed.
Bob Briggs 

Times Online, UK 12 février 2009  

“the real showpiece came after the interval, with Bruckner. All the composer’s symphonies are “big things”, and the conductor, from his Montreal base, has made a speciality of them. We heard the Seventh (in the Nowak edition). Conducting from memory and passion, Nézet-Séguin exerted an inexorable grip right from the start, when tremulous strings rose from the ether toward the motto theme, caressed in a voluptuous legato.”

“Good sense and sensibility governed every speed transition, always a test in Bruckner. Splendour of orchestral sound was abundant too. Woodwind details and counter-melodies glinted and winked. The brass melded into a mighty phalanx. Those unison chords in the finale seemed sliced with a knife: so straight, so sharp. The LPO’s warmth and exuberance even made palatable the one instrumental detail that in most performances seems to be a mistake: the cymbal clash and tinkling triangle at the height of the great adagio.”

“A romantically inclined Seventh, then. Yet Nézet-Séguin’s heat in this case never melted the symphony’s mountain peaks: the lover’s adoration went hand-in-hand with a structural engineer’s scientific skill. By speeding through some of the finale’s connecting tissue he actually made the architecture stronger. And the moment the orchestra gathered its full strength in the climaxes, the weight and glory of Bruckner’s thinking was laid out before us, triumphant. A performance to hear again on Tuesday, on Radio 3.”
Geoff Brown 

The Telegraph, UK 12 février 2009  

The London Philharmonic Orchestra's guest conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin fans the slow burn of Bruckner.

It was an astute move on the part of the London Philharmonic Orchestra to sign up the young Québécois Canadian Yannick Nézet-Séguin as its principal guest conductor.

The orchestra has seldom played with such a potent fusion of radiance and animation as it did in this coupling of Haydn and Bruckner, recalling a similarly sit-up-and-listen experience I had when I first heard him conduct Mendelssohn and Ravel with the Scottish Chamber Orchestra two years ago.

Since then, Nézet-Séguin has been wowing audiences worldwide. He is still in charge of the Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal, and in the autumn of last year took over from Valery Gergiev as music director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic.

A young man tackling Bruckner is not a common phenomenon. Nézet-Séguin is only in his early thirties, but the Seventh Symphony, which he has already recorded with his Canadian orchestra, is one of his calling cards.

He has a sure feel for the slow burn of Bruckner's epic scores. He is not afraid to adopt measured tempos, but crucially can also clearly see the end of the road, the culmination to which Bruckner's broad lines and sometimes seemingly discursive excursions are leading.
This LPO performance was exemplary in its cohesion. It was closely argued but judiciously took its time to make its points.

There was a glow to the string tone, a luminous halo to the entire orchestral sound, enhanced by the solemnity that a quartet of Wagner tubas can bring to the general timbre.

Restraint and energy seemed to coalesce, so that Bruckner's hallmark climaxes, where the resolution of a cadence is tantalisingly postponed through the piling on of new dissonances, grew inexorably towards the final release and resplendent sunburst.

Nézet-Séguin could galvanise the orchestra into granite-like statements and coax it into beguiling lyricism. Buoyancy and firm rhythmic impetus in the scherzo were contrasted with the mellifluous shaping of the intense adagio, and ever present alongside Nézet-Séguin's sense of overall perspective was his ear for subtly drawn details of expression within the complex texture.

On a much smaller scale, Haydn's C major Cello Concerto showed Nézet-Séguin's finesse in the 18th-century classics.

Truls MØrk gave a concentrated, calm and collected account of the solo part, to which the orchestra added a healthy spirit and a range of aptly highlighted instrumental colouring.

Altogether, this was an evening that signalled great things ahead for the LPO.
Geoffrey Norris 

The Evening Standard , UK 12 février 2009  

Nézet-Séguin was worth snapping up
*****
Riveting: Nézet-Séguin conducted an excellent show

The French-Canadian conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin made his European debut as recently as five years ago but the LPO wasted no time in snapping him up as principal guest conductor. This is his first season in that capacity and already he is creating a sensation.

He began last night’s programme by accompanying the Norwegian cellist Truls Mork in a lithe, supple account of Haydn’s C major Concerto.

While Mork is somewhat restrained, even phlegmatic, in demeanour, Nézet-Séguin generates every nuance with his bodily gestures. Sweeping the air, stooping, caressing, he exhorts his players to shape every phrase anew. That was the key also to one of the most remarkable performances of Bruckner’s Seventh Symphony I have ever heard. An intensely physical reading, its long phrases energised rather than coolly objective, it was wrung from the members of the LPO, playing their hearts out for this charismatic young athlete, conducting from memory.

Where a traditional Brucknerian like Bernard Haitink minimises his involvement, creating in the process a monolithic structure as awesome as a cathedral, the Canadian offers something far more subjective — more analogous to a living organism.

Changes of dynamics and tempo are strongly contrasted, phrasing is highly expressive and the nerve endings of the music exposed.

Passage after passage was revealed in a new light, but one stood out. After the massive climax of the slow movement, the Amen-like coda on Wagner tubas, joined by horns, sounded like a magnificently elegiac bellow, a great beast in pain. Then came the wind-down on flute and strings, detumescent and consoling.

Some may prefer their Bruckner to have more gravitas but I found it utterly riveting and emotionally draining. Judge for yourself by listening to the Radio 3 broadcast next Tuesday.

Barry Millington 

Independant Minds/livejournal.com 12 février 2009  

There's almost too much music going on in this great city of ours. As a professional critic, difficult choices have to be made; it just isn't possible to cover everything. But sometimes the biggest surprises come when one is off-duty - like last night at the Royal Festival Hall when the London Philharmonic under its principal guest conductor - Yannick Nézet-Séguin - gave us a truly uplifting account of Bruckner's 7th Symphony. It's been many years since I heard a conductor (a young one at that) so completely in sync and sympathy with the pulse of this music. Too often in Bruckner performances only half the picture emerges. Bruckner, the devout spiritualist, the visionary, is wholeheartedly embraced but Bruckner, the hale and hearty outdoor man, is downplayed. In other words Bruckner performances are invariably too reverent. One mood, one tempo. Not so this Nézet-Séguin performance. The young French-Canadian truly created a gripping odyssey, as surprising as it was inevitable. It was beautiful, passionate, raw, incandescent. The silence of the audience spoke volumes for the atmosphere he created. Even the Wagner tubas were in tune. I would have given it *****.

Check out my interview with Yannick Nézet-Séguin :

http://www.lpo.co.uk/about/nezet_seguin.html

Edward Seckerson 
 

Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
Du 5 au 8 février 2009

Trouw, Pays-Bas 7 février 2009  

Yannick Creates Volcanic Eruption

You can still go. And it is warmly recommended. For tonight and tomorrow afternoon, Yannick Nézet-Séguin will doubtlessly make the volcanoes that are hidden in the symphonies by Beethoven and Berlioz erupt with a lot of force. On Thursday night he did this in a spectacular way. In the last movement of Berlioz' Symphonie fantastique this was to be expected, but in Beethoven's First Symphony it was a surprise.

Between those two churning streams of lava, the Italian soprano Anna Caterina Antonacci sang Berlioz' solo cantata La mort de Cléopâtre, generating smoke and fire. Antonacci is considered to be the most important tragedienne among today's singers. She can make the words burn and adapt her vocal cords to any dramatic colour she wants.

In harmonious cooperation with Nézet-Séguin and the Rotterdam Philharmonic, which gave an electrifying performance, she let Cleopatra die in a spine-chilling way. Berlioz' music is bizarre, even hallucinatory now and then. The proud widow of Julius Caesar and Marc Antony ends her life in a grand way and asks the great pharaohs if she is worthy enough to enter their pyramids. Considering Antonacci's unique and magnificent performance this should be no problem.

Nézet-Séguin is in the middle of a Beethoven cycle in Rotterdam. During this concert, Beethoven's First symphony was linked very inventively to Berlioz' "First", which is what the Symphonie fantastique in fact is. The classical bud in Beethoven's music, bursts open in a romantic and fantastic way in Berlioz' score. It is wonderful to see how the conductor reveals this connection in his interpretations.

The phrasings, the tempos, the details and the energy were awesomely perfect. Berlioz' 'Witches' Sabbath'  trembled, screamed, shook and boiled until the witches' kettle almost exploded. Of course this all but happened, and that too is proof of the perfection of this performance. Superb!
Peter van der Lint 
(Traduit du néerlandais : Geertje Hoekstra) 

NRC, Pays-Bas 7 février 2009  

Berlioz with Terror and Grace

A phenomenally good concert programme may be performed every five, six years. Therefore it was appropriate that Yannick Nézet-Séguin repeated the combination of music by the revolutionary Beethoven with two pieces by the young avant-gardist Hector Berlioz: the lyrical scene La mort de Cléopâtre (1829) and the Symphonie fantastique that was written immediately after it in 1830. It is a combination that was earlier programmed by his predecessor Gergiev in 2003. Berlioz' works are very evocative and not only anticipate his operas Les Troyens (1895) and La damnation de Faust (1846) but also the works of Strauss and Mahler.
 
Gergiev started the programme with Beethoven's Die Weihe des Hauses. Nézet-Séguin surpassed him with the energetically stirred up First Symphony, which was performed with lots of character, and even sounded "authentic". Some time ago, the new Rotterdam Music Director performed an unrestrainedly explosive Seventh.

The Italian soprano Anna Caterina Antonacci, with her easy, radiant high register and her beautifully dark low register, dramatically performed the Egyptian queen Cleopatra's poison suicide. Cleopatra is embarrassed and disillusioned after her defeat against the Romans, but when she sighs for the last time "César", the orchestra shudders.

The Symphonie fantastique is a world, a life in itself. Nézet-Séguin conducted it with a lot of flair. The first movement, 'Rêveries-passions' could have been more surprising, but 'Un bal' had the right suppleness and waltzing gracefulness. Highlight is the melancholy quietude of the 'Scène aux champs', existential loneliness only Berlioz could compose. The demoniac finale 'Songe d'une nuit du Sabbat', with its shrill 'Witches' Sabbath', is a test case for the winds. The Rotterdam winds have got what it takes.
Kasper Jansen 
(Traduit du néerlandais : Geertje Hoekstra) 

De Volkskrant, Pays-Bas 7 février 2009  

Hellish Fanfares with a Graceful Undercurrent

Delusions and delirious dreams or stylised turmoil in classical form: Yannick Nézet-Séguin, the new Music Director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic, knows how to deal with both. The hallucinations are from Hector Berlioz, the clear language Beethoven's. The two combine very well, which is not surprising since Berlioz was a great admirer of Beethoven.

Six months after the official start of his tenure, Nézet-Séguin, the 33-year-old daredevil from Canada, is completely at home in Rotterdam. But what we hear from him, is   repertoire that fits him like a glove: works by composers who were not yet 30, and who had passionate temperaments. In Beethoven's First Symphony this becomes especially evident in the effervescent optimism of the performance, in which Yannick, as the young conductor is popularly called, brings forward a wide range of shades and colours. He seduces, he stirs, he coaxes the winds to soar over the strings and the other way around, but he never forces and always remains courteous.
 
Berlioz' music is much more impulsive, but Yannick also knows how to channel this composer's fantastic eruptions. In La mort de Cléopâtre [...] the soprano Anna Caterina Antonacci naturally took the lead. Her performance, full of melancholy and bitterness, was of an uninterrupted intensity, which made the audience in de Doelen listen in breathless silence. During the musical cardiogram in which the orchestra taps away the last minutes of Cleopatra's life, Yannick kept the tension perfectly.

The Symphonie fantastique, Berlioz' obsessed love expressed in music, was the impressive finale of the evening. Again the conductor and the orchestra gave a performance in which the audacity of the composer was given its full due without disturbing the balance and the self control. This major work contains many extremes, ranging from gallant and graceful dances to fascinating, vaguely changing harmonies, and from peaceful stillness, so quiet it is  almost beyond the limit of audibility, to the hellish fanfares of the Witches' Sabbath. And Yannick achieves it with an undercurrent of gracefulness that was usually hard to find in the interpretations of his predecessor Valery Gergiev.

Frits van der Waa 
(Traduit du néerlandais : Geertje Hoekstra) 

Algemeen Dagblad, Pays-Bas 7 février 2009  

Soprano with Emotional Berlioz in de Doelen

Her voice filled de Doelen with apparent ease, her timbre was on the cool side. In this case, a cool timbre is an advantage, because before you know it this piece becomes sentimental. Here dies a queen.
 
Anna Caterina Antonacci [...] sang Berlioz' cantata La mort de Cléopâtre expressively, beautifully articulated and most of all in a dignified way. The accompaniment by Yannick Nézet-Séguin and the RPhO was expressive as well. At the end, the cold wind that blew over the string section was spine-chilling.
 
However, compared to the Symphonie fantastique, Cleopatra's death is a cabinet piece. Because the Symphonie fantastique is about Berlioz himself. It is a journey through the emotional life of a wronged romantic hero, or a disturbed genius. The performance was formidable, exciting, fascinating. With four rustling harps and entrancing strings in 'Un bal', and with Nézet as the perfect maitre de ballet. But he does more: he takes things to a higher plane. Like the woodwinds who were in excellent shape. Everything was magnified: the 'Scène aux champs' was even more sinister than usual, the 'March to the scaffold' almost festive, the 'Witches' Sabbath' crazier than crazy.

An uncompromising performance like this one, makes the memory of what happened earlier in the evening fade away quickly. But Beethovens' First Symphony held its own. Here too the performance was excellent. A magnificent concert.
Ger van der Tang 
(Traduit du néerlandais : Geertje Hoekstra) 
 

L’Orchestre de Chambre d’Écosse
Mendelssohn : Elijah
29 et 30 janvier 2009

The Edinburgh Journal 8 février 2009  

“Joined by a sizeable SCO chorus and soloists, the orchestra makes their passion and understanding of the music apparent from the opening. Conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin is a joy to watch, making his intentions clear while holding a compelling focus throughout.”

“ It is performances such as this one that maintain the genre of Oratorio, and open up such works to new audiences. This fantastic Mendelssohn celebration continues in style.”

Sarah Mitchell 

Seen and heard, U.K. 3 février 2009  

“it would be hard to imagine a more essentially exciting performance than the one given in Edinburgh this week.  The star, again, was the exciting young conductor, Yannick Nézet-Séguin, who did such a great job with Mendelssohn’s Reformation Symphony last weekend.  His sense of drama gave the work a real shot in the arm, particularly in the climactic moments of the story, such as the contest on Mount Carmel, or the moment when the Lord passes by the mouth of the cave.  He is clearly convinced by this work: the architectural grasp of the overture was compelling, as was the sheer excitement of Is not his word like a fire?  Quieter moments have time to breathe, though, such as the gently questioning aria that begins Part Two.”

Simon Thompson 

The Guardian London, U.K. 2 février 2009  

*****

“Nézet-Séguin took the slow burn of the first part of Mendelssohn’s oratorio (something that can sink many a performance) and turned it into a gradual, inexorable buildup of momentum that was sustained throughout.  In the process, he showed Elijah to be far from the stodgy Victorian relic it is sometimes said to be, but a vital, intensely dramatic work.  This was not a revisionist, small-scale performance; those who like their Mendelssohn delivered with pared-down clarity would probably have found it over the top.  Yet, though it was luxuriant, it was not wilful; the weightiness and grandeur never came at the expense of the litheness of the performance.”

“Bringing his customary attention to detail to play on a vast canvas, Nézet-Séguin made the smallest gestures and phrases seem vitally important.  He elicited from the SCO Chorus a performance perhaps more sensitive than anything it has done in recent years.”

“this was one of those rare occasions when every aspect of the performance coalesced into a greater whole.”

Rowena Smith 

The Herald, Glasgow, Scotland, U.K. 2 février 2009  

*****

“this young genius of a conductor did on Friday with his magnificent battalion of vocal and orchestral musicians ...  a performance of unremitting focus, unwavering clarity and absolute assuredness of purpose”

“This was Elijah reinvented and rediscovered; a dramatic journey through anguish and despair to radiance and serenity, projected through the wondrous voices of some of the best singers in the world”

Michael Tumelty 

The Scotsman 31 janvier 2009  

*****

“Under the impressive baton of Yannick Nézet-Séguin – his second successive week with the SCO – detail was watchword.  From the chorus, only marginally stifled by its rearmost position onstage, he drew a stunning clarity that gave meaning to every distinct word.  This was theatre of the mind.  The unanswered fanaticism of the priests of Baal and the terror of the smitten Israelites were presented with gripping realism.”

“On the technical front, tuning was immaculate, Nézet-Séguin visibly insisting on pinpoint accuracy of attack.  So much for the backbone of the work, inspired too by an on-form SCO which responded instantly to the conductor’s exploration of every powerful nuance in Mendelssohn’s masculine score.”

“In every respect, this Elijah was a tour de force.”

Kenneth Walton 

Edinburghguide 30 janvier 2009  

4 stars on 5

“Under the baton of the exuberant French-Canadian conductor Yannick Nezet-Seguin, the whole performance with the Scottish Chamber Orchestra, soloists and chorus was memorably enthralling.”

Barbara Bryan 
 

L’Orchestre de Chambre d’Écosse
Tournée en Écosse
21 au 24 janvier 2009

Seen and heard, U.K. 29 janvier 2009  

Few young conductors on the international circuit are arousing as much interest as Yannick Nézet-Séguin just now. Recent feathers in his cap include replacing Gergiev as Music Director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic, and becoming Principal Guest Conductor of the London Philharmonic, as well as many commitments in his native Montreal. The SCO have done us all a service by bringing him to Scotland to cast his energetic vision on these Romantic staples. He is scheduled to conduct Elijah at the end of this week: if this concert is anything to go by then it will be a surprising and exciting reading indeed.

Nézet-Séguin’s style is characterised above all by a compelling sense of energy and thrust. His gymnastics on the podium are exhausting to look at (no wonder that he was drenched in perspiration by the end of the evening!) but he is one of the few conductors I have seen where watching him genuinely enriches the experience of listening. With most conductors the nuts and bolts are taken care of in rehearsal; this young man makes you think that he continues to create new things in the crucible of the performance.

Manfred started as he meant to go on: with a compulsive drive that feels unstoppable.  The opening three chords exploded off the page as if we had joined in mid-way through a conversation, and the main allegro surged forward with the passionate intensity befitting Byron’s hero. It suited this music brilliantly, especially the poignant drama of the tempestuous strings. Similarly, the Piano Concerto was stamped with an unmistakably extrovert feel. Angelich’s opening tumble down the keyboard felt almost out of control and the first movement seemed to career towards the cadenza. It was certainly exhilarating, though I couldn’t help but feel that some of the sentiment and subtlety of the work got lost en route. This was certainly true in the Intermezzo, which here felt almost brash, except for the marvelously distinguished contribution of the cellos. It wasn’t helped that the dynamic level had very little variation at all throughout the concerto: both orchestra and soloist played at a steady forte or mezzo forte from beginning to end. This wasn’t a problem for the finale, which really danced, particularly in the coda which had an irresistible skip to it. I got to the end feeling excited and exhilarated, but also a little drained. As a coda Angelich played Träumerei, which was everything the concerto was not: soft, nuanced and subtle.

However, the conductor’s gifts for drama found a natural home in the Mendelssohn. This work, written originally to mark the tercentenary of the Augsburg Protestant Confession of 1530, is all about struggle, particularly in its first movement where Nézet-Séguin’s natural energy drove the piece like a dynamo. Here there was subtlety, of a kind: the gentle strains of the “Dresden Amen” alternated with the declamatory brass of the introduction creating a sense of tension from which the rest of the movement drew its energy. The most interesting moment was the reappearance of the Dresden Amen at the end of the development when it seemed, albeit temporarily, to pacify the recapitulation. The Scherzo bounced along in an almost bucolic way, while the aching slow movement felt almost like a lost aria, the strings again shining magnificently. Nézet-Séguin showed a convincingly architectural grasp of the work, building towards the emergence of the chorale (Ein Feste Burg) at the start of the finale, stealing in gently on the winds before building, inexorably, to dominate the movement, and its symphonic treatment was most convincing. Finally it blazed golden in the closing pages. Nézet-Séguin’s youthful exuberance suits this music perfectly, and both he and the orchestra were given an especially enthusiastic ovation at the end. I can’t wait to hear what he does with Elijah!
Simon Thompson 

The Guardian, London, U.K. 28 janvier 2009  

5 out of 5

Mendelssohn's Reformation Symphony is largely overlooked and unloved, often dismissed as an occasional work rather than an enduring masterpiece. Yet, played well, the symphony rarely fails to come across as something more special.

The Scottish Chamber Orchestra has had interesting things to say about the symphony in the past, notably under then principal conductor Joseph Swensen. On this occasion the conductor was the young Canadian Yannick Nézet-Séguin, who made an extraordinary impression on his first appearance with the orchestra a couple of seasons ago. Here, in the first of two programmes with the SCO, he again demonstrated what made that first concert so memorable: his remarkable rapport with the orchestra.

Following an exquisitely crafted performance of Schumann's Manfred Overture, Nézet-Séguin and the orchestra provided Nicholas Angelich's fluid, soft-edged account of the composer's Piano Concerto with as near to perfect an accompaniment as one could wish for. In its wake, the Reformation could have been in danger of being an anticlimax. Instead, it was the performance of the evening. Conducting from memory, Nézet-Séguin laid bare the symphony's drama; the quotation of the Dresden Amen a mysterious, whispered moment of calm in the turmoil of the first movement. Precision and control were key - nothing was overplayed or overstated. In the wrong hands, the finale's quotation of the Lutheran chorale Ein' Feste Burg can seem like needless bombast; here it came across with a warmth and humanity that was entirely convincing and deeply moving. The Mendelssohn bicentenary will be fortunate indeed if it contains more performances of this quality; it will be fascinating to see what Nézet-Séguin makes of Elijah later this week.
Rowena Smith 

The Herald, Scotland, U.K. 26 janvier 2009  

PROPHECY in this game is a dangerous pastime, but let me give you a tip. This Friday, get to the City Hall for the SCO’s performance of Elijah, with its world-class series of soloists. They are at the top of their game.

But there is another reason, and that is Yannick Nézet-Séguin, the young French-Canadian conductor, one of the most energetic and sought-after conductors working today.  His musicality, which informed every nuance of the programme he conducted with the SCO on Friday, is completely natural and emanated every pore of his body.

He is the complete conductor; the genuine article is every department of his craft. With the SCO at its most responsive, Nézet-Séguin – in a programme that opened with Schumann’s Manfred and closed with a refreshed and compelling account of Mendelssohn’s  Reformation Symphony – laid out his artistic credentials.

The young man’s expressive art, surely, is unparalleled. He moulds phrases, dynamics, colours and accents, weaving them into a seamless, unforced and indissoluble unity. I have seldom heard playing of the supple, pliable quality that he secured from the SCO.

And I have never heard an accompaniment so scrupulously integrated as that provided by Nézet-Séguin for the breathtakingly liberated version of Schumann’s Piano Concerto, played by Nicholas Angelich with a magnetic mix of power and poetry.

Friday night, Elijah. Be there to witness a wonder of the conducting world.
Michael Tumelty 

The Scotsman, Edinburgh 26 janvier 2009  

IN THE wrong hands, the weighty combination of Schumann's Manfred Overture and Piano Concerto with Mendelssohn's Reformation Symphony could so easily have descended into the musical equivalent of a stodgy meal. But we know enough from Yannick Nézet-Séguin's recordings (and from his previous encounter with the SCO) to have expected nothing of the sort from this conductor, who has replaced Valery Gergiev as musical director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra.

Every one of his performances on Friday was notable for its probing clarity and subtle dynamism. Nézet-Séguin's meticulous control of the textures in the Manfred Overture avoided every potential trap, giving a delicious airiness to its melodic phrases and solid textures. Its most satisfying outcome was the sensuous ambivalence he achieved between the robust and contemplative characters feeding through Schumann's Byron-inspired score. If the SCO strings sounded a little under-nourished to this point, they opened up for the same composer's Piano Concerto. This performance brought with it another shining star in the form of American pianist Nicholas Angelich. 

Strolling onstage like a benign giant, Angelich gave a brilliantly individual account of the concerto. To introduce so many fresh thoughts to such an old warhorse of the repertoire was an extraordinary achievement. Sheer strength of body made possible an infinite range of tone, but it was the bold mannerisms with which he shaped the melodic line – a teasing unpredictability – that overcame the famously deceptive pitfalls that litter this music.

The spotlight turned again on the conductor for Mendelssohn's glorious Reformation Symphony. And once again the emphasis was on communicating the music's silvery finesse, though never at the expense of its stoical opulence.

Nézet-Séguin is back this week with the SCO in Mendelssohn's Elijah. What a mouth-watering prospect.
Kenneth Walton 

Edinburghguide.com 26 janvier 2009  

The guest conductor at this Scottish Chamber Orchestra concert was the exuberant French-Canadian Yannick Nezet-Seguin who first made his debut with the orchestra in April 2007.  Bringing out the best in the orchestra, his passionate energy quite mirrored the turbulent emotions which permeated the compositions chosen for the programme.

The performance began with Robert Schumann's 'Manfred' overture.  Composed in 1848-49, it was first performed in 1852 with the composer at the helm.  The overture forms part of Schumann's incidental music based on Lord Byron's poem of the  troubled, tormented Faustian soul who wanders the Bernese Alps.
Like the character in Manfred, Schumann too was a tormented soul and empathised totally with Byron's "restless, wandering, distracted man, tormented by fearful thoughts". And this agony of emotions is all too prevalent in his powerful overture, which ends on a dark, foreboding note.

Next on the programme was Schumann's piano concerto in A minor, played by the American pianist Nicholas Angelich, who has performed on many occasions with the conductor Nezet-Seguin.

Composed as a showcase for Schumann's wife Clara, this concerto is one of the most beautiful piano concertos ever written and orchestra and conductor, coupled with Angelich's accomplished interpretation of the rolling chord structures and the appassionatta passages resulted in a memorable rendition of this work.  For an encore, Angelich exquisitely played Traumerei (Dreaming) from Schumann's Scenes of Childhood.

The final piece, where the SCO quite excelled itself, was Mendelssohn's Symphony No 5 in D major entitled 'Reformation'.  Performed as part of this year's bicentenary celebrations of Mendelssohn's birth the 'Reformation' Symphony is a powerful piece of music.  Conducted in 1832 by the composer, the Symphony is based on (16th century) Martin Luther's setting of Psalm 46.

Majestic in places, with some frenetic passages, and resounding brass segments the concert concluded with a tour de force performance by Nezet-Seguin and the orchestra.
Barbara Bryan  

The Courier, St. Andrews 23 janvier 2009  

A fitting tribute to pay Mendelssohn

THE SCOTTISH Chamber Orchestra’s (SCO) Mendelssohn 200 is a series of concerts celebrating the 200th anniversary of the composer’s birth.

Thursday’s concert in St Andrews saw Mendelssohn paired with Schumann by the SCO in the Younger Hall.

The Manfred overture is one of Schumann’s finest orchestral works, but the orchestra and its conductor, Yannick Nezet-Seguin, gave it a new lustre—from the opening chords to the subdued ending.

The other items written alongside this overture have long since died a death, but this fine work deserves its everlasting popularity.

Schumann’s piano concerto has seldom been performed and obscured unfairly by its romantic counterparts.

However, it is a marvellous work, which the performance of Nicholas Angelich confirmed.

The orchestra was no slouch either, with one of the highlights being the exchange between it and the soloist in the second movement.

Mendelssohn came into his own in the second half of the evening.

His fifth symphony is magnificent work, but it shares the same fate as the Schumann concerto, and is overshadowed by the Italian and Scottish symphonies.

Thank goodness the SCO decided to share this with us, with a performance that could easily send it shooting up the popularity charts.

Nezet-Seguin seemed to play every note, such was his ebullient direction, but while such energy from other conductors might have detracted it only added positively to the overall effect.

The Scherzo’s rustic charm and the short and smooth as silk andante paved the way for the final movement’s chorale, Ein Feste Burg, started by the woodwind, developed and finished in exhilarating fashion by the whole orchestra.

This is the SCO’s only visit to St Andrews for its Mendelssohn celebrations, but if the other concerts in this series are as good as this, a fitting tribute will have been paid.
Garry Fraser  

Hi-Arts. co.uk (The Highlands Arts journal) 22 janvier 2009  

GEORGINA COBURN admires the podium style and musical direction of rising star conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin

A musical interpretation of Byron’s dramatic poem, Robert Schumann’s Manfred Overture opened the programme, followed by the same composer’s Piano Concerto in A Minor. A work infused with Romantic heroism and brooding characterisation, the Manfred sees Schumann exploring the range of the orchestra and concludes beautifully in a hush of melodious sound.

Schumann’s A Minor Piano Concerto relies less on keyboard gymnastics characteristic of 19th century piano works and infinitely more on creating a meaningful dialogue between soloist and orchestra. The opening movement is particularly beautiful and pianist Nicholas Angelich delivered a performance of great sensitivity and subtlety, with exquisite interplay between piano and woodwind. Written for Schumann’s beloved wife Clara, who performed as soloist at its premiere in 1845, the A Minor Concerto is a passionate and thoughtful work brought to life on this occasion by an equally engaged performance.

(...) In the third movement (of the Symphony No. 5 in D Major, Op.107), an Andante in G Minor, mellow melodic strings and solo flute give a more introspective and expressive flavour to the work. The unity of the orchestra under the direction of guest conductor Yannick Nézet- Séguin was evident throughout, and despite not entering the concert hall a Mendelssohn fan, the SCO’s performance encouraged my appreciation and desire to hear more of the composer’s work.

It is easy to see why Canadian conductor Yannick Nézet- Séguin is so much in demand worldwide, an appeal that extends beyond his lively, almost balletic style to sensitive and compelling articulation of the musical score. It would be wonderful to see him at the helm of different touring orchestras exploring a range of musical styles and I hope this will be one of many future visits to the Highlands. (...)

Georgina Coburn  

Wiener Symphoniker
18 et 19 décembre 2008

Osterreich 21 décembre 2008  

Retenez ce nom
Des débuts convaincants avec le Wiener Symphoniker

Retenez ce nom : Yannick Nézet-Séguin (33 ans), un Canadien français de Montréal. Depuis septembre, il succède à Gergiev comme chef de la Philharmonie de Rotterdam et occupe le poste de principal chef invité du London Philharmonic Orchestra. Il a fait sensation l’été dernier à Salzbourg en dirigeant l’opéra Roméo et Juliette de Gounod.

Il débute maintenant à Vienne, à la salle du Konzerthaus, dans une programmation passionnante: des œuvres de Ravel (La Valse, Ma mère l’oye), de Bartok (le Troisième Concerto pour piano avec le soliste Piotr Anderszewski), de Debussy (La Mer). Les musiciens du Wiener Symphoniker semblent aussi inspirés, aussi animés, techniquement aussi parfaits et en harmonie que lors de leur rencontre avec Gustavo Dudamel, il y a un an et demi. Et ce n’est pas une comparaison faite au hasard.

L’impact. Yannick Nézet-Séguin dirige avec un engagement corporel total, offrant au public une solide performance de pantomime. Mais au-delà de cet effet, il arrive à animer les musiciens avec un instinct des plus sûrs, produisant ainsi un maximum d’impact. Il arrive à mettre en valeur les subtilités et les finesses sans endiguer le flot de la musique et ose de courageux « ritardandi »pour accentuer les sommets musicaux. Ainsi, toute la représentation visuelle des oeuvres françaises se colore, prend presque une plasticité permettant de découvrir la richesse des détails. L’ovation finale préparée par les musiciens à leur jeune chef invité relève, selon moi, de plus qu’une reconnaissance, mais également du désir de le revoir.
Karl Löbl  
(Traduit de l'allemand : Marie-Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard) 

Wiener Zeitung 20 décembre 2008  

Des couleurs rendues avec une profonde acuité

« Des points de vue structurel et sonore, sa direction d’orchestre rend pleinement  justice à la musique de Ravel, de Debussy et de Bartok. »

« Dans La Valse de Ravel… de rigoureux équilibres sont établis entre les tempi et les transitions amenées avec finesse insufflent de la vie à cette partition aux aspects multidimensionnels. »

« Les musiciens de l’Orchestre symphonique de Vienne jouent  de manière impressionnante, comme s’ils étaient partenaires à part entière du pianiste. On obtient ainsi un amalgame sonore parfait entre les bois et le piano, particulièrement à la fin du premier mouvement. »

« Avec La Mer de Debussy, Nézet-Séguin arrive à réunir à la fois la grandeur et les détails de l’œuvre, la profondeur et la clarté des couleurs sonores. Le concert se termine sous un tonnerre d’applaudissements. »
Rainer Elstner  
(Traduit de l'allemand : Marie-Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard) 
 

Orchestre de Philadelphie
11 décembre 2008

Philadelphia Inquirer 13 décembre 2008  

“In orchestra years, a conductor in his 30s is a mere toddler, still framing out basic concepts of cause and effect as he moves through the world. Yannick Nézet-Séguin is no toddler. He's 33, but already he has a sophisticated set of skills. The Montrealer, who made a Philadelphia Orchestra debut of considerable impact Thursday night, has the full concept of ensemble control under his belt.“

“With some gorgeous phrase-shaping and meticulously detailed dynamics, he put a personal imprint on Rachmaninoff's Piano Concerto No. 2. Add to all this an unpretentious, smiling, journeyman stage persona, and what comes across the footlights in Nézet-Séguin is an extremely promising talent.”

“One of the nice things about Nézet-Séguin - music director-designate of the Rotterdam Philharmonic - is that he doesn't make a spectacle of himself, even if he is a very physical presence. He made his mark mostly in an impressive climax here and there, and by taking a chance with a severe accelerando at the end of the third movement that paid off stunningly.”
Peter Dobrin  
 

Orchestre National de France
4 décembre 2008

Diapason Février 2009  

National is back

« Symphonie de Bizet caracolante ».

« La Tragédie de Salomé de Florent Schmitt, clou de la soirée, est sulfureuse et l’imaginaire saturé de couleurs jusque dans sa frayeur conclusive. Il est admirable d’entendre cette phalange retrouver ses timbres et équilibres dans son répertoire sous une direction aussi inspirée ».

Jean-Charles Hoffelé  

concertonet.com 5 décembre 2008  

Musique française au National

Avec à sa tête un chef québécois de trente-trois ans, le National n’en a pas moins joué un programme typique de ceux qu’il aurait pu donner dans les années 1950 – ou du moins de l’idée qu’on peut s’en faire –, entièrement consacré à la musique française. Avec une gestuelle nerveuse et extravertie qui rappelle celle d’Emmanuel Krivine, Yannick Nézet-Séguin confère l’élan nécessaire à la juvénile Symphonie en ut (1855) de Bizet.

(…) D’une baguette plus transparente que capiteuse, animant la partition avec un grand sens dramatique, Nézet-Séguin fait ressortir en quoi cette musique (La Tragédie de Salomé de Stravinski) renvoie bien plus à Debussy ou Ravel qu’à Strauss, dont la Salomé n’est antérieure que de deux ans.

Simon Corley  

www.concertclassic.com 4 décembre 2008  

Éloge et défense de la musique française

A trente-trois ans, le chef québécois Yannick Nézet-Séguin, est une étoile montante de la direction d’orchestre. Outre son activité à la tête de l’Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal, il assure les fonctions de Chef principal invité au Philharmonique de Londres et vient de succéder à Valery Gergiev à Rotterdam. Sa réputation n’est pas un leurre à en juger par sa prestation au TCE avec l’Orchestre National de France. Dynamique, il insuffle à la Symphonie en ut de Bizet, composée par un jeune homme de dix-sept ans, une verve, un élan, un éclat orchestral qui va même parfois au-delà du caractère de cette œuvre aux parfums subtils mais non insistants. …

En deuxième partie, La Tragédie de Salomé, op. 50 de Florent Schmitt (1870-1958), bien moins connue que les œuvres précédentes, retrouve ses lettres de noblesse, sous la baguette claire et précise de Yannick Nézet-Séguin. Créée en 1909, elle ne doit qu’au relatif oubli dans lequel est tombé le compositeur (des propos antisémites y sont peut-être pour quelque chose) le peu d’intérêt qui lui est porté au concert. Pourtant, l’opulence orchestrale, la luxuriance des couleurs, l’impact dramatique, l’orientalisme sublimé en font une partition de tout premier ordre dont Stravinsky d’ailleurs s’inspira. L’Orchestre National se déchaîne (Danse des éclairs, Danse de l’effroi) sous l’impulsion énergique d’un chef dont on n’a pas fini d’entendre parler.

Michel Le Naour  
 

Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
28 novembre 2008

Seen and heard International Concert review 30 novembre 2008  

“Yannick made it clear once more that he can excel in repertoire (L’oiseau de feu de Stravinsky) that seemed to exist in only one version in Rotterdam (Gergiev’s).”

“Yannick found a lot of interesting details in the accompaniment (Prokofiev’s Second Violin Concerto) but kept the orchestra in perfect balance with the soloist. He reminded me in this way of the young Simon Rattle, also a conductor who treats his accompaniments seriously and enjoys to make music together.”

“Again (in Ravel’s Ma Mère l’Oye), Yannick showed his total command by highlighting certain details, relishing every phrase.”

“To conclude: this was an immensely inspiring and rewarding concert.”

Bas van Westerop  

NRC 29 novembre 2008  

Yannick Nézet-Séguin Surprises Again

Even though Yannick Nézet-Séguin led several concerts before he made his official debut as Music Director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra two weeks ago, his repertoire and his conducting style keep surprising.

His last concert was full of 'fireworks' and ended with an already 'historic' rendering of Beethoven's Seventh Symphony, which was performed with unbridled energy in the style of Carlos Kleiber. The concert will be released on CD.

Last weekend, the concert in de Doelen had a much more subdued character, with music by Stravinsky (Firebird Second Suite) Prokofiev (Second Violin Concerto) and Ravel (Ma mère l'oye). The program consisted of music composed in a period of 25 years: 1909-1935, one half of the concert Russian music, the other half French.

Nézet-Séguin dedicated the French part to Jean Fournet, who died earlier this month and who was Music Director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic from 1968-1973. And again the new Canadian Music Director surprised with his almost accentless Dutch.

Subtlety and refined colours characterized this music that often had a chamber music-like character. It was brilliantly performed and with constant tension.
The Russian-American concertmaster Igor Gruppman [...] excelled in Prokofiev's Second Violin Concerto, which he performed with sensuous lyricism and refined virtuosity. Sometimes his violin sounded like a flight of warbling birds high in a blue sky.

Combined with Stravinsky's Firebird and the chirping sounds in Ravel's wonderfully performed  Ma mère l'oye it was as if birds were the theme of the concert.

But there wore no birds at all in Les offrandes oubliées of bird composer Messiaen. This only 10-minute-long 'symphonic meditation' is typical of the religious composer: two thoughtful slow movements (The Cross and The Eucharist) separated by a vehement, shocking movement: The Sin.

Kasper Jansen  
(Traduit du néerlandais par Geertje Hoekstra) 
 

Deutsches Symphonie Orchester Berlin
21 novembre 2008

Le journal Süddeutsche Zeitung de Munich 25 novembre 2008  

(…) Nézet-Séguin sait exactement l’espace qu’il peut accorder en délectation amoureuse aux instruments à cordes, sans jamais perdre le fil conducteur. Avec de puissants mouvements qui entraînent tout son corps, il maintient une courte bride sur les musiciens, force chaque instrument à atteindre la précision et impose sa conception contemporaine de la musique en 3 dimensions.

(…) le ballet Jeux de Debussy , qui a été composé, comme un match de tennis, avec de nombreux rebondissements, Nézet-Séguin ne s’en tient pas aux gestes de politesse habituels. Il dirige sans qu’il y ait de subtilités érotiques ni d’élégants mouvements des joueurs portant des collants d’époque. Le chef  conçoit plutôt l’oeuvre, terminée en 1912, comme un sport de haute voltige avec des services difficiles exécutés en plein soleil du midi. Les trompettes retentissent comme des rayons de soleil éblouissants. Devant l’extrême luminosité des cordes jouant à l’unisson, on ferme instinctivement les yeux pour éviter d’être aveuglé. Il en est de même pour la célèbre deuxième suite du ballet pastoral Daphnis et Chloé de Ravel qui ne se perd pas dans les dédales des époques antiques ou rococo, mais au contraire, fait ressortir des détails fascinants et devient presque une composition contemporaine. Déjà dans le mouvement intitulé Lever du Jour , il semble que chaque cri de l’oiseau matinal qu’évoque le désordre sonore des bois proclame une force vitale irrésistible. La Danse générale qui conclut le tout, dans lequel les maîtres anciens comme Riccardo Chailly entendaient les premiers échos de l’écroulement de notre monde, est ici transformée chez Nézet-Séguin en extase de sons et de rythmes. La vie étant tellement belle et immodérée lorsque l’on a 30 ans.

Jörg Königsdorf 
(Traduit de l'allemand : Marie-Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard) 

The Montreal Gazette 25 novembre 2008  

Nézet-Séguin is praised in Berlin

Orchestre Métropolitain music director Yannick Nézet-Séguin has created a sensation in Berlin with the Deutsches Symphonie-Orchester - the ensemble Kent Nagano gave up to accept the MSO's directorship. "The music world has a new hero," lauded Klaus Geitel in the Berliner Morgenpost. He praised the conductor's "temperament, energy and penetration" in Tchaikovsky's Francesca da Rimini as well as his "descriptive" baton technique. Geitel also had positive words for Debussy's ballet Jeux (the orchestra played "most beautifully") and Ravel's Daphnis et Chloé Suite No. 2. The Danse générale of the latter had "breathtaking force." Lisa Batiashvili was the soloist in this Friday concert, in Prokofiev's Violin Concerto No. 2.

The Frankfurter Allgemeine remarked on the huge ovation that followed the Ravel blockbuster and called the conductor "Das Wunder Yannick" - an apparent reference to a nickname of the iconic 20th-century German conductor, Herbert von Karajan. While Nézet-Séguin was not conducting the Berlin Philharmonic, he was leading the DSO in the Berlin Philharmonie, a hall Karajan had a role in designing. The Allgemeine critic also reported on the presence of Nézet-Séguin's parents in the audience. Another widely read newspaper, Die Welt, carried an interview of the "merry, compact" Canadian, whose name apparently suggests Breton origins. The author of this interview, Manuel Brug, discusses his lively podium style and recalls his success at the immensely prestigious Salzburg summer festival. Brug points out that Nézet-Séguin has worked since 2000 with the OM in "in the shadow of its big brother," the MSO. This was an advantageous situation, since he could deepen his knowledge and extend his range without "big-city scrutiny."

Music director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic and principal guest conductor of the London Philharmonic, Nézet-Séguin is adding many prestigious orchestras to his guest-conducting schedule. In December, he conducts in Paris (Orchestre National de France), Philadelphia (Philadelphia Orchestra) and Vienna (Vienna Symphony).

Next season, the 33-year-old Montrealer will make his debut with the Munich Philharmonic, an orchestra Nagano led last weekend as a guest conductor. Nagano is music director of the cross-town Bavarian State Opera and Bavarian State Orchestra.

Arthur Kaptainis 

Berliner Zeitung 24 novembre 2008  

L’homme en mouvement
Yannick Nézet-Séguin, la jeune étoile montante, a dirigé le Deutsches Symphonie-Orchester

Ce vendredi, la tignasse du chef d’orchestre canadien Yannick Nézet-Séguin avait des allures audacieuses à la Tintin. Le jeune chef âgé de 33 ans avait l’air d’un poussin sortant de sa coquille. Comme la règle usuelle veut qu’un chef d’orchestre n’atteigne le sommet de son art qu’à partir de soixante-dix ans, Nézet-Séguin apparaît véritablement comme un néophyte. Mais il a déjà fait la preuve de ses nombreuses habilités et le monde international de la grande musique vient de s’en apercevoir.        

À l’été, Nézet-Séguin a pour ainsi dire sauvé le Festival de Salzbourg qui aurait pu sombrer dans l’insignifiance totale. Et ce grâce à son énergie et à son intelligence musicale dans la direction de l’opéra Roméo et Juliette de Charles Gounod. La rumeur s’est répandue comme une traînée de poudre. Voilà pourquoi la salle de la Philharmonie était pleine à craquer. Voilà aussi pourquoi des critiques musicaux de journaux de toute l’Allemagne étaient présents, ce qui ne survient que très rarement, afin d’assister aux débuts de Yannick Nézet-Séguin avec le Deutsches Symphonie-Orchester.       

Le jeune homme s’est révélé un artiste possédant une grande détermination. Une détermination qui sait aussi manœuvrer adéquatement dans les eaux troubles des processus opposés qui se déroulent en concomitance. On sait tous que le poème symphonique de Peter Tchaïkovski intitulé Francesca da Rimini débute par un conflit entre les forces des bourdons « Liegetöne » et les mouvements linéaires, bien que les bourdons aient tendance à exploser occasionnellement dans un soudain et rude feulement. Sous la direction de Yannick Nézet-Séguin, le Deutsches Symphonie-Orchester a réussi de manière excellente à créer cette tension entre l’immobilité et la subtilité du mouvement.

Même lorsque les sonorités de cette oeuvre, orchestrées de façon dure et brusque, déferlaient en mode Forte ou Fortissimo comme un moteur qui tourne à grande vitesse, la tension n’était pas créée par une pression extérieure. Elle était plutôt constituée par l’élaboration de ce que Tchaïkovski a aménagé en son for intérieur : une superposition raffinée de rythmes et de grandes lignes chantées, qui s’articulent selon les règles du langage poétique. Et cela fut très bien compris par les bois (surtout par les clarinettes!) mais aussi par les cordes du Deutsches Symphonie-Orchester.

Jan Brachmann  
(Traduit de l'allemand : Marie-Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard)  

Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, Francfort 23 novembre 2008  

Le chef d’orchestre Yannick Nézet-Séguin enflamme le Deutsches Symphonie-Orchester

Berlin. Strictement parlant, ce ne sont pas vraiment des débuts. On a déjà entendu le chef d’orchestre Canadien-Français Yannick Nézet-Séguin, âgé de 33 ans, en mars de cette année, diriger l’Orchestre Symphonique de la Radio de Berlin, un bon concert mais qui n’avait pas créé de grands remous. Tout cela se passait avant que ne survienne le « prodige Yannick » à Salzbourg, l’été dernier, lorsque celui-ci, alors illustre inconnu, a brisé l’ennuyeuse monotonie d’une première d’opéra réunissant le gratin dans l’enceinte du manège des Rochers (Felsenreitschule). Dès le lendemain matin, son nom, assez difficile à l’oreille et à la prononciation d’un germanophone, était sur toutes les lèvres. Et ce soir, la salle de la Philharmonie de Berlin était pleine à craquer, même les places rajoutées étaient vendues. Tous les mélomanes que compte cette ville et qui étaient libres ce soir-là s’étaient déplacés, curieux de savoir si le conte de fée allait continuer et si Yannick serait capable de tenir ses promesses.

(…) Au pupitre, la direction d’orchestre est techniquement impeccable. (…) ce concert est comme une fusée qui s’allume étage après étage. Cela s’améliore d’œuvre en œuvre, atteignant des sommets toujours plus élevés au fur et à mesure que le concert avance et que l’on quitte la stratosphère.

(…) Après la pause, le troisième étage de la fusée s’allume comme un feu d’artifice : voici Jeux de Claude Debussy, labyrinthe polyphonique rempli de timbres fous et multicolores. (…) Il y a longtemps que l’on n’a pas entendu le Deutsches Symphonie-Orchester jouer avec une telle limpidité, avec une telle exubérance riche en détails.

(…) La Deuxième suite tirée de Daphnis et Chloé est pure volupté. (…) Les musiciens excités entourent le podium, toute la salle explose et acclame le chef debout.

Eleonore Büning  
(Traduit de l'allemand : Marie-Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard)  

Berliner Morgenpost 23 novembre 2008  

Le nouveau héros au pupitre s’appelle Nézet-Séguin

Dès le début du concert, on est submergé par la musique du XIXe siècle. Yannick-Nézet-Séguin (âgé de 33 ans), est le jeune chef d’orchestre qui a été proclamé nouvelle super star du festival de Salzbourg. Il ouvre son concert avec la Deutsches Symphonie-Orchester dans la salle de la Philharmonie avec une oeuvre de Tchaïkovski que l’on entend assez peu de nos jours : la fantaisie symphonique inspirée de Dante qui d’abord célèbre Francesca da Rimini, puis la pleure pour finalement l’assommer avec un marteau musical. Nézet-Séguin saisit l’oeuvre et fait magnifiquement montre de sa dextérité au bâton.

C’est un chef d’orchestre qui déborde de tempérament, d’énergie et de détermination. Il transmet de façon impressionnante à l’orchestre la manière dont il doit jouer. Le résultat est tout simplement excellent. Il prend peut-être sa forme la plus belle et la plus accomplie dans Jeux,  oeuvre de Debussy rarement jouée, ballet amoureux créé sur scène par Nijinsky et dansé comme un match de tennis, où les rebonds ressemblent à ceux qu’un Boris Becker offrait à la fin de sa carrière. Chez Debussy également, la balle d’amour se retrouve souvent inexorablement à l’extérieur du terrain.

Par la suite, la féérique Lisa Batiashvili a merveilleusement joué le Second Concerto pour violon de Prokofiev, faisant s’épanouir avec esprit et empathie, particulièrement dans le deuxième mouvement, la beauté de toute la sonorité du violon. Nous avons entendu une violoniste de grand niveau qui, surtout dans le mouvement final, a joué avec virtuosité, volupté et une technique séduisante. Elle l’a encore démontré dans sa sélection du rappel,  extrait ravissant et mélancolique du répertoire de sa patrie géorgienne.

Après ces douces mélodies, ce fut Daphnis et Chloé de Ravel, où la danse générale du Finale a explosé avec une force à couper le souffle sous la direction de Nézet-Séguin. Le monde musical possède maintenant un nouveau héros.

Klaus Geitel  
(Traduit de l'allemand : Marie-Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard)  

Der Tagesspiegel, Berlin 23 novembre 2008  

Cet été, il a été consacré comme la star du Festival de Salzbourg et il vient tout juste de succéder à Valery Gergiev à l’Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam. Lors de sa première apparition avec la Deutsches Symphonie-Orchester, les attentes envers Yannick Nézet-Séguin sont très élevées. Devant une salle à guichet fermé de la Philharmonie de Berlin, le jeune Canadien âgé de 33 ans fait son apparition sur scène avec une démarche assurée. Il s’installe au pupitre et il commence à transmettre son énergie à l’orchestre. Sa gestuelle qui incorpore tout l’espace et tout son corps, trouve une dynamique dans le mouvement : en fait, le déploiement des bras n’est pas que du spectacle; il sert à transmettre le pouls inhérent à la musique. Pour Yannick Nézet-Séguin, il en va de même que pour ce qui fut écrit sur le jeune Simon Rattle en 1976, lorsque ce dernier débuta avec le même ensemble (qui s’appelait alors le Radio-Symphonie-Orchester) : « les chefs d’orchestre arrivent, comme les nageurs olympiques, à un perfectionnement technique à un âge toujours plus jeune. Auparavant, ce perfectionnement s’acquérait après de nombreuses années d’expérience et de mise à l’épreuve. » Que ce soit avec Francesca da Rimini de Tchaïkovski, le Second Concerto pour violon de Prokofiev (avec la grandiose Lisa Batiashvili), Jeux de Debussy ou Daphnis et Chloé de Ravel, Nézet-Séguin coordonne avec assurance la multitude de ces nombreuses sonorités. (…)

Frederik Hanssen 
(Traduit de l'allemand : Marie-Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard) 

Berlin-Brandenbourg Kulturradio 22 novembre 2008  

Yannick Nézet-Séguin, chef d’orchestre canadien, a fait des débuts ambitieux avec beaucoup d’assurance au Deutsches Symphonie-Orchester de Berlin. De toute évidence, il sait exactement ce qu’il veut. Avec une large gestuelle, il demande à l’orchestre un engagement maximum et exige aussi une perfection technique dans un programme composé d’oeuvres aux effets saisissants bien que délicats. La fantaisie symphonique rarement jouée de Peter Tchaïkovski, Francesca da Rimini, demande à la fois brio et expressivité. Les deux ballets de Debussy et de Ravel contiennent par contre de pures sonorités magiques et constituent un véritable test d’endurance pour tous les participants.

Yannick Nézet-Séguin aime la précision, ce qu’on peut clairement constater dans Jeux de Claude Debussy. Le chef d’orchestre aime les jeux rythmiques et réussit à reproduire scintillements et vibrations. Il façonne de merveilleux et souples va-et-vient; partant d’un sourire à peine audible, il intensifie graduellement la tension jusqu’au Finale tonitruant.

(…) dans l’interprétation de Francesca da Rimini de Peter Tchaïkovski, Yannick Nézet-Séguin réussit à faire ressortir les effets sonores de l’oeuvre avec une précision qui donne l’impression d’être calculée au millimètre près. Il gère bien les moments fulgurants avec légèreté et précision : la musique chatoie et mugit. (…)

Andreas Göbel 
(Traduit de l'allemand : Marie-Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard) 
 

Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
13, 14 et 15 novembre 2008

De Telegraaf 17 novembre 2008  

During the past decades, traditional symphony orchestras have lost terrain to specialists who explore old music on historic instruments and with performance principles. If there is one orchestra in the Netherlands that can regain its versatility in the short term, it is the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra. In Yannick Nézet-Séguin they have found a Music Director who is just as much at home with Handel as he is with Stravinsky. Such conductors are rare.

This weekend, the young Canadian started his first Rotterdam season triumphantly with a bouncy suite from Handel's Music for the Royal Fireworks.
A series of opera arias by Handel revealed the new chief's sense of style as well. Andreas Scholl sang them, and won the audience over.
The complete orchestra was only on stage for five minutes, for a dazzling performance of Stravinsky's symphonic fantasy Feu d'artifice. The evening ended with Beethoven's Seventh Symphony. Before the summer, Nézet-Séguin gave a brilliant rendering of Beethoven's Third, with which he proved that he has listened carefully to pioneers such as Brüggen and Harnoncourt. 

The Seventh Symphony was at least as enervating as the Third.

Thiemo Wind  
(Traduit du néerlandais par Geertje Hoekstra) 

Trouw 15 novembre 2008  

Yannick Nézet-Séguin is an All-Round Musician.

Is there any modern symphony orchestra that has had the audacity to perform Handel's Music for the Royal Fireworks lately ? For many years now, this baroque high point in music history has been the field of ensembles that have specialized in period performance. Yannick Nézet-Séguin, the new Music Director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra has an "authentic" background himself and just as easily transplants this "specialist" music into the big body of his orchestra.

In the festive programme themed "Fireworks" - it was the official start of the chief's tenure in Rotterdam - Nézet-Séguin demonstrated that he walked in very nice modern shoes, but that those shoes have wonderfully bouncy soles.

In Yannick's hands Handel sounded as "authentic" as possible, with well-considered accents in the second violins, for instance, and with that lovely "dropping feeling" that is so important for this music. It was pompous, glorious and perfect, and the orchestra followed him with visible and audible joy.

(...) the small conductor proved his greatness with Stravinsky's Feu d'artifice and especially with Beethoven's Seventh Symphony. In his Beethoven, Nézet-Séguin demonstrated again how much he has learned from period performance. It was almost as if he wanted to surpass his colleagues in their own field. With an unleashed and very keen orchestra he looked for the boundaries of what is possible. The risks he and his orchestra took with their entries, all worked out. Surprising accents and an admirable ear for balance and long lines characterized this wonderful performance. 

This much concentrated energy is rare on the concert stage. The last movement was not only con brio, but also con fuoco and con all kinds of things! It is not often that you hear firecrackers go off like this.

Peter van der Lint  
(Traduit du néerlandais par Geertje Hoekstra) 

De Volkskrant 15 novembre 2008  

Fireworks of a Daredevil

Handel's opera music is in good hands with Nézet-Séguin. With a little accent here and a small ritardando there he knows exactly how to handle Handel's Sprechgezang, and he effortlessly applies festive colours to the arias performed by an orchestra of baroque strength.

After Stravinsky's Feu d'artifice – exuberant, full of details – it was time for a huge firecracker: Beethoven's Seventh Symphony. You must have been there to know how much energy that piece can radiate. The way Nézet-Séguin raced through the last movement was almost like madness.

The Canadian conductor uses the rhythm to propel the music, and the melody for expressions of tenderness. He is a master of smooth changeovers, but he masters the abrupt ones, like sudden tempo changes or subito pianos, just as well.

If the Rotterdam orchestra is hungering for joy in playing, with Yannick they are at the right address.

Guido van Oorschot  
(Traduit du néerlandais par Geertje Hoekstra) 

NRC 14 novembre 2008  

Rotterdam Chief Starts with "Fireworks"

Stravinsky's early, short and difficult Feu d'artifice was a spectacular upbeat for an explosive performance of Beethoven’s Seventh Symphony. The orchestra, and especially the timpanist, was put at hard work with bravura, exuberance, extreme contrasts, big fortissimos and sometimes very sharp rhythms. An unrestrainedly flashy finale made it a real event.

Kasper Jansen  
(Traduit du néerlandais par Geertje Hoekstra) 
 

Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
3 novembre 2008

Mendelssohn : Elijah (en anglais)

Measha Brueggergosman, soprano
Lauren Segal, mezzo-soprano
Joseph Kaiser, ténor
Jonathan Lemalu, basse
Le Chœur de l’Orchestre Métropolitain

La Presse 5 novembre 2008  

Son goût pour la musique chorale a incité Yannick Nézet-Séguin à monter Elijah de Mendelssohn et à le donner non pas à Maisonneuve mais à Wilfrid-Pelletier. Sage décision: l'événement, lundi soir, avait attiré un peu plus de 2000 personnes, soit davantage que la capacité de Maisonneuve. (…)

Avec cet enthousiasme communicatif qui anime tout ce qu'il touche, Nézet-Séguin a signé avec l'Orchestre Métropolitain, le Choeur de l'OM et les quatre solistes requis une réalisation presque idéale de l'oeuvre, choisissant l'habituelle version en langue anglaise utilisée lors de la création de 1846. À cet égard, aucune réserve, ou presque. Dans le grand vaisseau de W.-P. où règne habituellement l'OSM, le second orchestre de cette ville sonnait comme une formation de premier plan et le Choeur de l'OM chantait tour à tour avec force et subtilité. (…)

Claude Gingras 

The Gazette 5 novembre 2008  

Bold programming can take many forms, including the dusting off of Mendelssohn's Elijah, a pious Victorian oratorio that was dismissed as outmoded 50 years ago.

Yannick Nézet-Séguin elicited all its melodrama Monday in Salle Wilfrid Pelletier. Fresh from the opera, the Orchestre Métropolitain played vividly (superb brass). While the OM chorus was not large at 100, and women initially sounded stronger than men, the fugues were robust and the assurances of the angels fell softly on the ear.

The stellar solo quartet, standing between the rear of the orchestra and the front of the choir, was led by Jonathan Lemalu, a rich (...) New Zealand bass who captured the fervour and compassion of the Old Testament prophet. Montreal-born Joseph Kaiser was a ringing tenor and the New Brunswick-born soprano Measha Bruegergosman brought a hot temperament as well as brilliant sound to her solos. Hear ye, Israel, indeed. Lauren Segal, a mellow mezzo, complemented her nicely. The sweet boy soprano was a bonus.

Nézet-Séguin balanced forces expertly, but his real mastery was in supporting the expressive curvature of the score. If no masterpiece - Mendelssohn's harmonic imagination was limited - Elijah has enough contrast and colour in the right hands to hold interest.

(...)

Arthur Kaptainis 
 
Orchestre Philharmonique Royal de Stockholm, Stocholm
29 et 30 octobre 2008
Svenska Dagbladet 31 octobre 2008  

Surprising effects left you longing for more

Try to remember the name: Yannick Nézet-Séguin. Specially prior to week 17, when the French-Canadian 33-year-old returns to the Philharmonics for his fifth visit.

The repeated invitations show that he is already an established name in the business. He is well-known by the audiences who kept applauding him onto the podium. And the musicians know. Their enthusiastic hammering with the bows on the music stands showed everyone´s delight in having outdone themselves, something that happens now and again.

(...) The fascinating thing about Nézet-Séguin is that his movements seem to stem from a detailed studying of the score rather than from the established movements in the record industry. Even when his gestures are wild and spontaneous, they give exact information of how to form a phrase - sound, breathing, climaxes and so on. In spite of the fact that the orchestra on occasion is pressed to the limit of its capability, the result is never vulgar or careless.

(...) By way of caressing the symphony from the orchestra, Nézet-Séguin opened up surprises. A new form of phrasing, very defensible indeed, in the adagio, a remarkably more cocky scherzo and an almost Spanish fire in the finale.

Carl-Gunnar Åhlén 
 
London Philharmonic Orchestra
10 octobre 2008
The Independent (London, UK) 23 octobre 2008  

Conducting is a mystical business. You generally know within seconds of the start of a performance if he or she has what it takes to take an orchestra and an audience to that other place where senses are heightened and the air seems to move a little differently.
 
The word has been out on Yannick Nezet-Seguin for a while now but it was the performance of Ravel's La Valse at the start of his first concert as Principal Guest Conductor of the London Philharmonic that ill have convinced a lot of people, myself included, of great things to come.
 
The erratic heartbeat at the start of the Ravel drew all ears into a strange nocturnal netherworld where murmuring bass voices grumbled and sighed. The emergence of the once-glorious waltz had the sickly-sweet smell of death about it and in exaggerating the rubatos and agogic hesitations of the familiar Viennese style it was as if Nezet-Seguin was holding a distorting mirror up to the music and showing us its imminent collapse. There was a wonderful moment in solo strings where the suggestion of a private soiree was but a fleeting, flickering, memory. The end was terrible in the best sense - grotesque and shocking. This was the moment Nezet-Seguin arrived.
 
Ace trombonist Christian Lindberg arrived in his customary hurry, signature white shirt flapping in the jet stream. A double-whammy was in the offing. In his own edition of Leopold Mozart's Alto Trombone Concerto a ripe vibrato, wickedly crisp articulation, and even a trill displayed all the agility of a piccolo trumpet. But when he returned in full evening dress to despatch something called Cantos de la Mancha by Jan Sandstrom, suspicions were immediately aroused. Within seconds of commencing a chivalrous fanfare he hurled his trombone to (...)the floor, started screaming at the audience, and ripping at his formal attire. Nervous breakdown or performance art? Both. This "mad scene" for the deluded Don Quixote would have been laughable but for the impossibly beautiful lament at its heart. Lindberg ended up in a pair of leopard skin tights brandishing his instrument's slide like a lance. I'm not quite sure who had the last laugh.
 
Nezet-Seguin definitely had the last word, a protracted resonance of bells and tam-tam rounding off his richly characterised performance of the Mussorgsky/Ravel Pictures at an Exhibition. Its sensibility was French but the boldness of sonority was entirely Russian with Samuel Goldenberg's pompous oration, for instance, rolling out like Chaliapin's basso profundo.

Edward Seckerson 

www.classicalsource.com 12 octobre 2008  

This concert – very much in the old Friday night “Classics for Pleasure” mould (and none the worse for that) – marked Canadian conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin’s first concert as the London Philharmonic’s Principal Guest Conductor. He first conducted the orchestra in May last year and his star is rising, as he has also just taken over from Gergiev at the helm of the Rotterdam Philharmonic, in addition to his long-standing duties with Montreal’s Orchestre Métropolitain. Short and energetic, but with an ability to suddenly adopt a very still, flowing conducting style, Nézet-Séguin was certainly a hit at this concert. Extraordinarily, the programme bore an amazing similarity to one of this season’s BBC Proms, again conducted by a young conductor from the New World. Indeed the first piece was exactly the same and the concerts both ended with French orchestral masterpieces, flanking a contemporary Swedish concerto, played in each case by a Swedish soloist who was not only asked to play but also required to dance, mime, pirouette and – in this case – vocalise. Where Gustavo Dudamel and the Gothenburg Symphony were joined at the Royal Albert Hall (13 August) by clarinettist Martin Fröst in Anders Hillborg’s Peacock Tales and ended with what I dubbed in my Proms round-up as ‘Symphonie bombastique’ (which is everything you need to know about what I felt about the performance), Nézet- Séguin had the irrepressible trombonist Christian Lindberg in Jan Sandström’s second (revised) trombone concerto, based on Don Quixote, before returning to Ravel, for his ever-popular orchestration of Mussorgsky’s piano masterwork. There’s no doubt that Nézet-Séguin scored heavily over Dudamel, especially in the orchestral classics. While I wouldn’t necessarily want him as my partner on “Strictly Come Dancing”, he certainly knows a waltz rhythm better than Dudamel, and also has a fantastic ear for balance and sonority, with timbres suddenly coming into focus that don’t seemed to have registered before. There was a sense of an edifice teetering and crumbling, all the more so because the LPO players (as they had for Kurt Masur two nights earlier) were on top form. There was the same keen musicality on display in the Mussorgsky/Ravel, encouraging excellent solo work from saxophonist Martin Robertson in ‘Il Vecchio Castello’ (accompanied relentlessly by John Price’s bassoon tread, another detail that seemed ‘new’) and Paul Beniston’s trumpet, mimicking Schmuyle’s shivering in the portrait of the two Jews later. The chords of ‘Catacombs’ were also wonderfully layered in both brass and strings. Nézet-Séguin had certainly made his mark and he got a tremendous reception from both audience and orchestra. With Dudamel a regular visitor with fellow RFH residents, the Philharmonia, it will be fascinating to watch these two conductors develop over the next few years – perhaps Masur’s choice of symphony two nights earlier was prophetic: ‘From the New World’ indeed! (...)

Nick Breckenfield 
 
Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
26 septembre 2008
La Scena Musicale 1er octobre 2008  

Yannick Nézet-Seguin: Young Montreal Maestro New International Star !

For the past few years I’ve been hearing more and more about the extraordinary talent of Montreal-born conductor Yannick Nézet-Seguin: he’s been given appointments by the London Philharmonic and the Rotterdam Philharmonic; this past summer he debuted at the Salzburg Festival leading Gounod’s Roméo et Juliette with Netrebko and Villazon in the title roles; he’s made a series of fine recordings - and he’s only thirty-two!

I finally caught up with Nézet-Seguin this week in Montreal to watch him conduct his Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal (OM). I came away convinced that Nézet-Seguin has the potential to become one of the most important conductors of his generation.

Nézet-Seguin has been artistic director of the OM since 2000. This is Montreal’s second orchestra, behind the more famous Orchestre symphonique de Montréal (OSM); it has its own following, and a large one at that.

Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal Totally in Tune
Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal was formed in 1981 by graduates of Quebec conservatories and music faculties. It gives about seven concerts a year at Place des Arts - also the home of the OSM - but it also plays in churches in the greater Montreal area and serves as the orchestra for the Opéra de Montréal in several productions a year. On this occasion, I heard the OM in the Salle Wilfred-Pelletier, the large hall at Place des Arts in a program of music by Ravel, Berlioz, Rachmaninov and Mussorgsky.

Watching Nézet-Seguin open the programme with Ravel’s La Valse, I was struck by his energy and enthusiasm. There are a lot of moving parts when he conducts, but there is little wasted movement. He has the ability to keep his players on the edge of their seats and make them respond to his every wish. To put it another way - as the musicians used to say about Toscanini – “when he looked at you, there was no way you couldn’t do exactly what he wanted”.

Nézet-Seguin has that special leadership quality that allows him to take charge and carry his players along with him. By the end of the concert it was obvious that not only was he able to lead them with authority but that they loved the leadership he was providing. No doubt about
it - this man is a born conductor.

Maestro Nézet-Seguin received most of his musical education at the Conservatoire de musique du Québec, but he also studied conducting with Carlo Maria Giulini. Physically they are very different types, but one can see the Giulini influence in the discipline of Nézet-Seguin’s gestures and in the intensity he projects to the orchestra.

Programming with a Purpose: Bold & Imaginative
In programming Ravel’s La Valse at Place des Arts, Nézet-Seguin was taking a chance. After all, his orchestra is really too small – not enough strings – and the walls are still resounding with Charles Dutoit’s near-definitive performances with the OSM. Dutoit has been gone for several seasons, however, and Nézet-Seguin and his players showed that if they could not be lush, they could be accurate and exciting. There was purpose to this programme. To open the concert, we had La Valse; then, to end the concert, we had the Ravel orchestration of Mussorgsky’s Pictures at an Exhibition. Nézet-Seguin wanted to show his audience what Ravel the composer could do, before they heard Ravel the orchestrator. Not bad at all!

Two Voice Version Perhaps not the Best for Berlioz Song Cycle
After La Valse came Berlioz’ song cycle Les Nuits d’été in a somewhat unusual version - for two singers instead of one. As it happened, soprano Marianne Fiset took ill and could not perform on the previous night and so at that concert, Les Nuits d’été was presented with only one singer, mezzo-soprano Julie Boulianne.
(…)

Soprano Marianne Fiset Charms Audience with Rachmaninov
The second half of the concert began with Rachmaninov’s Do not sing, my beauty, to me Op. 4 No. 4 in an orchestration by Leonidas Leonardi and in this lovely, melancholy song soprano Marianne Fiset was in her element. She sounded Russian – excuse me, Georgian, in this case – to the core.

I liked this bit of programming. Before Mussorgsky’s familiar Pictures,Néget-Seguin gave us another taste of Russian “soul”. It was a way of enriching a meal that was otherwise just a little predictable.

Mussorgsky’s Pictures Come to Life with Superb Playing & Thrilling Brass!
Nézet-Seguin didn’t do anything radical with Pictures, an orchestral showpiece, the primary requirement of which is superb playing. We got that in this performance! Interestingly, my most recent hearing of the piece was at Tanglewood this summer by the Boston Symphony under Peter Oundjian and the minor technical blemishes in the OM performance were almost exactly the same as those in the BSO rendering – and the conducting was equally stunning. In Pictures as in La Valse, Nézet-Seguin was somewhat handicapped by the small string section - but his musicians played their hearts out! The sound from the well-balanced brass section was thrilling, especially in the “catacombs” section.

More of Yannick Nézet-Seguin & OM in Montreal this Season
Nézet-Seguin and the OM return later in the season with performances of Mendelssohn’s Elijah, Mahler’s Das Lied von der Erde and Bruckner’s Eighth Symphony, the latter part of a Bruckner Cycle. Nezet-Seguin/OM recordings of the Bruckner Seventh and Ninth Symphonies are available on the ATMA label.

Nézet-Seguin is already the most successful Canadian conductor ever in terms of the international appointments he holds and the number and stature of the orchestras he has already conducted, or soon will conduct. Later this season, for example, he will appear with the Boston Symphony, the Philadelphia Orchestra, the Los Angeles Philharmonic, the Chamber Orchestra of Europe and the Vienna Symphony, among others. He will make his debut at the Metropolitan Opera in 2010. To keep up with his globe-trotting, check his website.

Paul E. Robinson 

La Presse 28 septembre 2008  

(…) Ravel dominait le programme avec La Valse et l'orchestration des Tableaux d'une exposition de Moussorgsky. Deux pages célèbres, autant de prodigieuses réussites. Étrangement, la réverbération qui nuisait à la voix seule conférait au second orchestre de cette ville une puissance, un éclat et une couleur qui le rapprochaient de son fameux concurrent. La pulsation que Nézet-Séguin imprimait à La Valse évoquait les grands soirs de Dutoit et les solos des Tableaux furent tous parfaitement rendus: la trompette, le tuba, le saxophone, qui nous donna jusqu'au petit glissando final si souvent ignoré. (…)

Claude Gingras 
 
Staatskapelle Dresden
21, 22 et 23 septembre 2008
Journal saxon, Sz.kultur@dd-v.de 23 septembre 2008  

La Staatskapelle célèbre un jubilé enivrant au Semper Oper de Dresde

(…) Choix d’œuvres historiques, interprétation rafraîchissante bien d’aujourd’hui, ainsi pouvait-on qualifier le cadeau sonore que s’est offert le Semper Oper de Dresde. (…) Tout simplement voluptueux et surtout pas banal, il (YNS) a caressé l’allegro et insufflé à ce Brahms une dose audacieuse de gaieté.  Comme il fallait s’y attendre, le double concerto a mis les solistes en valeur: ici, Julian Rachlin, violoniste communicatif, spontané, et là, la violoncelliste Mischa Maisky, sage, presque introvertie, riche contraste intégré dans un portrait esquissé de Brahms.   Pour Bruckner, Nézet-Séguin a soulevé une tempête de vagues symphoniques de proportions gigantesques dans la salle. Pendant 70 minutes a résonné une musique façonnée avec raffinement et d’une intensité fascinante par la Staatskapelle qui a ouvert son royaume de sonorités étonnantes. Le public ne pouvait répondre que par une tempête d’applaudissements.

Karsen Blüthgen  
(Traduit de l’allemand par Diane Caouette)  
 
Mozarteum Orchester Salzburg
14 septembre 2008
Ostthüringer Zeitung 15 septembre 2008  

Une explosion d’énergie vient clore le Festival des Arts
Finale grandiose avec le concert d’hier à Weimar


Lorsque l’on se demandera ce qui est resté cette année de particulièrement exceptionnel au niveau musical de ce Festival des Arts de Weimar, à part la présence de l’alto Tabea Zimmermann qui était altiste en résidence ici, on se remémorera spontanément et sans contredit ce concert de clôture ainsi que la fascinante dynamo au pupitre qui transmettait toute son énergie à l’orchestre. 

Yannick Nézet-Séguin dirigeait hier dans la salle de la ville de Weimar un concert de la Série Gala Europa pour lequel il fut acclamé. Ce concert était aussi l’occasion pour Madame Zimmermann de prendre congé de nous avec un concerto de Bartók grandiose et extraordinairement réussi au plan technique.

Il est certain que Nézet-Séguin fait partie de ces réelles étoiles montantes ( Shooting-Stars) de la direction d’orchestre. Et il ne serait en rien exagéré d’ajouter le nom du Canadien parmi les très grands noms qui composent la relève de ce club sélect.

Au début du concert, il nous a servi une direction d’orchestre qui semblait quelque peu difficile à apprécier, mais combien imagée et d’une efficacité extrême, stimulant ainsi l’orchestre du Mozarteum de Salzbourg qui était dans la meilleure des dispositions. Et il est arrivé à tirer quelque chose d’extraordinaire : un Berlioz extraverti mais sans tous les flonflons, une œuvre de Haydn presque outrageusement sensuelle. Après le Bartók ci-haut mentionné, il nous a servi un Oiseau de Feu de Stravinski d’une beauté plastique qu’on rencontre rarement.

C’était vraisemblablement l’un de ces concerts qui servira de référence et placera la barre encore plus haute au prochain Festival.

Tatjana Mehner, Ph.D.  
(Traduit de l'allemand par Marie-Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard)  
 
Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
10 septembre 2008
De Telegraaf 15 septembre 2008  

[...] Nézet-Séguin used his broad gestures to apply clarity by means of intelligent phrases and powerful details. [...]

Frederike Berntsen  
(Traduit du néerlandais par Geertje Hoekstra)  

Algemeen Dagblad 12 septembre 2008  

Spontaneous Beethoven by a Young Enthusiast

[…] his Beethoven was as sophisticated as exciting. Exuberant but melodious. […] Yannick not only conducted one of the most appealing Beethovens since years, but also one of the most brazen ones. That's promising for the future with the RPhO!

Oswin Schneeweisz  
(Traduit du néerlandais par Geertje Hoekstra)  

de Volkskrant 12 septembre 2008  

Nézet-Séguin Blends Orchestra and Choir in Vistas into Heaven

[...] Nézet-Séguin offered vistas into heaven at the quiet spots Beethoven created in between the more massive passages. The opposite happened towards the end, where the words Dona nobis pacem were combined with far-away marching music as an earthly and ironic comment. [...]

Frits van der Waa  
(Traduit du néerlandais par Geertje Hoekstra)  
 
Mozarteum Orchester Salzburg
21 août 2008
Punkt Kultur (Salzbourg) 22 août 2008  

Concentré sur les choristes

Reprenons nos chères habitudes : ce qui a retenu notre intérêt aujourd’hui, c’est la Grande Messe de Mozart en ut mineur dirigée ce jeudi 21 août par le jeune Canadien Yannick Nézet-Séguin, dont on a tant fait l’éloge lors du Roméo et Juliette de Gounod.

Si la présentation d’une œuvre est devenue avec le temps une institution, il faut chercher ce qui fait sa spécificité et sa particularité. Si on est chanceux, le chef d’orchestre va nous livrer l’heureuse marchandise. Le public de l’église Saint-Pierre peut se considérer chanceux d’avoir eu au pupitre Yannick Nézet-Séguin, né en 1975, qui a dirigé sans baguette et avec une gestuelle souple et légère et dont la perspective se concentrait surtout sur les choristes. L’orchestre jouait son rôle d’agitateur dynamique mais sans jamais essayer de dominer le chœur et les solistes, tout en étant toujours à leur service.

L’Orchestre du Mozarteum a démontré une extraordinaire délicatesse comme accompagnateur du choeur Bach de Salzbourg, qui, par ailleurs, a pu pleinement déployer la dynamique et le phrasé de ses qualités vocales. (…) Les deux voix féminines dégageaient ensemble une harmonie exquise et équilibrée tout comme l’ensemble des solos : Jeremy Ovenden et Markus Werba ont rempli leur tâche avec aplomb et assurance, et les voix des quatre solistes s’harmonisaient parfaitement.

L’une des composantes essentielles d’un concert religieux est évidemment les lieux dans lesquels il est présenté. Pour s’assurer d’une performance bien rodée, il faut respecter certaines règles. De ce point de vue, Nézet-Séguin a obtenu d’excellents résultats. L’équilibre et l’épanouissement des voix furent extraordinaires dans le Kyrie, clairement chanté pour que l’on puisse en différencier toutes les subtilités. Les profondes tonalités des sopranos n’ont à aucun moment été couvertes par l’orchestre. Dans le  déchaînement du Gloria, l’acoustique des lieux fut plutôt ingrate malgré la justesse du tempo. La performance des cuivres rappelait le Messie de Haendel. Le jeu du hautbois accompagnant le soprano était très élégant. Les sons de la voix et de la musique étaient en parfaite harmonie avec l’acoustique de l’endroit. L’orchestre était d’une justesse et d’une clarté absolues dans le Qui tollis où le chœur a atteint une tonalité somptueuse presque démoniaque. Nézet-Séguin a dirigé la fugue du  Cum Sancto Spiritu avec des grands gestes respiratoires, tout en accentuant le phrasé intéressant de la dynamique interne de l’oeuvre.

Il était étonnant d’observer la communication qui s’était engagée dans le  Et incarnatus est,  malgré la distance entre les instrumentistes et le soprano. Peut-être aurait-il fallu un peu plus de temps pour laisser les sons s’amortir dans cette église. On a pu entendre une belle tonalité opératique dans le Sanctus ainsi qu’un Hosanna parfaitement exécuté. Après les dernières mesures de l’Hosanna, Nézet-Séguin reste les bras en l’air pendant un certain moment tout en gardant le contrôle de l’espace intérieur de l’église. Ce n’est qu’après qu’il permet, en abaissant lentement les bras, de longs applaudissements et cela n’est certes pas du maniérisme. Ce n’est que la conséquence d’un dévouement inconditionnel à la musique.

Erhard Petzel-Dreh  
(Traduit de l'allemand par Marie-Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard)  
 
Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
4 et 5 juillet 2008
The Gazette 7 juillet 2008  

Nézet-Séguin leads Lanaudière premiere

(...) To report on the success of this avant-premiere is almost superfluous. Carmina Burana never fails, except perhaps with critics who find its musical style too primitive. But Nézet-Séguin softened the thrusting rhythms with lightness and humanity. The opening and closing Fortuna choruses were firm, no doubt, but much of the in-between had the character of operetta.

Which is to say it was nicely serviced vocally, especially by soprano Erin Wall, whose high-flying duets with the OM wind squad were enchanting. Tenor Frédéric Antoun did well with his cooked-goose routine and James Westman was a noble high baritone. The massed voices of five choirs, adult and youth, performed lucidly. (...)

At any rate, the most satisfying interludes of the night were the outer sections of Messiaen's Les Offrandes oubliées. Nézet-Séguin lifted the OM strings heavenward, very much in keeping with the spirit of the music. There was also a smooth performance by the brass of Jacques Hétu's Fanfare pour Lanaudière. (...)

Arthur Kaptainis  

La Presse 6 juillet 2008  

Festival de Lanaudière : Lisitsa et Prokofiev, Orff ensuite

Un autre Festival de Lanaudière qui commence bien. Cette fois, le 31e, avec l'irrésistible Carmina Burana de Carl Orff forçant la direction à donner le programme initial deux soirs au lieu d'un seul.

J'y étais le premier soir, vendredi. Il faisait très beau et il y avait là 4000 personnes (2000 sous la partie couverte et autant sur la pelouse) vibrant, dans un parfait silence, à l'électrisante virtuosité pianistique de l'Ukrainienne Valentina Lisitsa et à l'extraordinaire vitalité rythmique communiquée par Yannick Nézet-Séguin à la masse de plus de 300 participants englobant l'Orchestre Métropolitan et cinq choeurs locaux.

La populaire cantate profane de Carl Orff et le rare deuxième Concerto pour piano de Prokofiev étaient les deux grosses pièces du programme. Le Orff explique certainement ce succès de box-office et sa réalisation fut tout à fait satisfaisante,  mais la grande réussite de la soirée reste, à mon sens, le Prokofiev.

Valentina Lisitsa, dans ses débuts ici, apporta le maximum de technique et d'engagement à ce concerto qu'elle avait pourtant déclaré ne pas aimer et qui, effectivement, peut être qualifié d'"injouable". À certains moments, ses longs bras nus balayaient le clavier avec une telle rage qu'elle semblait en colère contre l'instrument. L'effet absolument foudroyant entraîna Nézet-Séguin et l'orchestre dans la même frénésie.

C'était la quatrième fois qu'on donnait Carmina Burana à Lanaudière, les précédentes exécutions ayant été celles du Métropolitain même dès 1989, de l'OSM en 1991 et de l'Orchestre Symphonique de Québec en 2000. Nézet-Séguin en a bien rendu la rythmique primitive et la truculence, en même temps que la poésie et la naïveté. Les différents choeurs en présence possédaient une belle unité (…) et l'orchestre sonnait avec le brio et le relief souhaités. (…)

Claude Gingras  
 
Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
2 juillet 2008
La Presse 4 juillet 2008  

Nézet-Séguin excelle

Rentré d'une tournée en Asie avec l'Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam dont il est le nouveau titulaire, Yannick Nézet-Séguin dirigeait mercredi soir son seul concert de l'été au centre Pierre-Charbonneau; de même, il dirige ce soir et demain soir son unique programme de la 31e saison de Lanaudière.

Même orchestre aux deux endroits: le Métropolitain, bien sûr, auquel l'infatigable jeune globe-trotter reste fidèle. Il avait centré le programme de mercredi sur un seul compositeur, Beethoven, représenté par deux oeuvres à caractère politique requérant toutes les forces du grand orchestre: la tapageuse Victoire de Wellington (traduction abrégée du long titre original allemand) et la grandiose et profonde troisième Symphonie, dite Eroica. Les deux fresques encadraient les deux petites Romances pour violon jouées par le jeune Jean-Sébastien Roy.

Manifestement imperméable à tout ce qui est décalage horaire, Nézet-Séguin impressionna la nombreuse assistance par son inépuisable énergie, en plus de faire précéder chaque oeuvre d'une explication claire. On souhaiterait simplement que notre Nagano en fasse la moitié autant.

Alexander Brott avait monté la Victoire de Wellington en plein air en 1973, au Stade Molson, avec un véritable régiment d'artillerie s'ajoutant à l'orchestre. À l'intérieur de Pierre-Charbonneau, les instruments d'orchestre suggéraient à s'y méprendre canons et mousquets, et jusqu'à la diminution de l'armée française vaincue par les Anglais.

Forte de récentes exécutions en Asie, l'Eroica trouva Nézet-Séguin dans sa plus grande forme, commandant, sans partition et partout à la fois, une interprétation de haut niveau, toujours passionnante à suivre, avec une Marche funèbre extrêmement sentie, de fracassants roulements de timbales et une sonorité d'orchestre étonnamment bonne pour un centre sportif. Le contexte justifiait d'omettre la reprise au premier mouvement, ce qui fut fait.

Jean-Sébastien Roy joua les deux Romances avec une élégance un peu fade, une justesse presque parfaite et des trilles et doubles cordes impeccables. Ce concert était aussi le premier de Marcelle Mallette comme violon-solo remplaçant Denise Lupien jusqu'à nouvel ordre.

Claude Gingras  
 
Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
13 et 14 juin 2008
Trouw 16 juin 2008  

Daredevil Yannick Makes Blazing Start in Rotterdam

What bravery! Only three weeks after his predecessor Valery Gergiev has left the orchestra, Yannick Nézet-Séguin started as the new Music Director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra with a sizzling and blazing performance of Shostakovich' Fifth Symphony. Shostakovich! The field in which Gergiev has had supreme rule for years. Time and again the unruly Russian proved this in a grandiose way in Rotterdam, for instance during his Gergiev Festivals.

But the small Canadian held his own and unleashed an enormous amount of energy and noise! At first it made the audience in the full hall of de Doelen quiet as a mouse, later they practically tore the hall down. Where Gergiev often achieved miracles with a mere shake of the left hand, Nézet-Séguin worked himself into a sweat for every bar, every note. He conducted by heart and indicated almost every entry for every single instrument. His style was a bit like Riccardo Chailly's, who also wants to make every turn in the score visible.

His approach yielded a grandiose performance, of a level that is even rare with maestro Gergiev. The Canadian conductor knows how eexert maximum tension and hold it endlessly. The way he and the violins moulded the second theme of the First movement, was a miracle of cooperation between musicians and conductor. The second movement, with its beautiful horns, was over before you knew it.

[...] Yannick started the evening with De aankomst by Otto Ketting; a suitable choice and a promising one for Dutch composers. Nézet-Séguin clearly felt connected with the work and also with Ravel's Piano Concerto in G in which he lucidly accompanied the Chinese wonder pianist Yundi Li, who surely will attract a large audience in Asia. Rightly so, for his Ravel was wonderful. A top evening!

Peter van der Lint  

NRC 16 juin 2008  

Yannick now Rotterdam Music Director For Real

During the past weekend, Yannick Nézet-Séguin was officially presented by the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra as Valery Gergiev's successor. [...]

Yannick started the concert with Ketting's De aankomst which he performed full of vitality and precision. It was a symbolic statement, for the versatile and broadly oriented Yannick also wants to conduct Dutch repertoire in Rotterdam. During his debut in 2005, he conducted Hendrik Andriessen's Variations and Fuge on a Theme by  Johann Kuhnau.

This time he arrived in Rotterdam on the rhythmic pulse of Ketting's kaleidoscopic musical  travel account, and he did it with class. In his joyous and congenial accompaniment of Ravel's Concerto For Piano and Orchestra in G, Yannick gave the Chinese pianist Yundi Li plenty of room to exhibit his refined style of playing.

The big question was: would Yannick be capable of making Shostakovich' Fifth Symphony sound at least as probing and overwhelming as his illustrious predecessor?

Outwardly, there is no greater contrast possible than between the tall Gergiev and the small, enthusiastic and intelligent Yannick. Their musical approach is also as different as night and day, but they have one very important thing in common: they both generate large quantities of musical energy, each in their own unique way.

Yannick's Shostakovich was less sultry and hallucinating than Gergiev's. But the music was at least as powerful because of its clear and flexible structure, the concise rendering of the  moods navigating between melancholy and fury, the energetic alignment of the various sections of the orchestra, the animated timing and the magnificent display of colour  Yannick drew from 'his' orchestra.

The musicians of the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra prosper under the high demands their new Music Director makes. Intonation, balance, nuance and razor-sharp phrasings are the result of thorough rehearsing. With the driven musician and reliable 'craftsman' Yannick the Rotterdam Philharmonic embarks on a new course.

Wenneke Savenije  
 
Orchestre Symphonique de Toronto
29 et 31 mai 2008
National Post 2 juin 2008  

With this maestro, we own the podium

Canada produces its share of high-profile singers and pianists, but not conductors; almost no podium masters working here are Canadian. None of them have been trained here. But Yannick Nézet-Séguin, just 33, is an exception. His performance with the Toronto Symphony Orchestra last week made plain that he's already among the best in the world.

Starting in September, this Montrealer becomes both the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra's music director and the London Philharmonic Orchestra's principal guest conductor concurrently. He's the complete musician, part artist and part boffin, part seducer and part athlete. His emphasis on physicality generates unvarnished, sizzling poetics, in the way that makes young Yundi Li such a great pianist. We may be entering a new classical ethos wherein the performer's body has as much to say as the tradition he enacts. For most of us, that's what life is really like. And it makes Nézet-Séguin a cutting-edge artist.

His crouching and arm waving evoke a combination of charisma and clarity that's simply uncontainable, stripping all the dreaminess from Brahms' fourth symphony, making it fast and lean. Nézet-Séguin's charm is infectious to the point of being overpowering. So is his on-site musical curiosity, which seems to feed on discovering new ways to present Brahms' inexhaustible but constantly performed orchestral material.

Nézet-Séguin takes volcanic pleasure in his musicians and their playing. The TSO was magnificent but there was an extra level of energy in Roy Thomson Hall. Each passage of the score was like an experiment that the orchestra somehow knew how to follow. Nézet-Séguin seethed with delight and a Gallic sincerity that would make any mammal melt. His rendition was always exploding with spontaneity, with textures rewoven in an eyeblink, more enthused than reverent, clean but never antiseptic.

As Nézet-Séguin led the orchestra, he'd flash the last person or section who'd performed a conspiring smile as a way of congratulations, the way jocks do. He's incredibly magnetic but not bossy -- his fluid gestures make him seem possessed by the concert event, as inspired by the players as he is by the material. That's not the same thing as genuflecting to a masterpiece the way most conductors have done for the last century. Rather the score is explored, with arresting new schemes that add playfulness, not in a saucy way but mischievously, alive with what Dmitri Metropolis called the "sportive element" in music that compels interpreters to take chances.

In his duet with American pianist Nicholas Angelich, Nézet-Séguin was receptive throughout their dialogue in Brahms' second piano concerto. Initially this seemed unlikely because the opening bars were louder than usual-- that's what Nézet-Séguin likes. Angelich's chords had to be almost bangy just to be heard. No one got away unsullied here; the orchestra was rawer than the usual majestic Brahmsian languor, so the initial effect was coarse but intriguing.

Again, that's what life's actually like; nothing of actual interest is seamlessly beautiful.

Angelich is a big undemonstrative man who nonetheless kept coming up with sparkling colours, at higher volumes owing to Nézet-Séguin's ability to transform the orchestra into a 400-member chamber ensemble.  Conductor and soloist seemed to represent different expressive poles, with Angelich as rationalist to Nézet-Séguin's ecstatic tribalism. The pianist's imperturbable contribution helped earn the show a rare standing ovation before intermission.

Seeing them walk off the stage together, brooding giant and animated sylph, they didn't quite resemble the same species. With Nézet-Séguin's approach being so New School, and Angelich more traditional yet indomitable, their pairing better illustrated how vital personality is to performance. And though the show was a total success it was also bittersweet with Nézet-Séguin leaving soon to work those choice gigs overseas.

Homegrown talent provides its own kind of satisfaction. When our hockey players tour internationally, we mark them carefully with maple leafs because we're proud of them. But Nézet-Séguin is leaving before the nation can get worked into an appropriate lather over his skills. His Toronto performances show why that's a real shame.

John Keillor  
 
National Arts Centre Orchestra
22 mai 2008
The Ottawa Citizen 23 mai 2008  

Yannick Nézet-Séguin proves worthy of all the hype

He's hot stuff. Yannick Nézet-Séguin has been the conductor of Montreal's Orchestre Métropolitain for some years, has been building a reputation as an opera conductor in Montreal and Toronto and has engagements for Salzburg and the Met. On top of that, he is Principal Guest Conductor of the London Philharmonic.

Oh yes, he was recently named Music Director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra, succeeding no less a luminary than Valery Gergiev.

Last evening he led the National Arts Centre Orchestra in a concert of Bouchard, Gershwin and Brahms, an eclectic mix if ever there was one.

Southam Hall was, if not sold out, certainly packed.

Things got underway with Linda Bouchard's Exquisite Fires, a work originally commissioned by the NAC and premiered here in 1992 when Bouchard was the orchestra's first and last composer-in-residence.

Rehearing this jewel of many colours after all these years was a treat, particularly since Nézet-Séguin and the musicians under him rendered a refined and persuasive account of it.

Marc-André Hamelin is one of Canada's most recorded pianists. He has made his reputation largely through playing music that has been, in his view, unjustly neglected.

It is often also extremely difficult, and he is invariably up to it.

Last night he appeared with the NACO playing Gershwin's Concerto in F, hardly an unknown work, but one we don't hear often. His nimble fingers made short work of its technical difficulties.

He and his colleagues on stage made what was probably as good a case for the score as can be made. It's a decent piece, though not comprised of the character as the composer's Rhapsody in Blue.

The most important of the evening's offerings was the Brahms Symphony No. 4 in E minor, and it was the best-rendered as well. You will probably never hear a more vital performance than last evening's or a warmer one.

At the same time, Nézet-Séguin gave the stormier episodes their full due, resulting in a rich array of contrasts and masterfully managed moods.

The orchestra played at its highest level, and that's saying a great deal.

It isn't possible to single out a movement or a musician for special praise, so fine was every aspect of the performance. This was music-making of the highest order.

Canada has produced several singers and instrumentalists who have become major international stars, but never a conductor. So far. Keep your eyes and ears on Nézet-Séguin.

Richard Todd  
 
Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
4 mai 2008
The Montreal Gazette 6 mai 2008  

Renée Fleming leads stellar cast for OM/Concordia benefit

Concordia University's Faculty of Fine Arts and the Orchestre Métropolitain have been in the high-stakes benefit business for a few years. On Sunday they presented a stellar and successful operatic concert in Théâtre Maisonneuve.

Led by Renée Fleming, the lineup included three future headliners of similar calibre under the baton of Yannick Nézet-Séguin, himself now an international commodity. This was the kind of event you travel across time zones to hear, or expect to find excerpted on YouTube.

Not that highlights were easy to choose. The German coloratura Diana Damrau, for whom high C seems to be a midrange pitch, turned Gounod's Je veux vivre and Bernstein's Glitter and Be Gay into one-woman shows with her vivacious acting.

Joyce DiDonato wondered aloud how she could follow the Bernstein, but she managed nicely in Rossini's La Cenerentola. A creative and secure singer where ornaments are concerned, this American mezzo-soprano also made a fresh case for one of the most belaboured of all Rossini vehicles, Una voce poco fa from Il Barbiere di Siviglia.

Tenor Matthew Polenzani, also American, was more inclined to stand and deliver the lyrical goods in Gounod's Ah! Lève-toi, soleil and Donizetti's Una furtiva lagrima. The crowd seemed transfixed by the melancholy beauty (and perfectly weighted tone) of the latter.

After warming up with Dvorak's Rusalka, Fleming made a scena of Je marche sur tous les chemins from Massenet's Manon, using much of the apron of the stage.

Fleming also gave us a lovely Willow Song from Verdi's Otello. In the final trio from Der Rosenkavalier she captured just the tone of autumnal radiance the role of the Marschallin requires.

Damrau and DiDonato concluded this sequence (and the program) with a physical show of affection that might have puzzled those who were not aware that Octavian, though written for mezzo-soprano, is a male character.

The OM, under Nézet-Séguin's flexible direction, was in top form. Seated close to the stage, I expected to hear some ringside roughness in items like Verdi's La Forza del Destino Overture, but string intonation was impeccable and brass entries were spot-on. Métropolitain? This orchestra sounded distinctly mondial.

Arthur Kaptainis  

La Presse 5 mai 2008  

(…) La chanteuse américaine (Renée Fleming) nous a aussi donné une très longue scène finale d'Otello à la fois soutenue vocalement et assez convaincante dramatiquement. Ce qui justifie de parler immédiatement de l'extraordinaire participation de l'Orchestre Métropolitain et de son chef Yannick Nézet-Séguin. La moitié au moins de l'impression produite par ce Verdi venait d'eux. Ils furent d'ailleurs de parfaits partenaires pour chaque chanteur. (…)

Claude Gingras  
 
Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
14 avril 2008
La Presse 16 avril 2008  

Nézet-Séguin et le Métropolitain : des Franck et Fauré convaincants

(…) En grande forme, comme on l'a constaté dès ses brèves présentations, le jeune chef a dirigé les deux oeuvres de mémoire. À la Symphonie de Franck, il a redonné sa sombre couleur germanique plutôt que française, sa paisible respiration, en somme sa noblesse. En contraste et, là encore, conformément à l'esprit de l'oeuvre, la sonorité orchestrale et chorale du Fauré (Requiem) était tendre et intime. (…)

Claude Gingras   
 
National Symphony Orchestra
10, 11 et 12 avril 2008
The Washington Times 12 avril 2008  

Rating: **** (out of four)

The National Symphony Orchestra uncorked one of its liveliest programs of the season Thursday night at the Kennedy Center Concert Hall: an evening of largely 20th-century Russian music led by guest conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin and featuring guest violinist Julian Rachlin. (…)

Excerpting four movements from this suite, Mr. Nézet-Séguin and the NSO offered a raucous yet controlled curtain-raiser that gave the orchestra's brass section a chance to shine.

(…) With intense focus and drive, he (Julian Rachlin) dramatically revealed all the passion, despair and outrage the composer had locked inside. He was ably assisted by Mr. Nézet-Séguin, whose powerful rhythmic sense — and accompanying body language — helped weld the NSO into a seamless instrument, at times backing Mr. Rachlin's virtuosity and at other times arguing right back. (…)

Wisely, Mr. Nézet-Séguin next gave the audience a breather with a hauntingly beautiful performance of the prelude to Mussorgsky's opera Khovanshchina, sometimes known as Dawn on the Moskva River, as reorchestrated by Mr. Shostakovich.

The program concluded with yet another high-velocity Russian work, Sergei Rachmaninoff's deeply intellectual yet sonically spectacular Symphonic Dances, Op. 45.
Moving from the vigorous first dance, oddly marked "Non allegro," the set weaves almost drunkenly into the second dance, a grotesque, gnomic waltz resembling at times Ravel's La Valse and at others the decadent ballroom music of Richard Strauss' opera Der Rosenkavalier.

The final dance, a march-turned-whirling-dervish marked "Allegro vivace," brings the full orchestra powerfully into play, with a variety of motifs careening almost recklessly among the orchestral sections. (…) Maybe the NSO's search committee should talk to this guy.

T.L. Ponick   
 
Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
31 mars 2008
La Presse 1er avril 2008  

Orchestre Métropolitain : grande réussite

(…)
Les cordes sonnaient avec générosité et leur virtuosité dans les vifs dialogues avec bois et cuivres était impressionnante. En un mot: une vraie sonorité de grand orchestre, sur laquelle Nézet-Séguin put créer une interprétation toujours convaincante. Sa Schéhérazade était on ne peut plus séduisante, avec un impeccable solo de violon de Denise Lupien et un Naufrage final d'une ampleur cinématographique. (…)

Claude Gingras   
 
Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
19, 20 et 21 mars 2008
De Telegraaf 21 mars 2008  

Nézet-Séguin with Expressive St Matthew's Passion

(…)
His broad orientation gives Nézet-Séguin an ideal background. He was a choir singer and studied choral conducting, and has a keen interest in period performance: "I belong to a generation of conductors who look at the work of specialists." He did not just "look" at the authentic performance movement but absorbed its views completely.

In a sold out Doelen, Nézet-Séguin's faithfulness to style went further than performing with a small orchestra and with little vibrato. Nézet-Séguin has a finely developed feeling for the sense of tension and relaxation, which changes so much quicker in baroque music than in the long lines of romantic music. In addition, Nézet-Séguin allows the notes room to gain meaning, right from the start. In the renderings of many colleague-conductors, the history of Jesus' suffering does not gain momentum until the second part. This young Canadian attracts the attention of the listener right away.

Every motive, every phrase has clear outlines. Nézet-Séguin's indications have an upward, inviting direction. It is as if the conductor worships the singers and the instrumentalists. The singers of the Nederlands Kamerkoor achieve miracles of expressiveness (…)

Thiemo Wind  
(Traduit du néerlandais)  

AD/RD 21 mars 2008  

Subdued Expressiveness in Nézet's St Matthew Passion

(…) Yannick's approach of Bach's masterpiece is not based on academic ideas or a deire for authenticity. His principle is: "I show you what I want, you make it sound." And it sounded wonderful. The chorales had a silvery sheen, and the performance as a whole breathed an atmosphere of subdued expressiveness, with sharply highlighted dramatic accents. (…)

Ger van der Tang  
(Traduit du néerlandais)  

De Volkskrant 21 mars 2008  

Nézet Brings St Matthew's with Breathless Pianissimos

The Netherlands has a new baroque conductor. Yannick Nézet-Séguin, who will be the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra's Music Director as from next season, proved that with a fair-sized choir, (two times 16 singers) and a standard-sized orchestra (two times 18 strings) it is possible to give a strictly personal rendering of Bach's St Matthew Passion.

The most striking aspect of Nézet-Séguin's interpretation is the sound ideal: a breathless pianissimo in which even the smallest differentiations create a turbulence. It creates an atmosphere in which the musicians are invited to give their soul, and in which the solo singers do not need to compete with a massive orchestral sound. This way, the Passion has a warm, intimate quality, with the emphasis on personal drama. The concrete Doelen was transformed into a sacred hall right from the start. (…)

Bela Luttmer  
(Traduit du néerlandais)  
 
Orchestre National du Capitole de Toulouse
14 mars 2008
La Dépêche du Midi 14 mars 2008  

L'Orchestre du Capitole et Yannick Nézet-Seguin cultivent l'excellence

(…) Ouvrant la soirée par les sublimes et crépusculaires « Quatre derniers lieder », il (YNS) veille à envelopper la voix ample et dramatique de la soprano américaine Christine Brewer d'une parure orchestrale riche de couleurs et d'émotion. En seconde partie, Yannick Nézet-Séguin, très à l'aise dans ce répertoire (R. Strauss, Symphonie alpestre), obtiendra le meilleur de tous les pupitres de l'orchestre lors d'une interprétation somptueuse de la Symphonie Alpestre de Strauss. Tout en rendant justice à l'opulence sonore de cette partition destinée à une formation de plus de cent musiciens, le chef canadien sait aussi maintenir une tension qui ne faiblit pas. Fasciné par la puissante beauté de l'œuvre comme par la virtuosité de l'orchestre, le public acclamera longuement chef et musiciens. (…)

Anne-Marie Chouchan  

Classictoulouse.com 14 mars 2008  

Tempête force douze

Yannick Nézet-Séguin insuffle à l’orchestre une respiration qui évoque une sorte d’hymne à la vie renouvelée. (…) Yannick Nézet-Séguin s’investit totalement dans la vaste fresque, écologique avant l’heure, de la « Alpensinfonie », vibrant hommage à la nature éternelle. Entre la naissance du jour et la tombée de la nuit, deux plages d’un calme indicible, le chef québécois, dirigeant de tout son corps, mu par une énergie sans limite, déchaîne les plus incroyables explosions orchestrales qui n’en restent pas moins toujours impeccablement maîtrisées. Les grands moments se succèdent : du rutilant lever de soleil à la tempête dévastatrice, en passant par la magique contemplation d’un horizon sans fin à l’arrivée au sommet (quel somptueux solo de hautbois de Jean-Michel Picard !). (…) Extases et élans dynamiques sont admirablement dosés par le chef qui semble obtenir tout ce qu’il désire de l’orchestre. (…)

Un grand moment de pur plaisir orchestral!

Serge Chauzy  
 
Rundfunk Sinfonieorchester Berlin
8 et 9 mars 2008
Berliner Zeitung 11 mars 2008  

Les réflexes d’un écureuil. Le jeune et phénoménal chef d’orchestre Yannick Nézet-Séguin fait ses débuts à Berlin

La posture de travail typique du jeune chef d’orchestre canadien-français Yannick Nézet-Séguin pourrait se décrire ainsi : un peu recourbé sur lui-même, les genoux légèrement inclinés, le centre de gravité quelque peu déplacé vers l’avant, il regarde  partout. Nézet-Séguin est donc toujours prêt à bondir, à se déchaîner dans toute direction, donnant aux uns le signal du départ tout en animant les autres, modérant les ardeurs de la gauche, ravivant le rythme de la droite. Cette posture permet au petit et habile musicien la plus grande des mobilités. Ce dimanche soir, on avait l’impression qu’il y avait plusieurs Yannick Nézet-Séguin sur la tribune de la salle du « Konzerthaus »où il dirigeait, agile comme un écureuil, sans trop poser de questions.

(…)

Ce dimanche, le jeune et phénoménal musicien faisait ses débuts avec l’Orchestre symphonique de la radiotélévision berlinoise (Rundfunk Sinfonieorchester, Berlin, ou RSOB), dans un programme francophone approprié: Ma mère l’Oye de Maurice Ravel, Les nuits d’été d’Hector Berlioz ainsi que la troisième symphonie de Scriabine, intitulée Le divin poème.  Le RSOB a, pour sa part, déjà fait ses classes en musique française, son chef, Marek Janowski, possédant une sensibilité certaine à cette musique, ayant fait ses études à Paris. L’orchestre a joué avec doigté chacune des touches de couleurs, comme il est approprié de le faire pour la musique de Ravel et de Berlioz. Nézet-Séguin a interprété (littéralement laissé jouer) avec une extraordinaire diligence et une circonspection de l’articulation, ce qui chez Ravel a comme conséquence que la musique semble parfois immobile; on peut justement aller très loin dans la délicatesse.

(…)

Yannick  Nézet-Séguin s’est révélé plus clairement dans la troisième symphonie pompeuse de Scriabine. Même si celle-ci est dépassée avec sa lourde théosophie, le chef  arrive à mettre de l’avant toutes ces harmonies qui doivent être relevées constamment par des mouvements orchestraux lourds. Que le chef d’orchestre arrive à une telle maîtrise ne rend certes pas l’œuvre plus digeste, mais nous la rend un peu plus intelligible.

Wolfgang Fuhrmann  
(Traduction libre: Marie-Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard)  

Berliner Morgenpost 10 mars 2008  

(…) la troisième symphonie de Scriabine, intitulée Le Divin Poème a déclenché une incroyable frayeur dans l’univers sonore et a permis l’éclosion et le scintillement d’étranges lumières cosmiques. Cette symphonie est le chef-d’œuvre de Scriabine, et on lui préfère volontiers le nom populaire du Poème de l’extase. En fait, nous avons rarement l’occasion d’entendre la troisième, et encore moins d’en entendre une si violemment sonore et si transparente à la fois, comme le fut l’interprétation de Nézet-Séguin. (…)

Volker Tarnow  
(Traduction libre: Marie-Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard)  
 
Dresden Staatskapelle
24, 25 et 26 février 2008
Kultur 25 février 2008  

Dédicaces amoureuses et bacchanales

La 6e série symphonique de la Staatskapelle de Dresde, en Saxe, déploie de brillantes couleurs orchestrales ayant pour thème l’amour. L’entracte nous transporte de la période du grand romantisme à celle de l’impressionnisme. On peut presque entendre les sensations musicales des premiers rapprochements amoureux, ressentir les joies et les déchirements de la passion, car l’orchestre joue clairement et les tonalités musicales sont vraiment distinctes. Francesca da Rimini, de Tchaïkovski, inspirée de la Divine Comédie de Dante, recèle un lyrisme plein et entier avec seulement un court passage plus calme au milieu de l’œuvre. Le jeune chef d’orchestre canadien Yannick Nézet-Séguin s’attaque à la partition ce dimanche avant-midi comme à un exercice de réchauffement sportif : une multitude de sonorités proviennent des instruments à cordes avec de nombreuses tonalités de cuivres et à la fin, une éblouissante apothéose qu’il réussit à générer grâce à un extraordinaire effort physique. En tout temps, il peut compter sur un orchestre très attentif.

(…) Si, en première partie, l’orchestre avait déjà su produire des nuances musicales lumineuses, c’est au retour de l’entracte que Nézet-Séguin s’en donne à cœur joie pour puiser une variété de couleurs musicales et nous délecter des œuvres de Debussy et de Ravel. Il entraîne ainsi l’orchestre dans une haute performance de danse. (…) Yannick Nézet-Séguin possède un accès privilégié à toutes ces œuvres, exploitant en alternance un jeu déchaîné et un encadrement contrôlé. À la fin, il est gratifié par des applaudissements enthousiastes.

Alexander Keuk  
(Traduction libre: Marie-Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard)  

Sächsische Zeitung 26 février 2008  

Musique aux accents de l’amour interdit

(…) Yannick Nézet-Séguin, au pupitre, fut inspiré et rempli d’enthousiasme envers les illustres sonorités de cet orchestre de Dresde que Richard Wagner décrivait jadis comme une « prodigieuse harpe (…).

Karsten Blüthgen  
(Traduction libre: Marie-Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard)  
 
The Toronto Symphony Orchestra
13,14 et 16 février 2008
The Globe and Mail (Toronto) 15 février 2008  

(…)
His (Yannick Nézet-Séguin’s) manner was that of someone mainly eager to share things he had discovered in the music at hand. I wasn't expecting to learn anything new about Enescu's Romanian Rhapsody No. 1, the pops-concert staple that opened the program, but Nézet-Séguin and the players worked patiently at displaying its virtues until the music's giddy enthusiasm seemed fresh all over again.

This young Montreal conductor has a very natural way of engaging with a score. His fluid movements seemed like a direct expression of his feelings about what was going on, and what lay ahead. No doubt that presentation concealed a lot of forethought, but while he was conducting I was aware mostly of how he responded to the mood and intensity of the moment. Everything he did was emotionally coherent.

There was a lot of control and gradation in his reading of Dvorak's Symphony No. 6, but I often felt that he was ready to leap over all constraints and take the orchestra with him. You could feel the players running with him toward the brink and yet never going over it, nor even over-playing. I found that much more thrilling than anything I heard during the concerto.

No wonder Nézet-Séguin's career is taking off internationally, with recent appointments at the Rotterdam Philharmonic (as incoming principal conductor) and London Philharmonic (as principal guest conductor). I hope he keeps room in his calendar for more concerts in Canada.

Yundi Li, Yannick Nézet-Séguin and the TSO perform at Roy Thomson Hall through Saturday. Yundi Li performs a solo recital at Roy Thomson on March 18.

Robert Everett-Green  
 
Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
4 février 2008
The Gazette (Montréal) 6 février 2008  

Riding the crest of a new wave of celebrity, Yannick Nézet-Séguin drew a big crowd to the Théâtre Maisonneuve on Monday night with his Orchestre Métropolitain. My perception was the audience was less purely francophone than in seasons past.

Whatever their mother tongue, however, the listeners emerged from the concert as confirmed Tchaikovskians. This was a passionate, organic performance of the valedictory Sixth Symphony, nicknamed Pathétique. A comparison with the recent MSO account under Zubin Mehta is interesting. Both conductors evoked blazes of anguish from the brass in the development of the first movement. Nézet-Séguin also managed to make the outpouring seem convincing as symphonic discourse. The movement was a great parabola, emerging from, and returning to, the silence of despair.

The five-four waltz was charming, and the march, so easily played flat-out, was animated with interesting detail. The conductor jumped into the Adagio lamentoso finale without a break, in part to suppress post-march applause.

Tchaikovsky's farewell to the world in the opinion of some, this movement was deeply moving. Radiant strings and solemn brass were warmly mixed, in a hall that makes mixing difficult. The performance had a profound affect on the audience, which remained transfixed in silence for almost a full minute after the end.

Before intermission, we heard Tchaikovsky's Second Symphony, based on Ukrainian tunes, as the conductor explained in a brief address. (…) Still, strings were vivid in the Scherzo, and there was much characteristic woodwind colour in the Andantino movement. The timpanist deservedly took a bow after the upbeat finale.

Through all this Nézet-Séguin moved with a natural balleticism of a man with his own orchestra, in his hometown. Dutch critics last November were struck by his kinetic podium style, but on Monday his gestures were often lyrical and restrained. These players, of course, need no convincing or coaxing.

They do need a better place to play. Given the increased crowds Nézet-Séguin is attracting, the OM really should move more PdA concerts to Salle Wilfrid Pelletier. That hall is no great shakes, but it is the Musikverein compared to Maisonneuve, which makes all orchestras sound scrawny.

At any rate, you still have a chance to hear this program in other settings, namely Notre-Dame-des-Sept-Douleurs Church in Verdun (tonight at 7:30), the Théâtre Outremont (tomorrow at 7:30) and Saint-Joachim Church in Pointe Claire (Friday at 8). You must go to the venues themselves for tickets.

Arthur Kaptainis  
 
Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
25 et 26 janvier 2008
MusicWeb 29 janvier 2008  

Ravel, De Falla, Debussy

(...)

Already in Alborada del gracioso I was impressed by the beautiful balance in the orchestra, clearly the result of careful work on the sound during rehearsals. Everything was audible, which is an achievement in this complex score. (...)

After this, we went into "the gardens of Spain" with De Falla and Yannick. His "accompaniments" in these "Symphonic Impressions for piano and orchestra" were exceptionally good in colour, rhythm and balance. (...)

Nézet-Séguin conducted Debussy's Ibéria and Ravel's Rhapsodie espagnole with such natural feeling for tempi, dynamics and colour that both pieces sounded much easier than they actually are. Among some gorgeous woodwind playing there was the big oboe/viola solo in "Par les rues et par les chemins" played as if  by a single Spanish singer by first oboist Remco de Vries and principal violist Anne Huser with such passion that the atmosphere was really hot .

(...)  Yannick Nézet-Séguin unleashed his orchestra ("a wild beast" according to Sir Simon Rattle) and now we could hear what was really possible from this potentially golden combination: passion, fire and energy. We smelled sweat and perfume in the sensuous night, were seduced by the Habanera and celebrated the Feria, full of bright light, raw energy and with a whirlwind of sound leading to an inescapable ending after which the audience rose to applaude this amazing young conductor and his equally amazing orchestra. What a joy to see such eager music making from both sides, and what a promise for the future this combination is. (...)

Bas van Westerop  

AD/RD 28 janvier 2008  

Nézet-Séguin as choregrapher of the orchestral sound

When asked how his Dutch is coming along, Yannick Nézet-Séguin replied: “I'm working on it.” “And your Spanish?” “You’ll hear it in the music.”

(…) But the audience had already heard that Nézet's Spanish is “muy bien”. For Ravel's morning serenade contained the whole programme of this 'Spanish' Prom concert in a nutshell: filigree guitar rhythms in the strings, castanets, a stylish bassoon solo, flashy, razor sharp orchestral passages.

De Falla’s nightly gardens were fascinating. (…) After the intermission, Ravel's Rhapsodie espagnole displayed beautiful miniatures in the Malagueña and the Habanera. The start of the finale was very delicate but the end was spectacular and festive. The performance of Debussy’s Ibéria was marvellous. The elegant, light and gay street scene in 'Par les rues', was followed by a wonderful weaving of the voices in 'Les parfums de la nuit'.

And just like in November's Strauss-Beethoven-Mahler concert, Nézet continuously shaped and coloured the orchestral sound, drawing it out, expressing it with his whole body. The conductor as the ballet master, or the choreographer of the sound.

Ger van der Tang  

De Volkskrant 28 janvier 2008  

Sublime Nézet-Séguin conducts with authority

Yannick Nézet-Séguin will not succeed Valery Gergiev as Music Director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra until next season, but the honeymoon has already started. This weekend the RPhO and the 32-year-old Canadian celebrated 'Spanish Nights'.

That was the theme of an evening with 'Spanishy music' by Ravel, De Falla and Debussy, presented by General Manager Jan Raes. His slogan, 'The best Spanish music comes from France', was executed convincingly.

(…)

The true proof of Nézet-Séguin's talent for intermediate colours, perfect transitions and stirring pianissimos came from the sublime interpretations of the festivities and the 'parfums de la nuit' of Debussy's Iberia and Ravel's Rhapsodie. The future chef comes from the French speaking part of Canada. In musical circles, this often leads to the assumption of a special affinity with French repertoire. The RPhO has already recorded music for a Yannick-CD with French music, and it is not for nothing that the Canadian will make his debut at the Salzburger Festspiele this summer with Gounod's opera Roméo et Juliette.

Earlier this season, however, Nézet-Séguin's wonderful Beethoven and Strauss interpretations proved that his repertoire is not limited to French music. The panorama will be broadened in March with Bach's St Matthews Passion and in June with Otto Ketting's Aankomst, and an attempt to nick Shostakovich's Fifth from Gergiev's heritage.

(…)

Roland de Beer  

NRC 26 janvier 2008  

Yannick brings Doelen down again

(…)

The promenade concerts feature light, popular music, and attract a highly varied audience with a notably large number of young people of all kinds, from neatly dressed to punk.

The youthful Yannick (32) who already knew he wanted to become a conductor 22 years ago, appeals to them with his flair, his informal style and his direct approach. (…)

More important are the orchestra's accomplishments under his direction in this repertoire, which calls for the utmost concentration and perfection. Well then, everything sounded excellent, with spicy exoticism, effective rhythms and magical colours, but even more important, with intense long phrases in still, slow movements, sensuous and sophisticated.

Kasper Jansen  
 
City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra
17 et 18 janvier 2008
The Guardian (London, UK) 21 janvier 2008  

****

The emergence of so much exciting conducting talent of late could hardly be better for orchestral music, and the Canadian Yannick Nézet-Séguin is one of those new names, his recent appointments to the Rotterdam and London Philharmonic Orchestras marking him as a rising star.

This appearance with the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra confirmed his credentials. His style has both a dynamic physicality and restless energy and, though not tall, he seems to have the upper-body strength of a weightlifter. He needed that stamina to deliver a vision of Bruckner's Ninth Symphony that was decidedly expansive: he shaped its vast contours with conviction and delivered its high points with unstinting force. Most strikingly, he underlined the degree of chromatic dissonance in this symphony, so unthinkable in earlier Bruckner. It implied a struggle if not of faith then of conscience, and, while the adagio is usually seen as the composer's farewell to life, the effect was to challenge any overly simplistic perception of Bruckner's spiritual certainty. Nézet-Séguin's ability to inspire his players was evident enough - conducting without a score ensured unbroken eye-contact - and he rightly acknowledged the contribution of the CBSO's blazing brass section. (…)

Rian Evans  

Birmingham Post (Birmingham, UK) 19 janvier 2008  

*****

(…)

Canadian by birth, Nézet-Séguin gives the lie to the assertion that Gallic conductors do not possess the key to Bruckner. In his reading of the composer's searing Ninth Symphony, patiently assembled like a medieval cathedral-builder, he dispelled all whiffs of the organ-loft with its creaky changes of registration, allowing instead all Bruckner's orchestral colourings to make their point and in this fabulous acoustic the pizzicati of the pounding scherzo had an amazing presence.

And after the heart-catching slow movement (the appropriate finale of this unfinished symphony), where Bruckner fulfils Schiller's Ode to Joy vision of finding God "beyond the stars", this reading went beyond applause, which thankfully took a long time to intrude. (…)

Christopher Morley  

Birmingham Mail (UK) 19 janvier 2008  

THE music of Bruckner is to understatement what Dawn French is to anorexia. He is a composer not given to restraint.

Sometimes this leads to music that is flabby and aimless. But sometimes there is unbridled emotion and searing passion.

Bruckner's ninth symphony, his last and unfinished despite its near hour-long duration, has plenty of examples of both the composer's vices and his virtues.

It is a tribute to the vision of the conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin and the musicianship of the orchestra that it is the peaks which will remain in the memory.

Dramatic splashes of dark tones, tension, passages of grandeur and the work's dying, resigned breaths marked this out as an intelligent and powerful account. Earlier the hues were much lighter as the young American soloist Jonathan Biss gave us a gripping performance of Beethoven's third piano concerto. This was a performance of the highest order that charmed, moved and enlightened.

VERDICT: *****

Paul Fulford  
 
Orchestre de chambre d’Europe
13 janvier 2008
Publico.pt (Lisbonne, Portugal) 20 janvier 2008  

La magie sonore de l'Orchestre de chambre d'Europe

(...)Le concert du 13 janvier a fourni encore une autre révélation : celle du jeune chef d'orchestre Yannick Nézet-Séguin, âgé de seulement 32 ans, qui a démontré une technique exemplaire et un charisme contagieux. Son interprétation a privilégié la dimension intense et pleine d'esthétique du style Sturm und Drang (Tempête et élan), contenu dans la Symphonie n° 44 ("Funèbre"), de Haydn, et dans la Symphonie n° 40, de Mozart, sans délaisser  l'élégance de l'architecture, en ce qui concerne les phrasés ou la transparence des plans sonores, ce qui est essentiel au style classique. Nous avons ainsi entendu des versions presque d'anthologie de ces oeuvres, avec plusieurs moments poignants, par exemple dans les mouvements finaux. 

Bien que l'utilisation d'instruments modernes donne une couleur différente de celle que Bach a idéalisé,  Nézet-Séguin a adopté rigoureusement une approche "historiquement informée" ; la  Suíte nº2, BWV 1067, a atteint un compromis très convaincant qui respecte l'essentiel de la nature du discours baroque. Le chef d'orchestre a été remarquable dans la forme comme dans sa gestion de la pulsation, de l'impulsion rythmique et du caractère dansant de mouvements comme les deux Bourrées, la Polonaise et le Menuet. Quelques excès dynamiques dans la Badinerie ont accentué le côté extrême de cette page célèbre. Le flûtiste Jaime Martin, avec une technique et une énergie brillantes, est entré dans le jeu, et après les enthousiastes applaudissements a fait répéter le mouvement d'une façon encore plus vertigineuse(...)

Cristina Fernandes  
(Traduction libre) 
 
Northern Sinfonia
14, 16, 21, 23 et 24 novembre 2007
The Press (York, UK) 16 novembre 2007  

Canadian conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin, handsome as a young Vladimir Ashkenazy, has quickly built a rapport with the Northern Sinfonia.

Principal conductor in Montreal since March 2000, he will be the principal guest conductor of the London Philharmonic Orchestra next year, and will then succeed Valery Gergiev as the next music director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic. His enthusiasm made this a hugely enjoyable evening.

This was a concert of warmth and lively intelligence, taken at a cracking pace, starting with Stravinsky's Preludes and Fugues from 1969, his expression of respect for Bach, taken from The Well-Tempered Clavier and beautifully tailored for strings and woodwinds.

After the Stravinsky, we had Bach's 2nd Suite, the 2nd Violin Concerto and finished with Rameau's Suite from Les Indes Galantes.

The stately Ouverture to the 2nd Suite had a beautiful mock-pomposity, but then flautist Juliette Bausor became the star of the show. I have rarely heard such a cheerfully fluent and eloquent flute.

The magnificent Bradley Creswick, leader of the orchestra since 1984, was the soloist in Bach's 2nd violin concerto. He gave a beautifully controlled and understated performance but with a vigour apparent throughout, even the quieter passages, in what we might have expected to be the highlight of the concert.

But Rameau's Suite from Les Indes Galantes was even more lively and exciting, decorated again by Bausor's flute and piccolo, making this a climax rather than a dessert to a marvellous pre-Christmas dinner.

Charles Hunt  

The Guardian (London, UK) 16 novembre 2007  

The Northern Sinfonia has an impressive track record for talent- spotting. It appointed Thomas Zehetmair as music director before a Gramophone award confirmed his international standing; now it introduces 32-year-old French-Canadian Yannick Nézet-Séguin as its next important find.

A dynamic young conductor with an irrepressible platform manner and a Jamie Oliver haircut, Nézet-Séguin was mentored by Carlo Maria Giulini and became principal conductor of the Metropolitan Symphony Orchestra in his home town of Montreal at the age of 21. Though he is still relatively unknown in Europe, that is likely to change when he succeeds Valery Gergiev at the Rotterdam Philharmonic next year.

A dedicated explorer of the lesser-beaten tracks of the French repertoire, Nézet-Séguin's unusual choice of calling card is Bizet's callow Symphony in C. Bizet wrote the symphony in 1855 at the age of 17, then shelved the piece, which didn't receive a public performance for over 80 years.

Nézet-Séguin conducts without a score - not that there can be many people prepared to commit Bizet's precocious juvenilia to memory - but he makes a convincing case for the work as a significant overture to the composer's operatic career. The slow movement is a langurous aria for oboe that seems to prefigure The Pearl Fishers, while the seductive Iberian dance patterns of the finale carry distinct echoes of Gypsy girls with roses between their teeth.

A vigorous parade of Rameau dance suites and a limpid account of Debussy's Prélude à l'Après-midi d'un Faune seem strangely diverse items to perform alongside the Bizet. Yet the lucent colours Nézet-Séguin extracts from the Sinfonia's wind section make a convincing case that if the Austro-German composers added woodwind as an additional flavour, French taste always made it as an essential ingredient.

Alfred Hickling  
 
Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam
8, 9, 10 et 11 novembre 2007
De Telegraaf (Rotterdam)   12 novembre 2007  

Yannick Nézet-Séguin est un guide fiable. L’Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam accueille son prochain Directeur musical.

Selon une loi non-écrite, un orchestre qui recherche un nouveau Directeur musical en choisit un qui est à l’opposé de celui auquel il est habitué. Gergiev, le surhomme, arrivait généralement à la dernière minute (ou en retard), n’avait pas le temps de répéter, battait des mains et allait de l’avant. Les bons jours, il faisait des miracles; les mauvais jours, ça pouvait être un désastre. Mais d’une manière ou d’une autre, les musiciens étaient toujours sur le qui-vive.

Gergiev laisse derrière lui un merveilleux orchestre qui a besoin cependant d’entretien. Nézet-Séguin (32) y procède tout de suite. Devant un De Doelen rempli à capacité ou presque, il amène le Rotterdam à des subtilités inhabituelles. Il dirige presque tout de mémoire, sans échapper un seul détail. Avec ce guide sûr, les musiciens savent exactement ce qu’on attend d’eux. Ses battements sont clairs et son sens du rythme est agréable à suivre.

Mort et Transfiguration de Richard Strauss commençe par une merveilleuse hésitation mais sans perdre le sens du mouvement. Nézet-Séguin a été chantre et chef de choeur et ceci devient évident par la respiration toute naturelle de sa musique.  On ne peut dire qu’il peint avec des couleurs mais plutôt qu’il dessine et au besoin grave son propos en contours clairs. Les fenêtres de sons ouvertes empêchent le poème symphonique de devenir un chou à la crème. Le résultat est musique à cent pour cent.

La Troisième Symphonie de Beethoven, Eroica, me prend par surprise. Il est audible que Nézet-Séguin n’a pas oublié ses accomplissements en musique ancienne. Les timbales se travaillent avec des maillets de bois, les trompettes sonnent les appels et les cordes utilisent le vibrato avec discrétion. Et que personne ne prétende que l’instrumentation a peu d’importance dans la musique de Beethoven. Nézet-Séguin expose en grands détails les divers niveaux de la partition  et en tire de l’énergie. Il s’agit là d’une grande démonstration des possibilités symphoniques, sans devenir parade pour autant. Lorsque jouée par un orchestre symphonique moderne, il est rare que la musique de Beethoven sonne aussi près de sa source.

Dans le premier mouvement, le désir de chanter d’une part et le besoin pressant d’aller de l’avant d’autre part produisent une sorte de friction pleine de santé. L’effervescence du scherzo et du finale épanouit l’esprit. Mais le summum de beauté et de sonorité se produit dans la marche funèbre. Par Jupiter! Le Philharmonique de Rotterdam sonne presque comme un orchestre du dix-huitième siècle. Le fait que Frans Brüggen ait dirigé l’orchestre à plusieurs reprises et ait familiarisé les musiciens du Rotterdam avec du Beethoven authentique a sans doute aidé.

La conclusion est manifeste. Yannick Nézet-Séguin et l’Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam ont beaucoup à s’échanger mutuellement. Il est admirable qu’après le grand Gergiev, l’orchestre ait choisi un jeune chef encore relativement peu connu. La musique souffre souvent des grandes réputations. Rotterdam a choisi l’engagement passionné.  Et vendredi soir, la passion de l’engagement pouvait être ressentie à chaque seconde.

Thiemo Wind  
(Traduction libre : GG et CNS)  

Trouw (Rotterdam)   12 novembre 2007  

Le futur Directeur musical Yannick emballe Rotterdam.

Bien que ses débuts officiels comme Directeur musical n’aient lieu qu’en septembre 2008, le jeune Canadien Yannick Nézet-Séguin tient déjà une place importante dans la programmation de la saison courante de l’Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam dont Valery Gergiev est encore le Directeur pour la moitié de l’année. C’est une décision intelligente qui permet à Nézet-Séguin de diriger ainsi quatre programmes majeurs. Jeudi soir dernier, il a dirigé le Philharmonique de Rotterdam pour la première fois depuis l’annonce de sa nomination au poste en décembre 2006.

L’ambiance au De Doelen était électrisante. Après le concert, il y eut un grand nombre de bravos émergeant de la salle remplie à capacité et les membres de l’orchestre tambourinèrent des pieds avec enthousiasme. On avait l’impression que Nézet-Séguin faisait ses débuts jeudi soir plutôt qu’en septembre prochain. La troisième symphonie de Beethoven (Éroica)  fut un magnifique happening musical. Ce n’était pas seulement le début de la  période excitante d’un nouveau Directeur musical, mais aussi le coup d’envoi de l’intégrale du cycle des Beethoven que Nézet-Séguin dirigera à Rotterdam. Pour l’interprétation de cette Éroica, il importait peu que le chef  n’ait pas encore le titre de Directeur musical. Nézet-Séguin (probablement aussi court que Napoléon à qui Beethoven dédia d’abord son Éroica) commandait ses troupes. 

Malgré les dissimilitudes évidentes entre Nézet-Séguin et Gergiev, quelque chose de très inusité s’est passé au début du concert. Si on écoutait les yeux fermés le Tod und Verklärung de Richard Strauss, on pouvait presque imaginer que le début incroyablement menaçant et angoissant était dirigé par le grand insondable Gergiev. Mais non, c’était vraiment Yannick qui conjurait un son super virtuose de l’orchestre dans une interprétation exceptionnelle avec son merveilleux échafaudage et ses grandes apogées. Expressif, communicatif, précis et ardent, tous ces qualificatifs s’appliquent à Yannick. Il n’est pas encore Directeur musical mais ce n’est qu’une formalité. Avis à Rotterdam!

Peter van der Lint  
(Traduction libre : GG et CNS)  

De Volkskrant (Rotterdam)   10 novembre 2007  

Le nouveau Chef de l’OPhR danse et bondit.

Court, un peu rondelet, les cheveux en pointes stylisées: Yannick Nézet-Séguin ne ressemble pas du tout à Valery Gergiev, ce grand sauvage hirsute qui est encore le Directeur musical de l’Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam. Mais dès qu’il lève le bâton, les ressemblances résonnent : Nézet-Séguin, ce Canadien de 32 ans qui prendra la direction de l’Orchestre de Rotterdam en septembre prochain, dégage autant d’intensité et d’énergie que son prédécesseur.

Quant au reste, le style est tout à fait différent: il bondit, il danse, il joue, il est partout à la fois, il s’étire aussi haut qu’il peut, il plie les genoux tellement qu’il serait disparu derrière le lutrin s’il n’avait pas dirigé presque tout de mémoire.  

Ce n’est pas la première fois qu’il dirige l’Orchestre et ce ne sont pas non plus ses débuts officiels, mais c’est tout comme, considérant que Nézet-Séguin est si souvent à Rotterdam cette saison et offre un répertoire si varié.  Il dirige un astucieux programme proposant des compositeurs qui avaient à peu près son âge lorsqu’ils ont composé ces oeuvres: Richard Strauss (25 ans), Gustav Mahler (25 ans) and Ludwig van Beethoven (33 ans).

Le Tod und Verklärung de Strauss s’ouvre sur des battements de cœur timides. Mais dès que la musique se déploie,  Nézet-Séguin s’avère non seulement un chef mais un « galvanisateur », avec une oreille pour les extrêmes mais aussi pour les gradations intermédiaires.

L’alto Birgit Remmert cause une légère déception dans les Lieder eines fahrenden Gesellen de Mahler. Nézet-Séguin, cette fois avec la partition devant lui, dépeint la langueur d’un vague désir et les douleurs de l’amour avec des sons orchestraux tantôt oppressants tantôt tranchants comme un rasoir.

Mais dès le début de l’Eroica, Nézet-Séguin manifeste tant d’inspiration qu’il est clair que Beethoven est son domaine Il porte une attention aiguë  aux marées mélodiques et aux rythmiques brise-lames, il explore les espaces plus profonds aux couleurs entre-deux de la grande Marche funèbre, et il  surprend en ajoutant une étincelle additionnelle à cette œuvre monumentale. Les musiciens de l’OPhR vont devoir s’habituer à cette direction de balle bondissante, mais à en juger par les sons qui en résultent, les fondations semblent assez solides pour les années à venir.

Frits van der Waa  
(Traduction libre : GG et CNS)  

AD/RD (Rotterdam)   10 novembre 2007  

Avec, cette année, une série de quatre concerts comprenant –et ça mérite d’être souligné- trois représentations de La Passion selon St-Mathieu de J.S. Bach, Yannick Nézet-Séguin et l’OPhR se préparent au futur Directorat Musical du jeune Canadien. La première série a commencé jeudi soir avec la musique de Richard Strauss, Mahler et Beethoven.

Cette Éroica fut intéressante du début à la fin. Nézet et l’OPhR offrirent une exécution brillante, claire et chaleureuse. Entre les passages héroïques et robustes sans être trop lourdement accentués, les passages plus méditatifs et mélodiques furent magnifiquement mis en valeur. Le scherzo au pied léger fut un chef-d’oeuvre et le son superbe des trois cors, un régal additionnel.

Auparavant, Nézet avait déjà captivé l’assistance avec le Tod und Verklärung de Strauss. Après un début d’une tranquillité à couper le souffle, il dirigea l’orchestre dans l’intense Allegro Molto Agitato. Le tutti diminuendo précédant le début de la Marche funèbre fut fascinant et la fin magnifique, presque festoyante.

L’intimité de l’orchestration  des Lieder eines fahrenden Gesellen révéla partiellement ce que sera le son Mahlérien avec Nézet-Séguin. La première impression fut favorable, particulièrement en ce qui concerne l’atmosphère.

En coopération avec l’alto Birgit Remmer, qui ne produisit pas un son ample dans le bas registre du premier Lied mais chanta magnifiquement, Nézet-Séguin offrit une superbe démonstration de ce qu’est la langueur d’un désir insaisissable.

Ger van der Tang  
(Traduction libre : GG et CNS)  

NRC (Rotterdam)   9 novembre 2007  

De Doelen ouvre les bras au futur Directeur musical

Hier soir, Yannick Nézet-Séguin (32 ans) a donné son premier concert comme futur Directeur musical de l'Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam et successeur de Valery Gergiev. Il a été immédiatement accueilli à bras ouverts par l'assistance. Ce chef étonnamment court et d'un enthousiasme désarmant, en redingote froissée sortie d'une boîte de costumes, a reçu un tonnerre d'applaudissements après sa prestation inspirée et remarquable.

Yannick Nézet-Séguin se révèle différent, attachant et désarmant. Mais il est aussi pertinent de dire qu'il est sans cérémonie, modeste et avant tout un musicien parmi ses musiciens. Pendant les applaudissements, il quitte souvent son podium pour se tenir debout parmi eux. Il encourage l'orchestre à oublier le Nézet-Séguin et à l'appeler simplement Yannick. Sa direction prend un aspect de conspiration: faisons cela ensemble. Et c'est justement ce que l'on entendait.

C'est Yannick lui-même qui a programmé cet ambitieux concert qui comprend le Tod und Verklärung de Strauss , les Lieder eines fahrenden Gesellen de Mahler et la Troisième symphonie Éroica de Beethoven. De la grande musique concernant la mort et un autre genre de vie.

Yannick dégage aussi autorité et possession de soi. Pendant un long moment, le début lent et noir du Tod und Verklärun est presque immobile, amenant graduellement l'orchestre dans les convulsions extraverties de la mort. Yannick utilise des contrastes dramatiques et des changements de couleurs et place parfaitement le moment des apogées et leurs proportions.

(...) L' Éroica de Beethoven fut un événement excitant, plein de caractère et d'énergie charismatique, éblouissant, avec syncopes et autres particularités rythmiques, vivant mais aussi d'un lyrisme souple et agile.

Kasper Jansen  
(Traduction libre : Guy Gagnon)  
 
Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
22 octobre 2007
La Presse (Montréal)   24 octobre 2007  

(...) Pour son hommage au 25e anniversaire de la mort de Glenn Gould, l'Orchestre Métropolitain est passé de Maisonneuve à Wilfrid-Pelletier attirant ainsi 2100 personnes. (…) le son qu'en tire Nézet-Séguin remplit la salle sans problèmes et il n'y a rien à redire sur la prestation orchestrale, continuellement animée par le jeune chef dont l'énergie semble inépuisable. (…) le Coriolan a beaucoup de nerf, un vent d'air frais traverse les Hébrides et la tendresse de Siegfried Idyll est parfaitement rendue. Nézet-Séguin dirige tout par coeur, sauf les concertos, et c'est finalement la magnifique réponse de l'orchestre qui marquera la soirée. (…)

Claude Gingras  

The Gazette (Montreal)   October 24, 2007  

(…) Hats off to Yannick Nézet-Séguin and his Orchestre Métropolitain for paying tribute to Glenn Gould Monday (…) Nicholas Angelich (produced) a spirited account of Beethoven's Piano Concerto No. 2. (…)YNS invested the piece (Wagner's Siegfried Idyll) with exactly the romance and rubato missing from the version Gould conducted before his death.

Arthur Kaptainis  
 
Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
24 septembre 2007
La Presse (Montréal)   26 septembre 2007  

(...) Nézet-Séguin reprenait la cinquième Symphonie après avoir dirigé l'intégrale des neuf en novembre 2005 et Lortie jouait une fois de plus le quatrième Concerto qu'il avait donné comme chef et soliste dans cette même salle en septembre 2001, avec l'OSM. Chef et soliste lui aussi, Nézet-Séguin l'avait été dès 1998 dans la Fantaisie avec piano et choeur.

Cette fois, c'est Lortie qui joue la Fantaisie - en fait, qui ouvre seul le concert puisque l'oeuvre débute par une longue introduction de quatre pages confiée au piano. Lortie remplit immédiatement l'espace par son jeu imaginatif.

Nézet-Séguin, son orchestre et son choeur apportent ensuite le maximum à cette oeuvre naïve qui, chantant la nature et la vie, préfigure la Neuvième. Seules faiblesses: certaines voix solistes du choeur.

Malgré un piano légèrement faux, Lortie maintient du commencement à la fin du quatrième Concerto contrôle technique et concentration tout en glissant ici et là d'expressifs rubatos. Très vivante direction, accents des cordes particulièrement marqués au mouvement lent.

Une énergie bouillonnante traverse la célébrissime Cinquième, et ce dès le premier mouvement, vraiment pris «con brio». À signaler encore, la précision des deux groupes de violons à l'unisson et des tutti marqués «fortissimo».

Le maire Gérald Tremblay assistait au concert.

Claude Gingras  

The Gazette (Montréal)   26 septembre 2007  

(…) Semi-public concerts for charities are usually more about the cause than the music. Not so Monday night in Place des Arts, where the Orchestre Métropolitain both raised funds for the Montreal Cancer Institute and produced some Beethoven to remember.

The evening brought together conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin and pianist Louis Lortie. It was hard to believe these local icons were meeting for the first time, but Lortie has long styled himself as an MSO collaborator and probably for this reason exempts himself from regular subscription OM events.

Too bad. There was great chemistry in the Fourth Piano Concerto, by which I mean an almost literally perfect balance of solo and tutti elements. Lortie's Steinway was sweet and bell-like and his phrasing spoke to the joy of philosophy. Nézet-Séguin was exuberant on the podium, flashing his new pal enthusiastic glances.

Our second orchestra sounded first-rate. Woodwinds were poetic in the first movement and the strings created just the right stern, grainy sound in the Andante con moto. Lortie's mastery of piano colour - which is to say his impeccable sense of when to use the sustaining pedal - was especially apparent in the cadenza of the finale.

Before this we heard the Choral Fantasy, Beethoven's exuberant precursor to the Ode to Joy. The conversation here included the red-blooded OM Chorus. (…)

Arthur Kaptainis  
 
Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
17 septembre 2007
The Gazette (Montréal) 19 septembre 2007  

Unfinished works made complete OM's grandeur fills St. Jean Baptiste Church

St. Jean Baptiste Church has been the scene for many impressive concerts, enough to make a top-10 list a very selective affair. Now we must make room for the Orchestre Métropolitain season opener on Monday night, a coupling of Schubert's Unfinished Symphony and Bruckner's Ninth, which famously lacks a finale.

Debate rages about whether these scores are in fact artistic wholes. They certainly seem complete when performed with the authority and grandeur that Yannick Nézet-Séguin brought to them on this occasion.

The orchestra seemed double its numbers in Schubert, producing a frightening climax in the development of the first movement. But for all the heaven-storming strength of the music, there were exquisite woodwind solos - quiet, lonely and clear.

Thus the personal and the monumental were joined, as they should be in a sacred setting. The two movements also seemed perfectly reconciled - the first stately, the second moved up a notch in tempo in the interests of lending it a "finale" feeling.

In Bruckner, the ensemble seemed doubled again. Fortissimos of the first movement were among the grandest sounds ever made in this church. Indeed, the conductor coaxed so much force from the horns and timpani in the savage main theme of the Scherzo that the staccato comments of the strings and woodwinds needed to be edited in mentally.

Still, this was not an evening of mindless heavy metal. The sonic peaks were part of a continuous and majestic range. (…) the rich tone of the violins, fed directly, it seemed, from the Austrian Alps.

This church always comes with a sonic nimbus, for which it exacts a price in internal clarity. It will be fascinating to hear how this program sounds Friday in that great palazzo of the east, St. Nom de Jésus Church. This concert will be given under the aegis of the Orgue et Couleurs festival. For details, go to www.orgueetcouleurs.com.

Arthur Kaptainis  
 
New Zealand Symphony Orchestra
7 septembre, 2007
The Dominion Post (Wellington, New Zealand) 8 septembre, 2007  

Thrilling moments for a dazzling star

THE young French Canadian conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin has, over the past fortnight, burst on the music scene here like a shooting star, dazzling musicians and audiences alike.

First we had a large, demanding programme, played by the National Youth Orchestra with finesse and fire, directed by Séguin with insight, superb technique and boundless energy.

And now we had the hardened professionals of the NZSO providing this young firebrand with some Wagner playing that ran the gamut from near-inaudible delicacy (in the Lohengrin Prelude) to blazing climaxes that possessed a quality that transcended mere loudness, offering any doubting Thomases in the audience a real insight into the sound world that the composer intended.

Séguin is, by his own admission, new to Wagner, and it was his incandescent freshness, allied to a potent natural musicality, that made this concert so special. Not for one moment did he falter in his vision, making this concert of what critics always call bleeding chunks much more cogent than usual.

Perhaps it was the inclusion of the Prelude and Liebestod from Tristan und Isolde, and the final immolation scene from Gotterdammerung, and the soaring voice of Margaret Medlyn, that tied the concert together, that gave it unity.

Medlyn, who has the right voice, and fully understands Wagner’s world, sang superbly. In both extracts she matched Wagner’s demanding orchestral resources, and realised the differences between Isolde and Brunnhilde in quite subtle ways.

Some might have been concerned by the voice being swept away by the orchestra at key moments, but this is what was needed, and sometimes is not in the opera house, and the reemergence of the voice from within the maelstrom provided some of the evening’s most thrilling moments.

The orchestra played brilliantly, with the huge phalanx of brass marvellously sonorous, and the audience left, no doubt wondering when they will experience the conducting of Yannick Nézet-Séguin again.

John Button  
 
NZSO National Youth Orchestra 2007
6 septembre, 2007
The Auckland Herald (New Zealand) 7 septembre, 2007  

To Experience symphonic music played by young musicians who have come together from throughout the nation is a joy like no other.

In times when our young people are easily distracted by all the trivialities that society hurls in their way, the sight of 100 players devoting their all to Ravel, Bartok, Debussy, and the music of one of their peers is inspirational.

The NZSO National Youth Orchestra's Monday concert revealed, as always, the special relationship that develops with a guest conductor - and the dynamic Yannick Nézet-Séguin came up trumps.

Ravel's La Valse is not the easiest curtain-raiser and, although there were some shaky first steps, once it swept firmly on to the dance floor there was no stopping it. Nézet-Séguin and the players ably captured the sweep, the passion and the utter delirium of it all.

The spotlight was turned on the orchestra itself in Bartok's Concerto for Orchestra. The strings were particularly secure, from those opening cello fourths to the full-voiced song of the violas in the Intermezzo. Woodwind sauntered past in cheery pairs for the Giuoco delle coppie and the brass ensured a lusty close.

Karlo Magetic's Belt Sander was a celebratory dash, oozing energy. The demands were of the split-second variety with splashy percussion and, for well-tuned ears, a suspicion of something Spanish caught in the mix.

Magetic made his mark, as a schoolboy, by carrying off Chamber Music New Zealand's Sounz Prize two years ago. Now, two years on, the orchestral canvas seems made for him.

The jewel of the evening was La Mer, in which the French-Canadian conductor ensured his charges evoked every billow and ripple of Debussy's sea. Woodwind and brass were elegantly moulded and a strong cello section showed no fears with that treacherous five-part chorus in the first movement.

Concertmaster Amalia Hall's idiomatic solos were the soul of subtlety.

The musicians bade us a Gallic farewell - a poised walk through a Ravelian fairy garden from the composer's Mother.

William Dart  
 
NZSO National Youth Orchestra 2007
3 septembre 2007
The Press (Christchurch, New Zealand)  

Youth orchestra delights

(…) Yannick Nézet-Séguin established himself from the start of Ravel's La Valse as exacting and energetic. He captured the nebulous opening as convincingly as the wonderful frenzied excesses that followed. His limitless energy and precision characterised the whole concert.

The NYO chose two major works – quite an achievement for a mere six days' rehearsal. Bartok's Concerto for Orchestra was always secure, and Nézet-Séguin led his young players firmly through the subtleties and complexities of the score without needing to refer to it himself.

It was the same with the even more demanding La Mer by Debussy. Expressively the most subtle item in the programme, Nézet-Séguin took the orchestra well on the way to capturing the evocative power of the work. Not surprisingly, the combination of youth and energy was to the fore in the third movement, while the more complex second benefited from the generally brisk tempi that characterised Nézet-Séguin's approach all through.

The NYO had an encore ready, Ravel's Magic Garden, which brought some beautiful solo playing by the violin and viola leaders.

For sheer musical enjoyment the NYO's concert outdid many that I have heard from some of the world's greats.

David Sell  
 
NZSO National Youth Orchestra 2007
30 août, 2007
The Dominion Post (Wellington, New Zealand) 31 août, 2007  

Young musos deliver in style

WE ALL know that our young musicians have been achieving extraordinarily high standards in recent years, but this year’s National Youth Orchestra would still have astonished even the most informed and hardened observer.

It was not just the quality of the playing across all sections, but the amazing capacity for work in just a few days, and the sheer stamina to bring off the programme.

And what a programme. Surely, few professional orchestras would play a concert that included Ravel’s La Valse, Bartok’s Concerto for Orchestra and Debussy’s La Mer, and then find time to premiere a busy piece by a young local composer, and an encore that was demanding in itself; the final Le jardin féérique from Ravel’s Mother Goose ballet.

This was all made possible by the orchestra’s relationship with the young French Canadian conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin, an up-andcomer who has conducted Montreal’s Orchestre Métropolitain since he was 24, and now, at 31, has been appointed music director of the imposing Rotterdam Philharmonic, succeeding Valery Gergiev.

He is, clearly, a superb musician, and a busy, technically adept, conductor. His clear grasp and precisely delineated approach to all the works on show would have gone for nought if the players had not been capable of delivering what he asked, but they rose to the occasion with playing of real precision and a near professional cohesion and style.

The opening La Valse (and what a nerve-racking work with which to open a concert) was a little queasy for few minutes, but soon settled and ended in a wonderful, uninhibited, riot of sound. The Bartok Concerto for Orchestra was amazingly assured, with splendid playing from all sections.

There was some memorable playing from the woodwind in the tricky second movement, sonorous brass in all five movements (what a wonderfully secure horn section) and, apart from some blurring in the scurrying passages in the last movements, terrific string playing.

After an entertaining, energetic piece from local Karlo Margetic, a wonderfully luminous La Mer, a performance of real colour and shading, a quality that was most affecting in the substantial encore, with Ravel’s final scene from Mother Goose possessed of real magic.

What a concert.

John Button  
 
Sydney Symphony Orchestra
6 juillet 2007
Manly Daily, Sydney 13 juillet 2007  

Hammering it home

WHEN Yannick Nézet-Séguin filled in at short notice for Lorin Maazel in the SSO's 2005 season he conducted Bruckner's monumental 8th symphony from memory.

The 31-year-old Canadian took Australia by storm and went on that same year to make an enormous impression in Europe with his debut there, culminating in the recent announcement that he is taking over from Russian superstar Valery Gergiev as chief conductor of the Rotterdam Philharmonic.

So his return to Sydney has been eagerly awaited and his performances of Debussy's Images and Mahler's 6th have been all - if not more - than we could have hoped for.

The Mahler, at little under 90 minutes long and mobilising enormous forces, including a hammer to beat out the blows of fate, is a great challenge to conductor and orchestra alike.

The architecture of this work is so intricate and the shifts of mood, dynamic and tempo so essential to its the overall power and logic that any false move on the conductor's part and the whole structure collapses.

Nézet-Séguin avoided this, stamping his mark on the work from the stabbing and relentless opening by the cellos and basses.

This was a muscular but sensitive reading with the tragedy and at times shrill irony of the outer movements and scherzo beautifully counterbalanced by the pastoral yearning mood of the andante, with its horn calls and use of cowbells.

The orchestra was in magnificent form with the musicians obviously enjoying their collaboration with this dynamic young talent.

Robert Johnson led the eight-strong horn section faultlessly and the percussion department was barely rested with Mahler's rich soundscope using various bells (on stage and off), celeste,
glockenspiels and drums.

Hearing a Mahler symphony live is always special but an exceptional performance like this is an experience that lives with the listener for a long time.

Steve Moffatt  
 
Sydney Symphony Orchestra
4 juillet 2007
Sydney Morning Herald 7 juillet 2007  

Ah, Yannick, he does it well

THERE can’t have been all that many performances as energised as this one.

Yannick Nézet-Séguin injected vivid immediacy into Mahler’s Sixth Symphony from opening winding-up bars of the march, to the moment where the final pizzicato falls lifeless to the floor. He is a terrific young conductor. But let’s give further credit where it is due. For that dear old thing. our 75-year old Sydney Symphony, was radiant all evening, playing with rounded fine balance in soft or loud passages.

Mahler’s first movement is monumental but conventional, juxtaposing a vigorous march with a second theme. It even reverts to the classical habit of repeating the exposition.

In the development the colours become individualised and glowing - a solo violin against horn, distant bells - before building to a wildly exultant close. Nézet-Séguin reverses the original published order of the inner movements in line with what most now believe was Mahler’s intention. This draws attention to a link between the first movements obsessive major chord that keeps darkening to minor, and a more subtle version of the same shift in the theme of the Andante. This was a movement of magically serene tones with horn, harp, and cor anglais sounds wafting on the winds of eternity.

After a highly contrasted Scherzo, by turns terrifying and childlike, it was the fascination of the sprawling complex finale, punctuated by two blows from a magnificent Thor-like hammer, wich was most mesmeric.

Peter McCallum  
 
Sydney Symphony Orchestra
28 juin 2007
Manly Daily, Sydney 6 juillet 2007  

Nigth to mark our heritage

ON the day vhen the Sydney Opera House joined the Acropolis and Taj Mahal on Unesco's World Heritage List, it was apt that this concert should be directed primarily at the next
generation.

The music could not have been better for such a historic occasion with a rarelyheard complete performance of Debussy's Images capping off a program which featured a truly awe-inspiring
performance of Richard Meale's Very High Kings, complete with blazing organ, six trumpets placed in the gallery and a doofa level to delight the youngest ears.

Young Canadian conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin last seen in Sydney filling in for Lorin Maazel with a majestic perfomance of Bruckner's 8th symphony, injected just the right amount of energy to keep things swinging along.

Haydn's London symphony - his last at No 104 - was an ambitious work for its time, calling for 60 players and prompting a contemporary critic to label it “grand but very noisy”.

It's difficult to imagine what he would have made of Meale's piece, written in 1968 and inspired by a letter Christopher Columbus wrote to his sponsors, King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella of Spain.

A huge heroic chord from the organ sets the scene for this 15-minute voyage which features a big orchestra, including no less than two tubas, three trombones, two pianos and a sizeable range of percussion.

Perhaps this explains why the piece had not been performed in Sydney for almost 40 years, but as composer-broadcaster Andrew Ford said in his introduction to the work, Australia is not good when it comes to revisiting new pieces - they get premiered and then disappear into the ether.

The same cannot be said of composers like Debussy whose works regularly find their way on to concert programs. But neither 75-year-old Meale nor Ford could recall ever having seen a complete performance of Images and Nézet-Séguin had never conducted it before.

This seems extraordinary. Perhaps it's time to restore it to its rightful place up there with La Mer and L'après-midi d'un faune.

Steve Moffatt  
 
Sydney Symphony Orchestra
27 juin, 2007
Sydney Morning Herald 30 juin, 2007  

Meet the music

(…) Yannick Nézet-Séguin, the focused and energised young conductor who gave such a memorable performance at short notice in 2005 when he stood in for Lorin Maazel, brought a lovingly concentrated sense of balance to these superbly orchestrated textures. Debussy’s imagination for sound is astonishing - rich, divided string chords, gently lapping horn chords, or a solo viola pushed up against trumpet solos to provide woody depth to a golden une - and under Nézet-Séguin the Sydney Symphony allowed its natural timbral refinement to rise to the surface.

But wait, there’s more. Nézet-Séguin had opened with a performance of Haydn’s last symphony, No. 104, driven by the care, shaping and colour that any pianist playing Haydn would bring as a matter of course, but of which conductors are so often negligent. This concert displayed the best playing from the Sydney Symphony this year. (…)

Peter McCallum  
 
Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
11 juin 2007
American Record Guide Septembre/Octobre 2007  

Ever since it was founded 27 years ago, the Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal (OMGM) unofficially has been known as the city's "second" orchestra, next to the Montreal Symphony. No longer. Montreal now has two first class orchestras. The OMGM's performance on June 11 of Mahler's Symphony No. 6 thrust it decisively into the major leagues. The 65-member orchestra was expanded to about 100, resulting not only in spectacular wails of sound but also in many passages with lovely chamber-music delicacy.

Music Director Yannick Nézet-Séguin exploited the dynamic spectrum to the fullest, from barely audible to terrifyingly loud. He wrung every drop of emotion from the music, with every musician behind him 110%. Tempos were perfectly judged, meter changes adroitly handled, every performance detail in the score meticulously observed. Phrases were lovingly sculpted, and every note had meaning. Mahler's huge structures were given shape and direction, and Nézet-Séguin knew exactly where in each movement to evoke the biggest climax. In addition, he maintained an iron grip on the rhythm while allowing for maximum elasticity of rubato. It was a performance made in heaven.

Special mention must go to Principal Horn Pierre Savoie for his liquid-smooth lyricism and golden tone, to Principal Trumpet Stéphane Beaulac for his sensational high-wire acts, and to Concertmaster Denise Lupien for her solos of aching beauty.

For once a standing ovation was truly deserved, and that's exactly what Nézet­Séguin and his orchestra got. But more tellingly, they also got, through the entire performance, total silence from the audience-87 minutes with nary a cough or sneeze. 2007 is barely half over, but this is almost sure to go down in my book as the "concert of the year".

The OMGM has enjoyed some fine conductors in its short history, notably Agnes Grossmann and Joseph Rescigno, but Quebec­born 32-year-old Nézet-Séguin (who also becomes music director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic in August 2005, succeeding Valery Gergiev) has taken this orchestra to new heights and led it in some truly memorable performances and recordings since becoming music director in 2000. He combines the discipline of Szell, the lyricism of Toscanini, the charisma of Bernstein, and the visceral effect of Solti. "He has it all", remarked Gregory Law, a percussionist with 40 years' experience in the orchestral world. "I've played under Karajan, Lemsdorf, Ozawa, Dutoit, Hollreiser, Inbal, and dozens of other conductors great and small, but Nézet-Séguin is to my mind as good as any of them."

Robert Markow  
 
Scottish Chamber orchestra
20 avril 2007
The Telegraph, London UK   26 Avril 2007  


Yannick Nézet-Séguin is a name to be conjured with. The young Québécois Canadian, who takes over from Valery Gergiev at the Rotterdam Philharmonic next year, has been gathering plaudits in Europe over the past three years, and in this concert was conducting the Scottish Chamber Orchestra for the first time. One imagines that it will not be the last, either.

This was a striking debut, exhilarating, polished and illuminated by a technique that threw even the most familiar music into sharp new relief. The orchestra applauded vigorously at the end, in a way that seemed to go beyond the normal bounds of politesse.

Nézet-Séguin is a physical conductor, not flamboyant but tautly energetic and dynamic in his pointing up of detail, accents and the shaping of musical ideas. He gives a firm impression of knowing what he wants and how to get it, and in Ravel's Le Tombeau de Couperin and Mendelssohn's Fourth Symphony achieved finely finished results of uncommonly arresting quality. (...)

The Ravel fused Baroque sensibility with 20th-century French finesse, fluid in melodic line, animated in its exploration of texture and instrumental timbre. There was no artifice in the way rhythms fluctuated, but rather a natural give and take.

Mendelssohn's Italian Symphony further exemplified Nézet-Séguin's ear for style in a blend of sun-drenched exuberance and reflective solemnity, with a coaxing out of expressive nuances that indicated depth of study, acuteness of imagination and a clear identification with the music's spirit. There is an impressive, mature and fertile talent here.

Geoffrey Norris  

The HERALD, Glasgow, Scotland   23 avril 2007  


Yannick Nézet-Séguin is going to be huge . The dazzling young Canadian conductor, in his debut concert with the SCO on friday night, confirmed impressions from his recent live recording of Bruckner Seven, with his Montreal orchestra, of his ability and stature.

It's not just that he is a fine conductor, with his onstage dynamism, technical control, evident rapport with orchestral musicians and wonderful sense of style. He is an absolute musical life force, in whose hands music galvanises itself and bounds from the page with zest, exuberance, and sheer joy.

The SCO, which clearly loved him, played out of their skins in a version of Ravel's Le Tombeau de Couperin that displayed every nuance of the composer's pristine orchestration, coupled with a glorious sense of line and expressive detail. the man's shaping of the music (a striking feature of his big Bruckner recording) is masterly, a characteristic that marked also his beautifully gauged account of Mendelssohn's Italian Symphony.

He is also - and this racks up his calibre yet a few more notches - a fantastic accompanist. His response to Han-Na Chang's powerhouse, volcanic account of Saint-Saens's First Cello Concerto, which was so spontaneous it would have floored some conductors and left others trailing in the Korean cellist's wake, was electrifyingly immediate and superbly coordinated.

At another emotional extreme, the melting loveliness of the playing he secured from the SCO strings in Chang's heartstopping version of Tchaikovsky's Andante Cantabile was of rare beauty.

It's logical to assume the SCO will pursue Nezet-Seguin for a return visit, but he's increasingly in demand and has just taken on the Rotterdam Phil job in succession to Gergiev. Here's hoping, anyway. The man's a knockout.

Michael Tumelty  

The GUARDIAN, London, UK   20 avril 2007

Classical

The name of Yannick Nézet-Séguin has yet to become a familiar one in this country. The 32-year-old French-Canadian conductor is already an established figure in his homeland. In recent seasons, he has also made a big impression on the continent, where in 2008 he will succeed Valery Gergiev as music director of the Rotterdam Philharmonic. Britain, however, has been slower to catch on; it was only last season that Nézet-Séguin made his UK debut with the Northern Sinfonia, followed up last month by performances with the LPO.

We will be hearing a good deal more from Nézet-Séguin in coming seasons, if his most recent performances in this country are anything to go by. In his debut with the SCO, Nézet-Séguin proved himself to be the genuine article; a conductor with not only the self-confidence and virtuosity that speaks of a maestro in the making, but also with a highly individual approach to the music.

Ravel's Le Tombeau de Couperin suite as concert opener transcended its status as attractive entree with a performance in which quite extraordinary detail was combined with unwavering attention to the clarity of the musical line. The same was true of the multi-faceted account of Mendelssohn's Italian Symphony which closed the concert.

Elsewhere, Nézet-Séguin was an equally astute accompanist, partnering a fiery account of Saint-Saëns' Cello Concerto and a gently mellifluous Tchaikovsky Andante Cantabile from soloist Han-Na Chang.

The audience loved it; so too, judging by the superlative playing, did the orchestra. The SCO management should be angling to have Nézet-Séguin back as soon as possible - while he still has space in his schedule.

Rowena Smith  
 
Orchestre national du Capitole de Toulouse
5 avril 2007
La Dépêche du Midi April 7, 2007  

Classique
Bruckner puissant et raffiné

En s'attaquant à la monumentale Huitième symphonie d'Anton Bruckner, le jeune chef québécois Yannick Nézet-Séguin a lancé un beau défi. Diriger ce répertoire exige en effet autant de technique que de maturité et peu de baguettes, y compris parmi les géants du passé, ont su restituer la profondeur du discours du compositeur autrichien, la spiritualité qui traverse ses grandioses architectures symphoniques. Jeudi soir à la Halle aux Grains, Yannick Nézet-Séguin ne s'est pas contenté de livrer une interprétation techniquement aboutie de la partition (ce qui serait déjà beaucoup), il a manifesté un engagement de tous les instants à la tête d'un Orchestre National du Capitole précis et souple. Dirigeant par cœur (un vrai exploit dans une telle œuvre), il choisit des tempos plutôt sages mais sans lourdeur, anime chaque moment sans laisser retomber la tension, rend justice aux raffinements sonores de la symphonie (dans le sublime adagio notamment) comme à sa puissance. Les solistes du Capitole le suivent sans faiblesse, les dix cors et tubens affirment leur solidité. À 31 ans, le jeune chef mérite bien de succéder à Valery Gergiev, à la tête de l'Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam.

Anne-Marie Chouchan  

classictoulouse.com 7 avril 2007  

De chair et de sang

Une seule oeuvre était inscrite au programme du concert du 5 avril dernier, mais quelle oeuvre ! La plus vaste des partitions de Bruckner, sa 8ème symphonie, élève son architecture monumentale à la manière d'une célébration sacrée. Rarement l'orchestre romantique aura sonné avec autant de plénitude et de solennité. Animé d'une foi sans limite et néanmoins torturé par le doute sur ses propres capacités créatrices, Bruckner remania cette symphonie ainsi qu'il le fit pour la plupart de ses autres partitions. Il en existe donc plusieurs versions qui furent éditées au 20ème siècle, l'une par le musicologue Robert Haas, l'autre par Leopold Nowak.

C'est la version Haas, la plus complète et donc la plus longue, que choisit Yannick Nézet-Séguin. Dirigeant sans partition cette oeuvre immense, le jeune chef québécois réalise là une véritable performance. Précis et enthousiaste, il stimule chaque pupitre de l'Orchestre du Capitole avec un étonnant pouvoir de conviction.

Dès les premières mesures de l'allegro moderato initial, l'auditeur s'embarque pour un long voyage qui abolit le temps. Ce premier volet, complexe, torturé, contrasté, est parcouru de violentes convulsions qui culminent en de gigantesques paroxysmes, toujours bien maîtrisés par le chef. Jamais les fortissimi, nombreux et apocalyptiques, n'écrasent le son. Les cuivres, pourtant nombreux et sonores (pas moins de dix cors, dont quatre « tuben » wagnériens), ne dominent jamais le puissant quintette de cordes. Le scherzo alterne martèlement énergique et rêverie poétique dans une rythmique parfaitement équilibrée. La grande méditation de l'adagio constitue probablement le sommet expressif de toute l'ouvre. Hantée de silences angoissants, elle coule comme un fleuve inexorable, ponctuée d'élans inassouvis.

Dans le final, Yannick Nézet-Séguin déploie toute la magie orchestrale possible, dans un dédale de pistes divergentes qui au terme du voyage convergent vers une coda triomphale, éclatante comme un lever de soleil.

Contrairement à bon nombre d'exécutions plus enveloppées de brumes et de perspectives lointaines, l'interprétation proposée et admirablement défendue par Yannick Nézet-Séguin et les musiciens de la phalange toulousaine est pétrie de chair et de sang, soutenue par une tension et une énergie constantes. De la bien belle ouvrage.

Serge Chauzy  
 
Orchestre Métropolitain du Grand Montréal
19 mars 2007
La Presse 21 mars 2007  

(…) quel génie chez Britten et ses quatre Interludes de l'opéra Peter Grimes. Avec maintes couleurs et subtilités dans le discours, Nézet-Séguin recrée le cadre exact de chaque tableau, depuis les profondeurs de la mer jusqu'à la tempête qui secoue le ciel. (...) Le jeune chef termine avec La Mer, de Debussy. Préparation à un enregistrement ces jours-ci, mais, déjà, réalisation très impressionnante, tour à tour lyrique et rageuse, et toujours détaillée.

Claude Gingras  

The Montreal Gazette 21 mars 2007  

(…) Britten's Four Sea Interludes from Peter Grimes is a fantastically vivid soundscape that the OM captured tenderly. Debussy's La Mer was a classic, if a little obvious, selection. Nezet-Séguin proved himself a capable purveyor of the French tradition. Pierre Mercure's . linked the program together with its scene of Montreal's industrious optimism of the 1940s, and it was a treat to hear playing of such affectionate vibrancy as the OM devoted to Mercure's score.


Kate Mollison  

 
Basel (Bâle), Suisse
Basel Sinfonieorchester
15 mars 2007
Basler Zeitung 16 Mars 2007  

A la fin, les applaudissement fusaient de toutes parts : une ovation du public envers l’orchestre et le chef qui, en retour, applaudissait l’orchestre et vice-versa. (...) ils ont joué de manière si éblouissante, avec des sonorités si brillantes, leur jeu fut si discipliné, de façon si consciemment consistante dans leur dynamique et si vitale dans leur articulation. Bref, comme nous les avions rarement entendus.

Le jeune homme au pupitre qui a réussi une telle performance (...) s’appelle Yannick Nézet-Séguin. Son métier principal est d’être le chef de l’orchestre Métropolitain de Montréal (au Canada) et il est considéré comme une des étoiles montantes parmi les jeunes chefs d’orchestre. (...) Avec cette interprétation propre et nette de l'oeuvre (Dvorak: Symphonie No 6 en ré) dont il a gommé toute la sensiblerie slave, il a démontré que l’on peut métamorphoser un bon orchestre en un ensemble de premier ordre. (…)

Sigfried Schibli  
(Traduction libre : Marie-Elisabeth Morf et Louis Bouchard)
 
London Philharmonic Orchestra, UK
9 mars 2007
Classicalsource.com Mars 2007  

(…) This LPO concert may well have been Nézet-Séguin’s London debut. He left his mark! (…)Debussy’s ‘Faune’ (…) received a compelling performance, which was launched by Celia Chambers’s flute solo. (...) his gestures are demonstrative, he lives every note, yet the ears heard a refined if sensuous account, very suggestive in its light-breeze rustling, fluid phrasing, a suggestion of drama under the surface, and eroticism at the generously moulded but not indulged climax. This strongly atmospheric performance – with rich-sounding harp flourishes
and very sensitive solo strings, vividly detailed yet appropriately ‘hazy’, and with enough emotional ‘distance’ to retain the music’s intangibility – could not have been a more impressive ‘introduction’ to this conductor.

Nézet-Séguin is also an alert accompanist, very much ‘with’ Herbert Schuch’s (…) Beethoven’s poetic Fourth Piano Concerto. (…) Nézet-Séguin elicited woodwind details usually submerged by either the soloist or the strings. (…) This was, (…) especially in the first movement, a reading that made one listen and think. Nézet-Séguin has keen ears (he seems to like highlighting the violas’ lines); if he hears something not quite as it should be (or as he wishes) he pounces
on it with a technical acumen that puts things right – cliché: ‘he knows what he wants and how to get it’. One also senses that Nézet-Séguin likes to leave something in reserve for the concert itself; he has the ability to make things happen on the night, and the members of the LPO certainly seemed to be hanging on his every gesture. (…)

Dvořák’s Sixth Symphony was vibrant and alive in the most positive way. (…) With the finale, (…) came (…) something of the Bohemian outdoors (…) an infectious swing informed the music, pointed rhythms sparkled and there was a drive that was inexorable rather than hard-driven.

Colin Anderson  
 
Toronto Symphony Orchestra
14 février 2007
Toronto Star 15 février 2007  

With one star snowed in, another steps in (...) Nézet-Séguin brought out the full sensuousness of Debussy's music in L'Après-midi d'un faune and La Mer, earning a well-deserved roar of approval from the audience. (...)

John Terauds  
 
Alexander Dobson, baryton
Yannick Nézet-Séguin, piano
3 février 2007
Scena Musicale Online 13 février 2007  

(...) Dobson's interpretation is powerful in a youthful, extroverted, heart-on-sleeve, dramatic, even operatic sort of way, appropriate for a singer still in his early 30's. (...) He was helped in no small way by conductor Yannick Nézet-Séguin at the keyboard. (...) his playing was fresh, crisp, assured, well paced, and above all very much alive, (...) Nézet-Séguin was ever the supportive colleague, breathing the music with the soloist. Kudos to him for not doing anything flashy to take the spotlight away, yet he was always there to offer sympathetic support. The eighty minutes went by in such a flash that I almost didn't want it to end. Let's hope there will be many more opportunities to hear these two young artists collaborate in the future.

Joseph So  
 
Orchestre National du capitole de Toulouse
1er janvier 2007
ClassicToulouse.com 2 janvier 2007  

Le désormais traditionnel concert du Nouvel An de l'Orchestre du Capitole était dirigé, pour la seconde fois consécutive, par le jeune maestro québécois Yannick Nézet-Séguin. Et l'on reste confondu, non seulement par le talent de cet artiste, tout fraîchement nommé à la tête de l'Orchestre Philharmonique de Rotterdam où il remplacera rien moins que Valery Gergiev en 2008, mais aussi par la formidable sympathie qui émane de ce personnage. Présentant avec un naturel fait de décontraction, d'humour et d'assurance, l'ensemble du programme, il met le public de la Halle dans sa poche en l'espace d'une seconde.(…) Richard Strauss et les suites pour orchestre de son Chevalier à la Rose donnent à l'orchestre l'occasion de montrer la rutilance de ses timbres et la puissance de ses cordes. (…) Mais l'enthousiasme d'un public comblé ne pouvait s'apaiser que par des bis que ces artistes (YNS et Emma Bell, soprano) ont volontiers donnés. (…) Encore deux moments inoubliables. Et parce qu'il fallait bien conclure, Yannick Nézet-Séguin attaqua la célèbre Marche de Radetzki, dirigeant autant l'orchestre qu'un public alors aux anges.

Robert Pénavayre  

La Dépêche du Midi 2 janvier 2007  

(…) Aussi à l'aise au micro qu'au pupitre, le jeune maestro québécois, qui dirigeait le concert du nouvel an toulousain pour la deuxième fois, sait communiquer son enthousiasme, son plaisir à diriger les œuvres de ses compositeurs favoris. Extraits d'opéras de Mozart et Richard Strauss, trois lieder de ce dernier, œuvres plus légères de Johann Strauss fils et Franz Lehar : le programme de ce concert festif était pourtant copieux et très délicat à mettre en place. Jouer la grande suite de l'opéra « Le Chevalier à la Rose » exige en effet d'un orchestre autant de virtuosité que d'élégance du style. Sous la baguette de Yannick Nézet-Séguin, les musiciens du Capitole ont dominé ces pages avec brio, restituant à la fameuse valse une séduction rythmique irrésistible. (…).

Anne-Marie Chouchan